Friday, January 28, 2011

PLEASE SAVE THE DATE - APRIL 20, 2011 - TORT TALK EXPO 2011

TORT TALK EXPO 2011

Seasons Ballroom
Mohegan Sun Casino
Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania

April 20, 2011
1 p.m. - 5 p.m.


Followed by a Cocktail Reception at the
Breakers Nightclub
in the Mohegan Sun Casino


The TORT TALK EXPO 2011 is designed to be a CLE Program that will be as entertaining and informative as the posts regularly sent out from the Tort Talk blog.

The seminar will be immediately followed by a cocktail reception at which attendees can network with fellow lawyers, insurance professionals, and members of the federal and state judiciary from around Northeastern Pennsylvania.

The TORT TALK EXPO 2011 will include door prizes for every attendee and chances to win raffle prizes (gift cards, sporting event tickets, etc.). There will also be vendor tables for attendees to visit with a variety of service providers in the legal field.

A portion of the proceeds from this event will be donated to the Janet Weis Children's Hospital in the Geisinger Health System in Danville, Pennsylvania.


The CLE Program will include the following topics and presenters:

The Tort Talk Top Ten (or so) Cases
Presenter: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire


Little League Tips for Big League Lawyers
Presenter: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire


Anatomy for Lawyers: Neck and Back
(Also, witness a live simulation IME by an Orthopedic Surgeon)
Presenter: Dr. Lucian Bednarz, Physiatrist - Northeastern Rehabilitation Associates
Presenter: Dr. Thomas A. Allardyce, Orthopedic Surgeon


A View From the Bench:
Ethical Issues in Legal Writing and Advocacy Before the Court
Moderator: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
Judicial Panel Members to be Determined


Networking Cocktail Reception Follows at Breakers
5 p.m. - 6:3o p.m.



Costs to cover both CLE Seminar and Cocktail Reception:

Claims professionals/representatives and risk managers $25.00

Lawyers who are Tort Talk Email Subscribers
$145.00

Lawyers who are not Tort Talk Email Subscribers
$165.00


Make checks payable to "Tort Talk."




For reservations, please complete the requested information below and return it to the address noted below or e-mail it to dancummins@comcast.net


Name(s)____________________________________



Firm/Company_______________________________


MAIL REGISTRATION FORM AND PAYMENT TO:


TORT TALK
c/o Daniel E. Cummins, Esq.
Foley, Cognetti, Comerford, Cimini & Cummins
507 Linden Street
Suite 700
Scranton, PA 18503




For more information, contact Dan Cummins at 570-346-0745 or at dancummins@comcast.net



HOPE TO SEE YOU THERE!

Thursday, January 27, 2011

Lackawanna County Judge Chester T. Harhut To Take Senior Status

Judge Chester T. Harhut has advised that he will be moving to senior status on the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas at the end of 2011. This will create a vacancy on the Lackawanna County bench beginning 2012.

Here is a link to the story in an article by Boris Krawczeniuk in today's Times-Tribune in Scranton. Note that this article was written just before the Judge announced his decision. As noted above, he has decided to go to senior status: http://thetimes-tribune.com/news/judge-harhut-considers-taking-senior-status-1.1095776#axzz1CFgDQUmI

Saturday, January 22, 2011

Two More Philadelphia County Post-Koken Decisions in Favor of Severance

Last week, two more decisions in favor of the severance of post-Koken claims were handed down by the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, by Order only, on the basis of filings by the tortfeasor defendant:

Saltzburg v. Haynes and State Farm, November Term, 2010, No. 03227 (Phila. Co. Jan. 14, 2011 Tereshko, J.)(Preliminary Objections of tortfeasor defendant on basis of improper venue and improper joinder of third party negligence case with UIM case; claim against tortfeasor dismissed without prejudice to Plaintiff's right to re-file in Montgomery county).

Pascal v. Nalbondian, et al., July Term, 2010, No. 2118, Control No. 10121229 (Phila. Co. Jan. 14, 2011, Fox, J.)(Tortfeasor's motion to sever negligence claims from claims filed against UIM carrier granted).

With the addition of these two cases to the Post-Koken Scorecard there are now at least 34 decisions across the Commonwealth in favor of the consolidation of these claims and 22 in favor of severance.

The breakdown county-by-county is much closer. There are now at least 10 counties that have ruled in favor of consolidation (Beaver, Cambria, Clinton, Dauphin, Erie, Lawrence, Lehigh, Luzerne, Montgomery, Northampton, and Pike Counties)

There are at least 8 counties that have ruled in favor of severance (Adams, Butler, Delaware, Lancaster, Mercer, Schuylkill, Washington, and York Counties).

Several counties, including Lackawanna, Montgomery, Philadelphia, and arguably Allegheny have a split of authority on the issue amongst the judges in their own court system.

Note that this compilation is not represented to be exhaustive and there may be other decisions out there that I have not yet come across.

Federal Middle District Court Judge Caputo Enters Summary Judgment on Bad Faith Claim in Favor of Carrier in Post-Koken Case

Recently, on December 28, 2010, Middle District Federal Judge A. Richard Caputo granted summary judgment in favor of Progressive Casualty Insurance Company in the post-Koken bad faith case of Calestini v. Progressive Insurance Company, slip copy, 2010 WL 5437278, 3:09-CV-1679 (M.D.Pa. Dec. 28, 2010, Caputo, J.)(mem. op.).

This case was previously publicized here on Tort Talk when Judge Caputo denied efforts by the defendant carrier to bifurcate and stay the bad faith claim from the UIM claim. Click here to review the prior post:

http://www.torttalk.com/2009/12/post-koken-update.html

In this more recent Opinion, Judge Caputo granted summary judgment in favor of the carrier on the bad faith claim after finding that "the Plaintiff has failed to bring forth clear and convincing evidence of bad faith on the part of the Defendant in handling Plaintiff's UIM claims."

In this case, the record revealed that, in addition to a number of other traumatic injury-producing events, the Plaintiff had been involved in a 2005 car accident and a 2006 car accident. The Plaintiff was pursuing UIM claims against Progressive relative to these two car accidents.

The Plaintiff filed a single Complaint covering claims arising out of both the 2005 and 2006 accidents. The Complaint alleged two breach of contract claims and two bad faith claims, i.e. one set of claims for each of the two accidents.

The Court rejected the Plaintiff's argument that the carrier's previous proposal that the UIM claim arising out of the 2005 accident be tried together with the negligence claim against that tortfeasor amounted to bad faith conduct.

Judge Caputo stated that "[n]othing about Defendant's proposal to try the negligence claim and the UIM claim together undermined or was inconsistent with the logic of the UIM coverage." The court noted that, in making such a proposal, the carrier was still on the hook to pay UIM damages if warranted by such a jury verdict. The court also appeared to agree with Progressive's contention that the proposal would have benefited the Plaintiff in avoiding the trouble and expenses related to two separate lawsuits.

The Court also rejected the Plaintiff's allegation that the UIM carrier failed to expeditiously evaluate the claims presented. In this matter, the Plaintiff had an extensive prior medical history and there were questions as to what injuries were related to the 2005 accident versus what injuries were caused by the 2006 car accident. The court noted that, although the carrier was eventually given an expert report by the Plaintiff separating out the injuries from the 2005 accident and the 2006 accident, the carrier only had "several days" to review that report before the bad faith claims were filed.

Judge Caputo concluded that "[g]iven the number of accidents Plaintiff has been involved in over the past six years and the extensive injuries he allegedly suffered, it is reasonable that Defendant would want to conduct a thorough investigation of the injuries and have all of the requisite documents and records before it before settling Plaintiff's claim."

The court also noted that the carrier's actions in this matter of desiring to conduct additional discovery on the causation issues was further supported by the opinion of the defense IME doctor who raised questions as to the causation and extent of injuries issues.

For these reasons, the court granted summary judgment in favor of the carrier on the bad faith claim.



The bad faith expert for the prevailing defendant carrier was Attorney David Cole (email: coled01@padefense.org), who also happens to be the Executive Director of the Pennsylvania Defense Institute. The prevailing defense attorney was Robert Dapper, Esquire of the Pittsburgh office of Dapper, Baldasare, Benson, Behling & Kane, P.C.

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

Trivial Defect Case out of Philadelphia County

On December 13, 2010, Judge Levin of the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas issued an Opinion supporting entry of a compulsory non-suit in favor of a property owner after ruling that a defect in the sidewalk that was only 5/8 of an inch was a trivial defect as a matter of law in the case of Alston v. Commonwealth, PICS Case No. 11-0061 (Phila. Co., Dec. 13, 2010, Levin, J.).

In this case, the injured party had previously secured a settlement from the City of Philadelphia and PennDOT due to her injuries from a fall on a city street. The City of Philadelphia proceeded to trial against the property owner to recover the money the City paid in settlement on the grounds that the property owner was secondarily liable to the Plaintiff.

Judge Levin pointed to the fact that the City's own liability expert conceded at trial that there were thousands of city sidewalks with elevation levels of less than one inch. The court also noted that there were numerous appellate decisions finding deviations greater in size than the one at issue in this matter did not provide any basis for liability against a property owner.

The court further stated that "[i]t is simply unreasonable and utterly unrealistic to hold municipalities and property owners to a standard of care of maintaining pavement in pristine condition."

Rather, court found that the standard is reasonable care depending upon the surrounding the circumstances. Applying this standard, the court asserted that it properly entered a compulsory non-suit in favor of the property owner.



Anyone desiring a copy of this case (for a small fee) may contact the Pennsylvania Law Weekly's Instant Case Service at 1-800-276-7427 and provide the above-referenced PICS Case Number.


Source: "Digest of Recent Opinions" in January 18, 2011 Pennsylvania Law Weekly.

More Post-Koken Decisions in Favor of Consolidation

Below are summaries of three more recent Post-Koken decisions, all of which come down in favor of the consolidation of the claims against a tortfeasor and the UIM carrier under one caption.

By my count under the updated Post-Koken Scorecard (which is thorough but may not be exhaustive) there are at least 34 decisions from around the Commonwealth in favor of consolidation of claims and at least 20 decisions in favor of severance. Click here to view the Post-Koken Scorecard here on Tort Talk: http://www.torttalk.com/2009/12/new-and-improved-updated-list-of-post.html

To date, there still has been no appellate decision on point.

Dauphin County

I was notified of a post-Koken Order that came down in Dauphin County back on September 10, 2010. In the case of Schaeffer v. Bonny and Donegal Group, No. 2010 - Civil - 4547 (Dauph. Co., Sept. 10, 2010, Coates, J.), Judge Bernard L. Coates, Jr. denied preliminary objections filed by tortfeasor defendants and the UIM carrier and allow the claims filed by the Plaintiff against the tortfeasor to remain consolidated under one caption with the claims against the UIM carrier.

This is at least the fourth decision out of Dauphin County in favor of consolidation.

The prevailing attorney in the Schaeffer case was Attorney Matt Crosby of Handler, Henning & Rosenberg, LLP in Harrisburg, PA.

Cambria County

With its recent decision in two matters, the Cambria County Court of Common Pleas makes its first appearance on the Post-Koken Scorecard.

On January 10, 2010, an en banc opinion was issued in the Cambria County post-Koken case of Link v. Eckenrode and State Farm, No. 2009- Civil - 1312 (Cambria Co., Jan. 10, 2011)(Opinion by President Judge Timothy P. Creany, Concurrence by Judge David J. Tulowitzki, and Dissenting Opinion by Linda Rovder Fleming). The issue presented was whether negligence claims should be allowed to proceed in a consolidated fashion with UIM claims under one caption.

In its Opinion, the en banc panel of the Court of Common Pleas of Cambria County also addressed the same issue as presented in the separate case of Lydick v. Keilman, No. 2010- Civil - 1700 (Cambria Co., Jan. 10, 2011, Creany, J.).

The majority opinion essentially relied upon the interests of judicial economy in holding that it would allow the plaintiff to join the third party and UM or UIM claims in the same proceeding particularly where the cases involve the same or similar questions pertaining to the liability and damages issues.

The majority noted that the issues attendant with introducing insurance into the trial setting, including the potential implication of the collateral source rule, can be "overcome by cautious trial management in presenting insurance evidence to the jury so as not to taint either party.

The court also stated that the jury could be instructed that, in the event the plaintiff recovers, contractual relationships would then determine whether the plaintiff's own insurance company is liable as well.

In her dissenting Opinion, Judge Fleming pointed to the current split of authority among the trial courts across the Commonwealth and indicated that a collection of these decisions was "compiled through the diligent efforts of Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire" in a recent Pennsylvania Law Weekly article. See Link at p. 2, n. 1.

Judge Fleming noted that, in her assessment of the question presented, the potential prejudice to a tortfeasor defendant by the introduction of insurance issues at trial outweighed any interest of judicial economy and, as such, she would have erred on the side of caution, in favor of a severance of claims.


Anyone desiring a copy of the above-noted decisions may email me at dancummins@comcast.net.

I send thanks to Attorney Steve T. Mahan a third year law student at Widener and a law clerk at the Harrisburg law firm of Handler, Henning & Rosenberg, LLP, Attorney Scott Cooper of the Harrisburg law firm of Schmidt Kramer, and Attorney Paul Oven of the Moosic, Pennsylvania law firm of Dougherty, Leventhal & Price for bringing these cases to my attention.

Sunday, January 16, 2011

Important Rule Changes Pertaining to Pre-Trial/Settlement Conferences Go Into Effect

Here is a link to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court of amendments to Pa.R.C.P. 212.3, 215 and 216, pertaining to pre-trial conferences and settlement conferences, which became effective January 15, 2011.

Of note is the following new provision to Rule 212.3, pertaining to Pre-Trial Conferences:

"A court may require, pursuant to a court order, various parties to attend a pre-trial conference, including an insurance or similar representative, who has authority to negotiate and settle the case."

The Rule goes onto state that, if the Pre-Trial Conference is set up without any Court order regarding the attendance of an insurance representative with settlement authority, such a person is still required by the terms of the Rule to attend the conference in person "or be promptly available by phone."

Here is a link to all of the amendments to the Rules noted as contained in the January 8, 2011 Pennsylvania Bulletin:

http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol41/41-2/30.html


I send thanks to Attorney Dave Cole, Executive Director of the Pennsylvania Defense Institute, for bringing these Rule changes to my attention.