Friday, August 6, 2010

Judicial News

Kagan Sworn Into U.S. Supreme Court

Elana Kagan was sworn in on Saturday, August 8, 2010 as the fourth woman to ever serve on the United States Supreme Court. Justice Kagan takes the spot vacated by Justice John Paul Stevens, who retired. She is expected to have a similar liberal bent.

There are now three women on the Supreme Court. Here's an Associated Press article by Mark Sherman commenting on the possible impact of the new makeup of the Court: http://www.lasvegassun.com/news/2010/aug/08/3-women-on-high-court-historic-but-impact-unclear/


Ciavarella Given February 2011 Trial Date

According to an August 6, 2010 article by Dave Janoski in Scranton's The Times-Tribune, the criminal jury trial on the bribery, extortion, and racketeering charges against former Luzerne County Judge Mark A. Ciavarella has been scheduled to begin with jury selection on February 7, 2010 before Judge Edwin M. Kosik in the U.S. Federal District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania.

Here's a link to the article: http://thetimes-tribune.com/news/ciavarella-jury-selection-in-february-1.926306

CHART YOUR COURSE - A CELEBRATION OF LIFE, TRAVEL, & FAMILY


Chart Your Course
A Celebration of Life, Travel, & Family

Sunday September 12, 2010
Radisson Hotel - Scranton

12pm to 3:30pm

Tickets: $50 or $350 for a table of 8.


CHART YOUR COURSE--A CELEBRATION OF LIFE, TRAVEL & FAMILY is an event for Crossing the Finish Line, a non-profit organization that assists young adult cancer patients, ages 24 to 50, and their families by giving them a “break from cancer.”

This organization offers a retreat from the unyielding physical and emotional demands of cancer treatment – a hopeful respite during the throes of a courageous battle – by providing a one week all-expense paid excursion to homes and resorts in Orlando, the Poconos, the Jersey Shore, California, and North Carolina.

Many families from our immediate area have been recipients of these travel experiences along with 821 families from PA, NJ, and Delaware.

The event promises a 3 course luncheon at the Radisson along with an exciting raffle with great prizes. The Keynote speaker is Suzanne Fisher Staples author of the award winning Under the Persimmon Tree.

Marci Schankweiler, the Crossing the Finish Line Founder/President and 2010 recipient of the National People Magazine/MLB Stars Among Us Award will also speak along with 2 local women who have received respite travel from Crossing the Finish Line.

To understand the lasting effects of this fantastic organization, please visit this link for a local woman’s story and slide show http://www.crossingthefinishline.org/sailor-detail.asp?id=24

Please support this great cause by attending the event, sponsoring the event, giving a prize for the raffle, or making a donation. For more information on the Chart Your Course Fundraiser visit http://gallery.crossingthefinishline.org/goto/chartyourcourse ; email chart_your_course@verizon.net or call 570-498-2595.

In the alternative you can forward your request for sponsorship, donation, raffle prize, or your request for tickets to my attention at Foley, Cognetti, Comerford, Cimini & Cummins, 507 Linden Street, Suite 700, Scranton, PA 18503. Checks can be made out to "Crossing the Finish Line."


As over 300 people have been sent invitations to purchase tickets to this event, it is anticipated that this will be a well-attended event by members of the local community. A sponsorship of this event will therefore also turn out to be a worthwhile advertising effort in support of a great cause.


Thanks for your consideration of this request for your support.

Wednesday, August 4, 2010

GUEST POST: Recent Superior Court Cases Handed Down on Learned Intermediary Rule

I received permission from Attorney James Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Dechert LLP law firm to reprint the below July 30, 2010 post from his Drug and Device Law Blog, an excellent resource for continuing updates on that topic:

NEW DEFENSE LEARNED INTERMEDIARY WINS IN PENNSYLVANIA

This week the Superior Court of Pennsylvania (the intermediate appellate court) issued two new opinions on warning causation in the context of the learned intermediary rule. Cochran v. Wyeth, Inc., ___ A.2d ___, No. 2838 EDA 2008, slip op. (Pa. Super. July 27, 2010), and Owens v. Wyeth, No. 185 EDA 2009, slip op. (Pa. Super. July 26, 2010) (memorandum).

Both of these cases arise from the few remaining fen-phen cases in Philadelphia County, which involve primary pulmonary hypertension as the claimed injury. Obviously, Cochran is the more important of the two, because it will be published, and is precedential.

Cochran involved a peculiar warning claim. The plaintiff conceded that the warnings regarding primary pulmonary hypertension were adequate. Instead she claimed that the warnings about valvular heart disease (VHD) - a condition she admittedly never contracted - were inadequate, and that had the prescribing physician been warned of that risk (as opposed to PPH), he would not have prescribed the drug.

Obviously, opening up the entire warning to inadequacy attacks, regardless of the injury actually suffered, would have been a major increase in the scope of liability. Fortunately the Superior Court didn't buy the theory:

Here, [defendant] allegedly breached its duty in failing to disclose the risk of VHD, and Appellant’s injury was PPH. The risk of VHD did not develop into the actual injury of VHD. Although [the prescriber] testified in his deposition that he would not have prescribed [the drug] to Appellant had he known of the risk of VHD, this does not alter the fact that [defendant] failed to disclose the risk of VHD and Appellant suffered from PPH. In these circumstances, the relationship between the legal wrong (the failure to disclose the risk of VHD) and the injury (PPH) is not directly correlative and is too remote for proximate causation. Therefore, as a matter of law, there is no proximate, causal connection between [defendant's] failure to disclose the risk of VHD and Appellant’s specific injury.

Cochran, slip op. at 14-15.

In Owens - which as an unpublished opinion is neither precedential nor even citable in Pa. state court - the prescriber knew all about the risk of PPH. He testified he would have prescribed notwithstanding a black box (which wasn't on the drug at the time) because the risk of a fatal obesity-related disease (diabetes) was much worse. Slip op. at 8-9.

Owens also had the VHD/PPH issue, but the physician testimony didn't support but for (as opposed to the proximate causation rationale in Cochran) causation. Slip op. at 11.

Owens also affirmed dismissal of three novel claims. The first was "negligent marketing," which the Superior Court limited strictly to overpromotion:

Appellant next argues that her claim for “negligent marketing” is cognizable under Baldino v. Castagna, 478 A.2d 807 (Pa. 1984). Indeed, our Supreme Court has recognized a cause of action against a drug manufacturer when over-promotion of a drug effectively nullifies adequate warnings. See Baldino, 478 A.2d at 810. However, in her complaint, Appellant did not make any averments that [defendant] marketed [the drug] in a manner that negated its warnings concerning [the drug's] risks. Therefore, Appellant’s alleged “negligent marketing” claim does not fit within the rubric of Baldino’s over-promotion cause of action, and fails to state a claim upon which relief could be granted.Owens, slip op. at 12-13.

The second novel claim to bite the dust was “negligent failure to withdraw [the drug] from the market” - a failure to recall claim. The Superior Court joined unanimous precedent in rejecting that theory:

Appellant’s contention lacks merit. In [a prior case], this Court refused to recognize a duty to retrofit a product. Following the natural direction . . ., this Court is persuaded by the majority of modern jurisdictions that have decided not to impose a common law duty to recall on a manufacturer. We conclude, accordingly, that in Pennsylvania, a drug manufacturer does not have a duty to withdraw or recall a prescription drug from the market.Owens, slip op. at 13 (citations omitted).

The third novel claim was "negligent failure to test":

Pennsylvania law has not recognized an independent tort for negligent failure to test. In fact, this Court has held that the claim for negligent failure to test is not a viable cause of action recognized by our courts.Owens, slip op. at 14 (citation and quotation marks omitted).

--Posted By Bexis to Drug and Device Law at 7/30/2010 08:00:00 AM

Another Decision in Favor of Consolidation Out of Luzerne County

On July 29, 2010, Judge Tina Polachek-Gartley issued a single Order in the companion cases of Mitkowski v. Nationwide, No. 582-Civil-2010 (Luz. Co. July 29, 2010, Gartley, J.) and Mitkowski v. Stefanec, No. 17284 - Civil - 2008 (Luz. Co. July 29, 2010, Gartley, J.) that served to consolidate the Plaintiff's UIM claim with the Plaintiff's claim against the tortfeasor.

The Motion to Consolidate was filed by the UIM carrier, Nationwide Insurance. In the Order, Judge Gartley noted that the two causes of action arose out of the same occurrence, i.e. the motor vehicle accident, and that each case had factual questions relevant to the other case.

This raises the number to four (4) in terms of Luzerne County decisions in favor of the consolidation of Post-Koken claims. There are no Luzerne County decisions in favor of the severance of these types of claims.

Anyone desiring a copy of this Order may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.


I thank Attorney Shawna R. Laughlin of the Moosic, PA law firm of Thomas J. Kelley & Associates and Attorney Neil O'Donnell of the O'Donnell Law Offices in Kingston, PA for bringing this case to my attention

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Former Luzerne County Judge Michael T. Toole Benefits from Recent U.S. Supreme Court Ruling

According to an August 2, 2010 article by Dave Janoski in the Scranton Times-Tribune, the recent United States Supreme Court decision ruling the honest services fraud statute unconstitutionally vague has erased a fraud count that could have sent former Luzerne County Judge Michael T. Toole to federal prison for up to 20 years. According to the article, the former judge is now only facing a tax evasion count that could result in a lesser sentence.

For more information, here is a link to the article:
http://thetimes-tribune.com/news/u-s-supreme-court-ruling-erases-charge-against-former-luzerne-judge-toole-1.917904

Monday, August 2, 2010

Superior Court Rejects Application of Regular Use Exception to U.S. Post Office Garage/Maintenance Worker

In a July 29, 2010 decision in the case of Dixon v. GEICO, 2010 WL 2950318 (Pa.Super. July, 29, 2010, Bender, J. Ott, J., Kelly, J. - Opinion by Kelly, J.) , the Pennsylvania Superior Court reversed a trial court decision which applied the "regular use" exclusion to preclude UIM coverage for a garage man employed by the U.S. Post Office injured while delivering a repaired postal vehicle.

The injured party worked for the U.S. Postal Service at a repair and maintenance facility in Philadelphia as a garage man. His duties included, in part, the maintenance of the postal vehicles and driving them to various post offices to then be used by the mailmen. He was involved in an accident while driving a postal vehicle and in the process of delivering the vehicle to a post office.

The tortfeasor paid his $15,000 liability limits. The U.S. Post Office was exempt from having UIM coverage and did not otherwise purchase any UIM coverage on the vehicle.

The injured party therefore turned to his own personal automobile insurance policy with GEICO for underinsured (UIM) motorists coverage. GEICO denied the UIM claim under its "regular use" exclusion which precluded UIM coverage to an insured "When using a motor vehicle furnished for the regular use of you, your spouse, or a relative who resides in your household, which is not insured under this policy."

In its ruling the Superior Court reiterated the findings of prior decisions that the "regular use" exclusion was not against public policy and did not violate Pennsylvania's Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law.

The Superior Court disagreed with the trial court's finding that there were no issues of material fact on the extent of the use of the vehicle by the injured party. The Superior Court noted that there were pending factual issues on whether the injured party's use of the vehicle was regular or "habitual" as well as whether the vehicle was, under the terms of the exclusion, "furnished or available" for regular use by the injured party. The case was therefore remanded back to the trial court for a jury determination on these coverage issues.

In so ruling, the Dixon court noted that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court was considering a similar UIM "regular use" exclusion issue in the still not decided case of Williams v. GEICO, 986 A.2d 45 (Pa. 2009), which involves a police officer injured while driving a police vehicle.

Here's a link to the Superior Court's decision in Dixon v. GEICO:
http://www.pacourts.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/a19034_10.pdf


I send thanks to Attorney Scott Cooper, Esq. of the Harrisburg firm of Schmidt Kramer for publicizing this case on LinkedIn.com.

Sunday, August 1, 2010

The Curse of Snooki

Please allow me to digress from the law to come to the defense of my (former) home state, New Jersey. Yes, I am originally from New Jersey (don’t tell anyone). Let me clarify as I have done in the past and will likely do for the rest of my life, I am from SOUTH JERSEY.

New Jersey as a whole is currently under attack from a barrage of trashy reality shows, leaving the rest of the nation with misguided perceptions of the Garden State. I ask that when you watch those shows (we know you do), that you think the following:

Jersey Shore: NORTH JERSEY

The Real Housewives of New Jersey: NORTH JERSEY

Jerseylicious: NORTH JERSEY

All of these shows are set and cast in North Jersey. Draw a line across the state at Trenton (around Exit 7A on the Turnpike), look above that line and over by the New York City area. Heck, the people in Jersey Shore are mainly New Yorkers thrown together in a house in a North Jersey shore town.

Now, I don’t necessarily disagree that these New Jersey reality shows might accurately depict a certain element of people from North Jersey—I just want it known that things are different, better, in South Jersey where I’m from (I mean,really, do you think a South Jersey guy like myself could ever get away with calling himself “The Situation”?).

Sure, we may have had our share of bright, yellow Camaro Iroc Zs and guys with more gold around their necks than Fort Knox in South Jersey. Yes, there is a certain element in South Jersey that will kick you at least three times when you're down and out in a fight (but not five times, like in North Jersey). By and large, however, things are much more pleasant in South Jersey.

Think of South Jersey as being made up of sprawling, green suburbia and farmland compared to the dingy, on-top-of-each other rowhouses in North Jersey in the shadows New York City and the oil refineries and chemical plants off the Turnpike and Garden State Parkway.

Think of the beautiful southern New Jersey shorelines in family-friendly Brigantine, Longport, and Ocean City compared to (Yuck!) Seaside Heights, Point Pleasant and other North Jersey Beaches.

Think of nice roadways through the Pine Barrens in South Jersey lined with vegetables stands overflowing with Jersey tomatoes, peaches, blueberries and corn compared to the monstrous five (5) lanes in each direction Garden State Parkway in North Jersey.

To further clarify the distinction, note that South Jersey primarily has Phillies and Eagles fans compared to the obnoxious Mets, Yankees, and Giants fans of North Jersey.

So, please, when you are caused to think of New Jersey by these reality shows or any other negative publicity, remember that there’s North Jersey (what you’re negatively thinking of about Jersey) and South Jersey.

Aaaah, I feel better now—thanks for letting me get that off my chest. Speaking of chests, I read that Snooki was thrown in jail last night. One North Jersey character down, many more to go.