Thursday, August 29, 2013

Judge Minora of Lackawanna County Holds That the Law is Not an Ass

  

In his recent August 27, 2013 decision, in the case of White v. The Medical Protective Company, et.al., No. 2010-CV-7058 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Aug. 27, 2013 Minora, J.), Judge Carmen D. Minora of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas disagreed with Charles Dickens' assessment above in an Opinion addressing a discovery dispute in a medical malpractice action.  
 
According to the Opinion, the discovery dispute arose from an underlying case involving alleged medical malpractice in the delivery and birth of a minor Plaintiff.   That 2003 lawsuit went on to a jury verdict on November 17, 2008 in favor of the Plaintiff in the amount of $20,500,000.00.   That verdict was modified to include delay damages, which increased the verdict to the amount of $27,352,195.21.   This verdict was later affirmed by the Pennsylvania Superior Court.  
 
According to the Opinion, the size of the verdict far surpassed the insurance coverages of the Defendants.  Accordingly, the Defendants assigned their potential causes of action against their insurers and their counsel to the Plaintiff which gave rise to the instant lawsuit before Judge Minora.  
 
Judge Carmen D. Minora
Lackawanna County
Before the Court on this Opinion were disputed Orders issued by the Lackawanna County Special Trial Master.   The specific issue before Judge Minora was the Plaintiff’s Motion to Strike on Procedural Grounds the Defendant’s appeal of the decisions of the Special Trial Master on certain discovery issues.  The particular issue before Judge Minora was whether the Defendant’s appeal was properly filed or was procedurally fatally deficient.
 
The Plaintiff’s argument was that, in order to properly appeal an Order of the Special Trial Master in Lackawanna County, the appellant must present an appeal motion to the designated motions court judge under Lackawanna County Local Rule of Civil Procedure 206.4(c) together with proof of payment of the appropriate fee.  
 
After reviewing Lackawanna County Local Rule 206.4(c) along with Lackawanna County Local Rule 4000.1(b), Judge Minora agreed that the Plaintiff correctly stated the prescribed procedure.  
 
Lackawanna County Local Rule 4000.1(b) provides that “An Order of the Special Trial Master may be appealed de novo by presentation of an appeal motion to the designated Motion Court Judge in accordance with Lacka. Co. R.C.P. 206.4(c) together with proof of payment to the Clerk of Judicial Records of an appeal cost in an amount to be set by the Court from time to time.  The appeal motion shall be filed within ten (10) days of the Order of the Special Trial Master and shall be considered by the Court pursuant to Lacka. Co. R.C.P. 4000.  
 
Judge Minora also stated that, under Lackawanna County Local Rule 206.4(c) as incorporated by reference in Lackawanna County Rule 4000.0(b), one seeking to obtain a Rule to Show Cause in such an appeal must present a Petition to the Motions Court pursuant to Lackawanna County Local Rule 208.3(a) requires the moving party to serve all counsel with a copy of the Motion or Petition that will be presented advising them of a date certain when the presentation will take place and provide, at a minimum, three (3) business days of notice prior to that presentation.  
 
While the Court stated that the Plaintiff’s arguments and positions appeared to be correct, the Court disagreed with the conclusion proposed by the Plaintiff that the appeal was dead and could not be revived. 
 
In reaching this conclusion, Judge Minora noted that it was the Defendant’s contention that they have proceeded in good faith on the appeal but were relying upon an outdated version of the Lackawanna County Local Rules of Civil Procedure that was posted on the Lackawanna County official website.   Judge Minora reviewed the Rules on the website and found it to be an older version that read differently from the current version that was actually in effect, particularly with respect to Local Rule 4001.1.   
 
The Defendants also argued that, in addition to proceeding in good faith, they had, in any event, timely filed their motions on the appeal and paid the appropriate filing fees.  
 
Thus, as stated, the issue before Judge Minora of whether or not the procedural defect resulting from the Defendant’s reliance upon the old Rule was fatal to the appeals.   The Opinion of the court confirmed that it was uncontested by the Plaintiff that the Defendant’s appeals were timely and that all appropriate fees were paid.  
 
Judge Minora additionally stated that the only prejudice to the Plaintiff’s claims presented would be the need to proceed through the appeals process if the Court ruled in favor of the Defendant.  
 
After reviewing the applicable law, including Pa. R.C.P.  126, entitled "Liberal Construction in Application of Rules," the Court overruled the Plaintiff’s Motion to Strike the Appeals and asserted that the “Plaintiff ha[d] clearly elevated process over substance and overstated the consequences of Defendant’s predicament.”  
 
Under Pa. R.C.P. 126, which Judge Minora construed to also apply to to local rules, it is stated that the Rules of Civil Procedure “shall be liberally construed.”   The rule also states that the “Court at every stage of such action or proceeding may disregard any error or defect of procedure which does not affect the substantial rights of the parties.”  
 
Judge Minora concluded his Opinion with a Dickensian reference by stating that “[c]ontrary to Charles Dickens, the law is not an ass.” [Emphasis in Opinion at p. 12].  
 
Judge Minora further stated that “the trial of a lawsuit is not a sporting event where the substantive legal issues are subordinated to the rule of the game.”  He additionally noted that “procedural rules are not ends in themselves, but means whereby justice as expressed in legal principles is administered; they are not to be exalted to the status of substantive objectives requiring rigid adherence.”  
 
Accordingly, Judge Minora ruled that “the Court should not be astute in enforcing technicalities to defect apparently meritorious claims.”   Ultimately, the Court denied the Plaintiff’s Motion to Strike the Appeal of the Defendants from the Orders of the Special Trial Master. 
 

Anyone wishing to review this interesting Opinion issued by Judge Minora in the case of White v. The Medical Protective, et.al. may click this LINK. 
 
 
ADDITIONAL NOTE:
The Civil Rules Committee of the Lackawanna County Bar Association is currently in the process of reviewing the various Lackawanna County Local Rules in a concerted and purposeful effort to come up with a correct and current version of the same.  
 
Once this process is completed, it is anticipated that the updated version of the Lackawanna County Local Rules will be made publicly available on either the Lackawanna County’s website and/or the Lackawanna Bar Association’s website.  
 
If possible, I will also establish a Link to the Lackawanna County Local Rules from Tort Talk as well.
 




Wednesday, August 28, 2013

Superior Court Addresses Issue of "Occupying" Vehicle Under Household Exclusion

In its recent decision in the case of Swarner v. Mut. Ben. Ins., 2013 Pa. Super. 198 (July 18, 2013), the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed the household exclusion in the context of an application of the Utica Mutual factors as to whether or not an injured party was “occupying” a vehicle at the time of the accident.

According to a summary of this case, the injured party was thrown from one vehicle and then hit by another vehicle while lying unconscious on the road.   The original vehicle was apparently owned by the injured party’s spouse. 

After applying the factors applicable to the test of whether or not a person is “occupying a vehicle,” the court held that the household exclusion did not apply as the insured injured party was lying in the roadway after she ceased to occupy the original vehicle after being thrown from that vehicle during the first collision.

Anyone wishing to review the Swarner decision may click this LINK.

Source:  “Court Summaries” by Timothy L. Clawges, Esquire Pennsylvania Bar News (August 19, 2013).

Monday, August 26, 2013

Judge Terrence R. Nealon Addresses Fair Scope of Expert Report/Opinion Rule

In his August 23, 2013 Opinion in the case of Shields v. Fafard, No. 2009 - CV - 8636 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Aug. 23, 2013 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas denied a Plaintiff's Post-Trial Motion asserting that the defense medical expert was impermissibly allowed to testify beyond the fair scope of his report in an auto accident trial.

After thoroughly reviewing the applicable law on the issue presented, Judge Nealon found, as follows:

  • that the Plaintiff waived the issue by failing to properly lodge an objection during the course of the testimony of the defense medical expert witness;
  • that the defense medical expert's testimony was within the fair scope of his written report such that the Plaintiff was not unfairly surprised by the expert's reasonable explanation of his written words; and,
  • that, "more importantly," the Plaintiff was able to secure expert medical testimony to rebut the testimony of the defense medical expert at issue such that the Plaintiff was not prejudiced by the admission of the defense medical expert's testimony.

Anyone wishing to review this decision by Judge Nealon in the Shields case may click this LINK.


Wednesday, August 21, 2013

Bench Trial Bad Faith Verdict in Favor of Lackawanna County Plaintiff

In his recent August 15, 2013 decision in the case of Davis. v. Fidelity National Insurance Company, No. 2009-CV-6154 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Aug. 15, 2013 Minora, J.), Judge Carmen D. Minora issued a Memorandum and Order at the end of which he entered a verdict in favor of the Plaintiffs under the Bad Faith Act, 42 Pa. C.S. §8371, in the total amount of $2,062,746.59.  

According to the detailed Opinion, the case came before the court as an insurance bad faith and breach of contract action arising out of a title insurance policy.   The parties proceeded to a bench trial after both parties waived their right to a jury trial.  

Judge Carmen D. Minora
Lackawanna County
Concisely, after a thorough review of the facts and the current status of bad faith law in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Judge Minora concluded, in pertinent part, that the evidence before the court showed that the carrier did not have a reasonable basis for taking almost five (5) years to resolve the Plaintiffs’ claim.    The court noted that the carrier took 20 months to complete its investigation and notify the Plaintiff that the claim was covered under their policy.  However, the Defendant was found to have been delayed payment for almost three (3) years thereafter, and, according to the court, only finally tendered an inadequate offer once suit was filed.

The court found that the “extreme delay” found in the record before the court in this case constituted bad faith under 42 Pa. C.S. §8371.   The court found that that inaction of the Defendant carrier to be outrageous and recklessly indifferent to the rights of its insured.  

As such, the court entered a verdict comprising of compensatory and punitive damages that in the above amount.  

Plaintiff’s counsel was Carl J. Guagliardo of the Kingston, Pennsylvania law firm of Selingo & Guagliardo.  
 
Anyone wishing to review this Opinion may click this LINK.

Judge Williamson of Monroe County Addresses Allegations of Recklessness in Complaint

In his recent decisions in the case of Burger v. Jaggers, No. 1858-Civil-2013 (C.P. Monroe Co. July 22, 2013, Williamson, J.), Judge David J. Williamson of the Monroe County Court of Common Pleas addressed a series of Preliminary Objections in a strict liability action.  

According to the Opinion, the case arose out of an incident during which the Plaintiff and the Defendant were on the Defendant’s property to cut up trees.   While the Plaintiff was cutting up a fallen tree, the Defendant allegedly cut down a nearby standing tree, without warning, which fell onto the Plaintiff, allegedly causing injuries.  

The Defendant’s Preliminary Objections requested the Court to strike allegations of “reckless conduct,” “recklessness,” and “deliberate disregard” as being the alleged inclusion of scandalous and impertinent matter.  The Court also was requested to dismiss a count on strict liability.   The claim for strict liability was apparently based on the fact that the parties were cutting trees with chainsaws.

Judge Williamson overruled the Preliminary Objections and held “obviously, recklessness is relevant to the claim and therefore cannot be impertinent.” and found that there was nothing scandalous about such allegations under the facts presented.  

The Court also denied the Preliminary Objections on the strict liability claim indicating that, while “the Court must determine, as a matter of law, whether an activity is abnormally dangerous so that strict liability will be imposed…[accepting] all well-pleaded allegations…as true…Plaintiff has sufficiently averred the factors to establish a claim for strict liability.”  

 
I send thanks to Attorney Joseph F. Kulesa of Fischer and Fischer Law Offices in Mount Pocono for bringing this decision to my attention.


Anyone wishing to review this decision, may click this LINK.

Friday, August 16, 2013

Judge Nealon of Lackawanna County Addresses Novel Issue of Viability of Punitive Damages Claim For Distraction by GPS While Driving


Judge Terrence R. Nealon has written an excellent and thoroughly researched Opinion on the novel case of first impression of whether a punitive damages claim may be pursued in an auto accident case against a defendant driver on the basis that the defendant was distracted by looking down at a GPS on a smart phone at the time of the accident.

In the case of Rockwell v. Knott, No. 12 CV 1114 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Aug. 13, 2013 Nealon, J.), the defendant filed a motion for partial summary judgment on this punitive damages claim.

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County
In his detailed Opinion, Judge Nealon noted there were a few Pennsylvania court of common pleas decisions involving cell phone use (which does not divert the driver's eyes and attention from the roadway), but nothing involving texting while driving, or use of a cell phone GPS, which could cause far greater driver distraction. 

The court also reviewed similar cases from other jurisdictions to round out the analysis on the issues presented of driver distraction by mobile devices.

While Judge Nealon noted in his Opinion that looking away from the road at a GPS on a smart phone to the point of distraction could arguably amount to reckless conduct to support a punitive damages claim, the record before the court in this particular matter failed to contain any evidence to support the claim that the defendant driver was indeed so distracted at the time of the accident.

As such, the defendant's motion for partial summary judgment on the punitive damages claim was granted by the court.

This case has settled since the issuance of the Opinion and, therefore, there will be no appellate review of this case.

Anyone wishing to review this Opinion by Judge Nealon in the case of Rockwell v. Knott may click on this LINK

PDI North Region CLE Continued to December 4, 2013 to Coincide with Holiday Happy Hour

The Pennsylvania Defense Institute has announced that their annual North Regional CLE progam, which was set for August 22, 2013 at Mohegan Sun at Pocono Downs, has been postponed to December 4, 2013 to coincide with a Holiday Happy Hour on the same date. 

The program is co-sponsored by the Northeast Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association.

The afternoon CLE program will be followed by the evening reception.

The program will feature new Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice Correale F. Stevens, and a panel of local judges.

The cost for lawyers is $175 for the program and reception, and free for all others (insurance claim professionals, law clerks, paralegals, etc...).

For an agenda and registration click here (But be reminded that the new date is December 4, 2013).

You can also contact PDI Executive Director Dave Cole at coled01@padefense.org.for more information.