Tuesday, August 31, 2021

Tort Talk CLE in Lackawanna County Set for September 14th (Non-Members Welcome)


 

UIM Rejection Form for Commercial Auto Policy Found Valid


In the case of Eberly v. Firemen’s Ins. Co. of Washington, D.C., No. 5:20-CV-05471 (E.D. Pa. July 13, 2021 Leeson, J.), Judge Joseph Leeson of the Eastern District Federal Court granted a Defendant carrier’s Motion to Dismiss in a UIM case.

This matter involved a commercial auto policy.  The Plaintiff challenged the UIM rejection form on the basis that the document did not contain a policy number and because the document did not indicate the authority of the signatory to execute the document on behalf of the commercial insured.     

The court found that the form executed by the Plaintiff rejecting equal UIM coverage under a commercial automobile insurance policy was valid where that form was signed by the corporate insured’s owner, who was the only individual who had ever acted as a signatory for the company. 

The court also found the form to be valid where the relevant policy number was listed in an attached schedule to the coverage forms.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (July 29, 2021).

Source of image: Photo by Andrea Piacquadio from Pexels.com.

UIM Bad Faith Complaint Dismissed For Conclusory Allegations


In the case of O’Brien v. Liberty Mutual Ins., No. 21-CV-01234, 2021 WL3203405 (E.D.Pa. July 28,2021 Baylson, J.), the court granted a carrier’s Motion to Dismiss a Plaintiff UIM bad faith claim for failure to plead beyond conclusory allegations.

The court noted that the Plaintiff did not provide sufficient factual allegations under which the court could reasonably infer the Defendant’s ill-will. The court found that the claims of bad faith described in the complaint were overly vague and did not contain any specific factual allegations that suggested bad faith.

For example, the Plaintiff did not plead specific facts to suggest how the Defendant forced the Plaintiffs to file the lawsuit. Nor did the complaint give facts in support of claims of false pretexts and invasive tactics utilized by the insurance company.

The court noted that, basically, the sole factual allegation in the Complaint regarding the Defendant’s action was that the Defendant denied the Plaintiff’s claim for UIM benefits.

Although the court granted a Motion to Dismiss, the court also allowed the Plaintiff leave to amend.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK. 


I send thanks to Attorney Lee Applebaum of the Philadelphia Law Firm of Fineman, Krekstein & Harris, and the writer of the excellent Pennsylvania and New Jersey Insurance Bad Faith Case Law Blog, for bringing this case to my attention.

Source of image:  Photo by Sora Shimazaki from Pexels.com.

Monday, August 30, 2021

UIM Coverage Election Forms Found To Be Valid


In the case of Eckman v. Encompass Home & Auto Ins. Co., No. 1904038 KSM (E.D. Pa. July 30, 2021 Marston, J.), the court ruled that an insured was not entitled to underinsured motorist coverage equal to the bodily injury liability coverage limits under the subject automobile insurance policy where the statutory coverage election forms, as well as the insured’s initial application for the insurance policy, all provided sufficient evidence under Pennsylvania statutory law to demonstrate that the insured intended to purchase a lower amount of UIM coverage.

As such, the Defendant carrier’s Motion for Summary Judgment was granted and the Plaintiff’s cross Motion for Summary Judgment was denied.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff sought to preclude the coverage forms at issue from consideration by the court. However, the Plaintiff also conceded that, if the UM/UIM coverage forms were admissible, then the carrier would indeed be entitled to summary judgment. The court denied the Motion to Preclude the Documents from Consideration.

The court also ruled that, even if the election forms were excluded, the application for insurance itself constituted sufficient evidence for the court to find that the Plaintiff intended to purchase lower UM/UIM coverage limits.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.

The Court's Opinion on the Plaintiff's motion to preclude the admission of copies of the pertinent documents can be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Aug. 17, 2021).

Source of image: Photo by Scott Graham on Unsplash.com.

Friday, August 27, 2021

Upcoming Tort Talk CLE for Luzerne County (September 9th)

 Below is a reprint of the Ad for the Luzerne County CLE entitled "BACK TO SCHOOL:  A Civil Litigation Update with Tort Talk."

This will be a one hour CLE that you can attend via Zoom or Live (I will be presenting via Zoom).

If you are not able to access the Link to register within the Ad here, please try this LINK to register through the Bar's website.

Thank you for considering this CLE.



Vague Allegations of Recklessness Stricken in a Motor Vehicle Accident Case Out of Beaver County



In the case of Willis v. Tyson, No. 10646-2020 (C.P. Beaver Co. May 24, 2021 Shahen, J.), the court struck allegations of recklessness as insufficient in this motor vehicle accident case.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff alleged that the Defendant driver was operating a vehicle when that vehicle struck the Plaintiff’s occupied parked vehicle. The Plaintiff generally asserted that the Defendant was operating a vehicle at a high rate of speed and in a reckless manner. The Plaintiff otherwise argued that the Defendant driver was negligent in operating a vehicle in a recklessness manner under the totality of the circumstances.

The court reviewed the issue under a Preliminary Objection asserting insufficient specificity of a pleading.

After reviewing the current status of the law of Pennsylvania on the claim of recklessness, including the review of the case of Archibald v. Kemble, 971 A.2d 513 (Pa. Super. 2009), the court in this Willis case noted that, while a condition of the mind may be averred generally, a plaintiff must still plead sufficient facts to establish that the conduct of the Defendant was reckless. In this regard, the Willis court cited the case of Ammlung v. City of Chester, 302 A.2d 491 (Pa. Super. 1973). The court in Willis emphasized that the Ammlung court pointed out that the allowance to aver conditions of the mind generally “was not meant, however, to dispense with the requirement that material facts constituting the conduct of a Defendant also be pleaded.” [citation omitted].

In this case, the court found that the Plaintiff’s allegations regarding the claim of recklessness failed to inform the Defendant as to what conduct was allegedly at issue in terms of an allegation of reckless conduct which would potentially support a claim for punitive damages. The court found that the claims in the Complaint alleging reckless conduct were “fatally vague and uninformative.” As such, the court granted the Defendant’s Preliminary Objections and struck the allegations of the Complaint alleging reckless conduct. 

The court did grant the Plaintiff leave to file a Second Amended Complaint in an effort to secure the deficiencies at issue.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to attorney William C. Robinson, III of the Pittsburgh law firm of Robb Leonard Mulvihill, LLP for bringing this case to my attention.

ARD Can Be Considered a Prior Conviction in Some Contexts


In the case of Davilla v. Dept. of Transp., No. 4478-CV-2020 (C.P. Monroe Co. June 11, 2021 Higgins, J.), the court denied a licensee’s suspension appeal.

This decision is of note given that the court ruled that the licensee’s prior acceptance into the Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition (ARD) Program was properly considered to be a prior conviction under the Motor Vehicle Code for purposes of imposing a civil collateral consequence of his conviction.

According to the Opinion, the licensee previously entered into an ARD Program due to a prior DUI.

While the court noted, based upon Pennsylvania precedent, that prior acceptance into an ARD Program could not be considered to be a prior offense in order to increase a criminal penalty against the licensee, this matter involved a civil proceeding.

The court noted that a license suspension is a collateral civil consequence of a criminal conviction. Accordingly, the court found that the licensee’s prior ARD acceptance was considered a prior conviction under the Motor Vehicle Code for purposes of imposing a civil collateral consequence of his conviction.

As such, the court denied the licensee’s license suspension appeal.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions,” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (July 29, 2021).


Commentary: This decision may raise a question as to whether a DUI Defendant’s acceptance into an ARD Program may count as a criminal conviction for DUI under the Motor Vehicle Code for purposes of determining whether a limited tort Plaintiff falls under an exception to the limited tort rule where the accident involved a DUI Defendant.


Source of image:  Photo by Mathilde Langevin on unsplash.com.