Monday, February 10, 2025

Plaintiff Found To Have Offered Sufficient Expert Testimony In Support of a Delayed Cancer Diagnosis


In the case of Delavern v. Health Services of Clarion, Inc., No. 858 WDA 2024 (Pa. Super. Jan. 6, 2025 Bowes, J., Beck, J., and Bender, P.J.E.) (Op. by Bowes, J.), the court affirmed the entry of judgment against a medical malpractice Defendant in which a jury entered an award of $7.3 million dollars. The case involved a medical malpractice action with allegations of a delayed diagnosis.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiffs had claimed that a physician’s assistant affiliated with a Defendant incorrectly diagnosed the Plaintiff with a separate condition other than the cancer which was later found relative to the patient. The Plaintiffs alleged that the supervising physician signed off the on the physician’s assistant’s notes without properly reviewing them and also failed to refer the Plaintiff for further screening.

The Plaintiffs claimed that the Defendant’s negligence resulted in a 13-month delay in the Plaintiff receiving a cancer diagnosis, which thereby allegedly allowed the cancer to progress from a curable stage to an incurable one.

On appeal, the Pennsylvania Superior Court rejected a Defendant’s argument that the Plaintiffs’ oncology expert failed to show that the Plaintiff experienced a worse health outcome as a result of a delayed cancer diagnosis.

The trial court and the Superior Court both agreed that the Plaintiff’s expert offered sufficient proof of an increased risk of harm caused by the Defendant’s negligence so as to allow the issuance of causation to go to the jury.

Anyone wishing to review this non-precedential decision of the Superior Court may click this
LINK.


Source – Article: “Superior Court Rejects Pa. Hospital’s Challenge to $7.3M Med Mal Judgment,” by Aleeza Furman of The Legal Intelligencer (Jan. 6, 2025).

Court Rules That Seasoned Federal Middle District Attorneys Can Expect Hourly Rates of $375 Per Hour For Attorney's Fees Requests


In the case of Holmes v. American Homepatient, Inc., No. 4:21-CV-01683 (M.D. Pa. Jan. 28, 2025 Brann, C.J.), the court granted, in part, a Plaintiff’s Motions for Attorney’s Fees Under 42 U.S.C. §1988.

In his decision, Chief Judge Brann reviewed a Plaintiff’s law firm’s request for $2.45 Million Dollars in attorney’s fees and allowed for such fees but cut down the amount requested to just over $250,000.00. In coming to amount of fees awarded, the court reduced the hourly rates pled and the hours logged.

This attorney’s fees request came after the Plaintiff prevailed in a hostile work environment case against her former employer. According to the below cited article on this case, while the Plaintiff had originally secured a verdict that included $20 million dollars in punitive damages and $500,000.00 in compensatory damages, in another, previous decision rendered in this case, the court subsequently reduced that verdict to $1 million dollars.

After reviewing attorney's fees awards in the Federal Middle District Court of Pennsylvania for the past five (5) years, Chief Judge Matthew W. Brann determined in this matter that the district court regularly awarded attorney fee rates ranging from $100.00 to $375.00 depending upon skill, experience, the complexity of the case, and other factors.

Chief Judge Matthew W. Brann
M.D.Pa.

In this case, finding that the Plaintiff’s lead attorneys, who have been practicing for twenty-eight (28) years and twenty-four (24) years respectively, the court awarded those attorneys hourly rates of $375.00 per hour. The lesser involved attorneys with lesser experience were awarded hourly rates of $300.00 per hour and $250.00 per hour. The court also reduced the paralegal hourly rates down to $150.00 per hour and $115.00 per hour, based upon the factors noted.

The court otherwise cut down purported travel time and other hours of work on post-trial motions. Chief Judge Brann noted that many of the post-trial motions were not complex and did not propose novel questions.

The court also agreed with the Defendant’s argument that, overall, the fees requested should be slashed by 5% because of the Plaintiffs’ attorneys’ use of quarter-hour and half-hour increments for billing.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: Article – “Judge Tanks Prevailing Pittsburgh Attorneys’ $2.45M Fee Request to $250K,” by Riley Brennan, The Legal Intelligencer (Jan. 29, 2025).

Source of top image:  Photo by Towfiqu Barbhuiya on www.pexels.com.

Friday, February 7, 2025

Court Quashes Subpoena For Records As Too Broad in Scope


In the case of The Cincinnati Ins. Co. v. K&K Fire Protection Enterprises, Inc., No. 6060-CV-2021 (C.P. Monroe. Co. Nov. 20, 2024 C. Daniel Higgins, Jr., J.), the court laid out the law pertinent to a Motion to Quash a Subpoena and related Motions for Protective Orders on records sought by subpoenas.

This case arose out of a fire loss. The Plaintiff claimed that inadequate maintenance by the Defendant was the cause of the fire. 

At issue before the court was a subpoena that the Defendant had issued to another entity seeking maintenance records related to the fire protection systems on the premises.

The entity that was subpoenaed asserted that the records in question no longer existed.

The court denied that entity’s Motion to Quash the subpoena and for a Protective Order as to those records. The court noted that it expected an affidavit from that entity to confirm, under oath, that the records requested no longer existed.

The subpoena at issue also sought additional other records that the court found were not relevant to the claims against the Defendant. The court found that the subpoena requests for those other records were too broad in scope.  As such, the court quashed the subpoena for those records after find that the subpoenas submitted to the entity that was requested to produce the records amounted to unreasonable annoyance embarrassment oppression, burden, or expense.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert. (Jan. 8, 2025).

Thursday, February 6, 2025

Superior Court Affirms Trial Court's Finding that No Coverage Existed Related to a COVID-19 Shutdown of a Business



In a non-precedential decision issued by the Pennsylvania Superior Court in the case of The Scranton Club v. Tuscarora Wayne Mut. Group, No. 238 MDA 2021 (Pa. Super. Jan. 27, 2025 Panella, P.J., Olson, J., and Kunselman, J.) (Op. by Kunselman, J.), the Superior Court affirmed the trial court’s dismissal of all claims filed by The Scranton Club and found that no coverage existed to the COVID shut down of the Plaintiff’s business.  

The affirmed trial court Opinion was written by Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackwanna County Court of Common Pleas.  The Tort Talk Blog post on Judge Nealon's Opinion, which contains a link to that decision can be found at this LINK.

In this case, the Superior Court followed the precedent set forth in the recent Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision on similar issues in the case of Ungarean v. CNA & Valley Forge Ins. Co., 323 A.3d 593 (Pa. 2024).

The Superior Court in this case found that the trial court properly ruled that The Scranton Club did not allege any facts to establish that it incurred a “direct physical loss of or damage to property” as required to establish coverage under the policy. The court noted that, given that there was nothing that required restoration of The Scranton Club’s property as a result of the COVID shut down, there is no coverage to be provided under the insurance policy at issue.

The Superior Court noted that it also continued to affirm the trial court’s decision to dismiss the Plaintiff’s claims for civil authority coverage. The court noted that, to assert a claim for the civil authority coverage under the policy at issue, the civil authority action prohibiting access to the premises must have been in response to “damage” caused to another property. Given that there is no evidence of any damage to any neighboring properties which resulted in the Plaintiff’s property being shut down, the Superior Court held that the trial court was correct to deny coverage on this ground as well.

Lastly, the Superior Court noted that it was now affirming the trial court’s dismissal of the claim for bad faith given that coverage was not otherwise available under the policy at issue.


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Vehicle Damages Photos From Accident Were Not Authenticated and, Therefore, Not Allowed


In the case of Moore v. Nordland, June Term, 2020, No. 01679 (C.P. Phila. Co. Nov. 19, 2024 Turner, J.), the court issued a Rule 1925 Opinion asking the Superior Court to affirm the trial court Order denying the Defendant’s Motion for Post-Trial Relief following a motor vehicle accident.

A primary issue in this case raised by the Plaintiff was whether the court erred in precluding photographs of the vehicle that were involved in the accident.

According to the Opinion, during cross-examination, both Plaintiffs confirmed that they could not recall or remember if the photographs of the vehicles presented to them fairly and accurately depicted the condition of the vehicles following the accident. Accordingly, the court found that, based upon the testimony of the Plaintiff, the Defendant was unable to authenticate the photographs.

During the direct examination of the Defendant, defense counsel again attempted to authenticate the photographs. However, when asked whether the photographs depicted the way to the Plaintiff’s vehicle following the accident, the Defendant testified, “Yes, I mean, there’s nothing different from what I’m seeing in these pictures compared to what I saw there on Cheltenham Avenue,” where the accident happened. The Defendant also testified that the photograph of the Plaintiffs’ vehicle “looks like the exact same vehicle that I was in the accident with that afternoon–evening.”

The trial court judge wrote in her Opinion that the Defendant failed to testify that the photographs fairly and accurately depicted the vehicles following the accident. Rather, the Defendant only testified that the vehicle in the photograph was the same vehicle he was in the accident with. The court noted that the Defendant was unable to confirm that the photographs fairly and accurately depicted the damage, or lack of damage, to the vehicles following the accident.

Based upon the testimony of all of the parties, the court found that the photographs were not properly authenticated and, as such, did not allow the Defendant to admit the photographs into evidence or to publish them to the jury.

In so ruling, the court cited to “Pa. R.E. 901(a), which pertains to authentication of evidence. The court additionally cited to the case of Com. v. Loughnane, 128 A.2d 806, 814 (Pa. 2015), for the proposition that a photograph “may be authenticated by testimony from a person who has sufficient knowledge that the photograph fairly and accurately reflects what the proponent is purporting the photograph to reflect.” 

Here, the court noted that, while photographs of vehicles were certainly relevant, and may be admissible, in this case, the Defendant failed to properly authenticate the photographs. The court additionally noted that, “most importantly,” there was no testimony as to who took the photographs, when the photographs were taken, and whether any repair work had been done to the cars following the accident but before the photos were taken.

Also of note with regards to this decision, the court found that the Plaintiffs’ testimony regarding the accident, their injuries, and the residual impact of the injuries on the injured Plaintiff’s life, along with the Plaintiff’s expert testimony, provided the jury with sufficient testimony and evidence to make a determination as to whether or not the limited tort Plaintiffs’ injuries were “serious” such that the pierced the limited tort threshold.

Here, there is evidence that the Plaintiffs sustained soft tissue injuries to her cervical, thoracic, and lumbar spine regions along with disc protrusions and herniations in her neck and mid-back and low back. The court also noted that the Plaintiffs testified in detail as how the injuries impacted their everyday lives.

Accordingly, the trial court requested the appellate court to affirm the trial court’s denial of the Defendants’ Motion for Post-Trial Relief in this regard.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: The Legal Intelligencer Common Pleas Case Alert, www.Law.com (Jan. 16, 2025).

Source of image:  Photo by Victor Moragriega on www.pexels.com.

Many Mock Trial Volunteer Jurors Still Needed -- Please Consider Signing Up

 




Wednesday, February 5, 2025

TIP FROM CUMMINS MEDIATION SERVICES


 TIP TO IMPROVE CHANCES 
FOR SUCCESS AT MEDIATION:

STEP INTO SHOES OF OPPONENT AND FULLY VIEW YOUR CASE FROM THAT PERSPECTIVE

AND THEN

BE PREPARED TO ADDRESS THE PROBLEM 
AREAS YOU SEE