Friday, June 30, 2023

Petition To Transfer Based on Doctrine of Forum Non Conveniens Granted


In the case of Mitchell v. Gentry, No. 22-CV-2951 (C.P. Lacka. Co. March 3, 2023 Nealon, J.), the court granted a Petition to Transfer Venue filed by the Defendants in a motor vehicle accident.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff was a Lycoming County resident who was injured in a Lycoming County accident.  The records also revealed to the court that all of the Plaintiff’s medical treatment occurred in Lycoming County.

The Defendant driver was a New York motorist and his employer was a company incorporated in the State of New York and which maintained its principal place of business in New York.

The New York Defendants filed a Preliminary Objection asserting improper venue in Lackawanna County since the Defendant motorist could not be served in Lackawanna County, given that the Defendant driver’s employer did not regularly conduct business in Lackawanna County, and given that the cause of the action arose in Lycoming County.

In the alternative, the Defendants filed a Petition to Transfer Venue to Lycoming County under Pa. R.C.P. 1006(d)(1) on the grounds that the litigation and trial of this matter in Lackawanna County would be oppressive to the parties and witnesses.

Based upon the totality of the circumstances, the court found that Lackawanna County was an oppressive forum and, as such, the court granted the Defendant’s Petition to Transfer the case to Lycoming County.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Wednesday, June 28, 2023

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Upholds Immunity of an Employer Where Plaintiff Claims Covered By Worker's Compensation


In the case of Franczyk v. Home Depot, Inc., No. 11 WAP 2022 (Pa. April 19, 2023) (Op. by Wecht, J.) (Todd, C.J, concurring), the court addressed immunity provided to employers in personal injury civil litigation matters given the employer’s exposure to worker’s compensation recoveries.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court confirmed that the worker’s compensation system is a compromise that, in exchange for a no-fault insurance system, employers are granted immunity from tort liability for workplace injuries.

The court reiterated that, where worker’s compensation is available, such compensation is the exclusive remedy for an injured party against their employer.

The worker’s compensation statute precludes virtually any sort of negligence claim against the employer “on account” a physical injury that occurs in a workplace.

In this matter, the court found that a Plaintiff could not sue his employer for allegedly failing to investigate a dog bite that occurred at the place of employment and thereby obstructing the Plaintiff’s ability to bring a claim against the customer who owned the dog.

The court found that the plain language of the exclusivity clause under the Worker’s Compensation Act barred this action.  None of the exceptions were found to apply.

The court otherwise noted that employers have no general duty to protect and preserve the interests of their employees relative to a possible personal injury action.

Given that the Plaintiff in this matter was seeking a recovery of the same damages from the same injury that occurred in a workplace, the claim was found to be precluded from the Worker’s Compensation Act.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Concurring Opinion by Chief Justice Todd can be viewed HERE.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Reed Smith law firm in Philadelphia for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, June 26, 2023

Judge Nealon Give Complaint Drafting Tips


In the case of Dolinak v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. 2021-CV-1643 (C.P. Lacka. Co. June 5, 2023 Nealon J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas reviewed the Rules of Civil Procedure regarding proper Complaint drafting in a case involving alleged weather-related damages allegedly sustained to the home of a State Farm insured.

Relative to the claims presented, the Plaintiff filed a Complaint against State Farm and State Farm filed Preliminary Objections stating that, based upon the allegations of the Complaint, it was not able to confirm exactly whether the Plaintiff was asserting simply a breach of contract claim and/or a bad faith claim.

Judge Nealon reviewed the pertinent Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, and the related case law, regarding Complaint drafting.

The court noted that Pa. R.C.P. 1020 provides that a Plaintiff may state in the Complaint more than one cause of action against the same Defendant and that such claims may be pled in the alternative.

However, under the related case law, a Plaintiff is required to present each claim in a self-sufficient separate count within the Complaint, which count is required to include allegations of facts in support of the particular claim asserted and the relief sought.

Here, the court noted that, even reviewing the allegations of Plaintiff’s Complaint as a whole, the Complaint did not provide State Farm with sufficient notice of the claims against which the carrier was required to defend.

As such, the court sustained the Preliminary Objections asserted by the Defendant but allowed the Plaintiff the right to file an Amended Complaint in which the Plaintiff was required to identify the claims asserted and the damages demanded in conformity with the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Federal Court Finds That UIM Bad Faith Claim Was Plausibly Pled


In the case of Perhosky v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., No. 2:23-CV-00025 (W.D. Pa. May 4, 2023 Lenihan, J.), the court denied a Defendant’s carrier’s Motion to Dismiss a Plaintiff’s bad faith claim over the carrier’s alleged failure to pay UIM benefits after the Plaintiff was injured in a motor vehicle accident.

The court found that, based upon the pleadings in the Complaint, the Plaintiff had pled a plausible bad faith claim.

The court noted that the Plaintiff averred that the Defendant carrier failed to provide any explanation for its offer to settle the Plaintiff’s claim for $25,000.00. The Plaintiff also asserted that the carrier did not conduct any investigation and did not refer the Plaintiff to an independent medical examination.

In so ruling, the court rejected the Defendant carrier’s arguments that the Plaintiff did not take into account that the Defendant had factored into its evaluation and liability credit of $100,000.00 from the Plaintiff’s prior settlement with other insurance carriers. 

The court also rejected the Defendant’s argument that the bad faith claim was simply based upon the Plaintiff’s disagreement with the carrier’s evaluation and that the carrier had not yet completed its investigation.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (June 8, 2023).

Friday, June 23, 2023

Summary Judgment Granted In Slip and Fall Case Where Plaintiff's Evidence Was Deficient


In the case of McClure v. Love’s Travel Stops, No. 1:21-CV-00334-YK (M.D. Pa. May 23, 2023 Kane, J.), the court granted the Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a slip and fall case.

According to the Opinion, a tractor trailer driver pulled his vehicle into the parking lot of a Love’s store to purchase fuel and food. It was not raining at the time.

The Plaintiff entered and exited the store without any problem before the incident. He confirmed that he did not see any type of liquid on the ground where he fell while entering and exiting the store.

After fueling his tractor trailer, the Plaintiff retrieved an empty cup from his truck and returned to the store. Using the same entrance that he had previously used to enter and exit the store, the Plaintiff entered the store and fell.

In this Motion for Summary Judgment, the Defendant asserted that the Plaintiff admitted during his testimony that he did not know what caused him to fall.

The Plaintiff argued that he only did not know the identity of the particular substance that caused him to fall. The Plaintiff maintained that the store manager wiped up a black, foreign substance from the store near the store’s diesel entrance, which was an area away from the area where he fell.

According to his deposition testimony, after he fell, the Plaintiff felt around on the floor with his hands but did not recall seeing anything in the area where he fell. The Plaintiff also testified that he went to the bathroom after he fell and that, when he returned to the location of his fall, he did not recall seeing anything there on the floor.

The store manager also testified that he examined the area where the Plaintiff allegedly fell and found that the floor was not slippery in this location. The store manager also denied cleaning up any black substance off any part of the floor.

The court also noted that the Plaintiff did not have any information or facts to offer in terms to how long any alleged slippery substance was on the floor in the area where he fell prior to the accident or how long the area was allegedly slippery.

Judge Kane reviewed the law of Pennsylvania regarding actual and constructive notice of an allegedly dangerous condition existing on a Defendant’s premises. After reviewing that law in detailed fashion, the court concluded that the Plaintiff failed to produce sufficient evidence of any actual or constructive notice on the part of the Defendant of any allegedly dangerous condition that caused the Plaintiff to fall.

In the end, the court granted summary judgment.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Patrick J. Murphy of the Scranton office of the BBC Law, LLP for bringing this case to my attention.

Summary Judgment Granted in Slip and Fall Case -- Mere Happening of an Incident Does Not Equal Liability


In the case of Harkins v. Three Monkeys Cronydon, Inc., No. 2019-CV-03333 (C.P. Bucks Co. April 18, 2023 McHugh, J.), the court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion to explain its rationale to the Superior Court in terms of its entry of summary judgment in this slip and fall case.

In its Opinion, the trial court emphasized that the existence of a harmful condition and/or the happening of an accident, in and of themselves, do not automatically establish a breach of the landowner’s breach of care.

The court found that the Plaintiff had failed to provide evidence to specifically identify exactly what caused the Plaintiff to fall. It was also noted that the Plaintiff failed to provide evidence that the Defendant knew or should have known about any alleged condition and/or that the Defendant failed to exercise reasonable care to protect invitees from an alleged danger.

With respect to the Plaintiff’s offer of expert testimony on the liability issues, the court noted that the admission of such testimony was at the discretion of the trial court. In this matter, the court found that the Plaintiffs’ expert’s opinion was deficient, and that the opinion offered by the expert was lacking any specialized knowledge beyond that of a layperson. The court also found that the expert failed to provide sufficient scientific authority to support the expert’s opinions.

With regards to the Plaintiff’s claim of spoliation relative to any video surveillance of the incident, the court found that the deletion of video surveillance footage under the Defendant’s standard policy did not constitute spoliation because there was no evidence presented to suggest that the footage that was deleted was relevant in determining the case of the Plaintiff’s fall.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (June 13, 2023).

Thursday, June 22, 2023

Issues of Fact Prevent Entry of Summary Judgment in Slip and Fall Case


In the case of Spruill v. Dreher Ave. Holdings, No. 6444-CV-2021 (C.P. Monroe Co. April 17, 2023 Zulick, J.), the court denied a property owner’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a slip and fall case after finding that issues of material fact existed as to the cause and location of the ice and whether that condition allegedly caused the Plaintiff to fall.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff slipped and fell in her employer’s parking lot after leaving a Christmas party.

After discovery, the Defendant moved for summary judgment, claiming that the hills and ridges doctrine barred the Plaintiff’s claim.

The court noted that the Plaintiff had produced photographs and testimony that ice had accumulated around a drainpipe and then spread across the sidewalk, went over the curb, and ran across the surface of the parking lot.

The court ruled that the hills and ridges doctrine did not preclude liability where an icy condition was allegedly caused by a drainpipe or some other cause like a defective hydrant or water pipe.

Judge Zulick noted that, where a specific, localized patch of ice existed in the area that was otherwise free of ice and snow, the presence of the hills and ridges necessary to support the hills and ridges defense is not established.

The court found that material questions of fact and testimonial differences as to the cause and location of the ice, as well as whether that condition caused the Plaintiff to fall, required the court to deny the Motion for Summary Judgment.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (May 16, 2023).