Friday, December 27, 2024

Arbitration Clause Under an App Ruled Unenforceable

In the case of Pierce v. Floatme Corp., No. GD 24-2169 (C.P. Allegh. Co. Dec. 19, 2024 Hertzberg, J.), the trial court overruled preliminary objections filed by a loan provider called Floatme Corp. in which the loan provider sought to have the class action filed against it dismissed pursuant to an arbitration clause contained within the provisions noted in the smartphone app when customers downloaded the app. 

In so ruling, Judge Hertzberg found that the arbitration provisions were not conspicuous enough for the users of the app so as to uphold any alleged arbitration agreement.  More specifically, the court found that  a "meeting of the minds" on the issue of arbitration was lacking in the case presented.  There was no unambiguous assent to arbitration by the customers in this case.

In his decision, Judge Hertzberg referred to a split Superior Court ruling in the case of Chilutti v. Uber Technologies.  In that Chilutti case, the Superior Court ruled that a binding arbitration agreement found in the Uber app failed to provide sufficient notice to customers that they were, in fact, agreeing to arbitration in the event of disputes and thereby waiving their right to a trial.  That Chilutti case is currently up before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court on appeal.

The Tort Talk post on the Chilutti case can be viewed HERE.

A copy of the Pierce v. Floatme Corp. case summarized in this Tort Talk blog post can be viewed at this LINK.

I send thanks to Thomas J. Foley, III if the Foley Law Firm in Scranton, PA for bringing this decision to my attention.

Federal Court Addresses Exception to "No-Duty" Rule In a Slip and Fall Case


In the case of Neyman v. Sunbelt Rentals, Inc., No. 2:23-CV-00226-WSS (W.D. Pa. Dec. 13, 2024 Stickman, J.), the court denied a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a slip and fall case.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against the Defendant to recover for injuries that the Plaintiff sustained when he slipped and fell on a wet and muddy ramp while unloading a forklift from a tractor trailer.

The defense filed a Motion for Summary Judgment arguing that it had not duty to the Plaintiff because the Plaintiff knew of the dangerous conditions on the ramp and chose to voluntarily walk on the ramp and was injured as a result. Essentially, the Defendants were arguing that a “no-duty” rule arises in favor of a Defendant when a danger is known and obvious to a Plaintiff and the Plaintiff chooses to voluntarily encounter that danger.

The Plaintiffs argued that the second clause of §343A, along with comment F of that Section under the Restatement (Second) of Torts created an exception to the “no-duty” rule. The Plaintiff more specifically argued that, even if a danger is known and obvious to a Plaintiff, a Defendant may still be liable if the Defendant should expect that a business invitee will not protect themselves against the danger due to being distracted at the time of the incident.

After reviewing the law as applied to the facts presented, the court held that, although it was clear that the Plaintiff knew about the dangerous condition of the ramp based upon the Plaintiff’s testimony that the ramp was indeed muddy and wet, the court otherwise found that issues of fact remained as to whether the Defendant should have anticipated a harm to the Plaintiff despite the Plaintiff’s knowledge of the ramp conditions.

There was evidence in the case that, prior to the Plaintiff’s fall, an employee of the Defendant had slipped on the ramp. Accordingly, the court noted that a jury could reasonably determine not only that the Defendant knew that the ramp was slippery, but that its slippery condition could lead to workers falling on the ramp. The court stated that it would be up to a jury to determine whether, despite the Plaintiff’s knowledge of the dangerous condition on the ramp, the Defendant should have anticipated a harm despite such knowledge on the part of the Plaintiff or the fact that the danger was obvious.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Garrett L. Trettel and Attorney Brendan B. Lupetin of the Pittsburgh, PA law firm of Lupetin & Unatin for bringing this case to my attention.

Source of image:  Photo by Ace Cranes on www.pexels.com.

Monday, December 23, 2024

Plaintiff Found to Have Released Personal Injury By Signing a Business Termination Agreement



In the case of Werner v. 1281 King Associates, LLC, No. 1725 MDA 2023 (Pa. Super. Nov. 13, 2024 Panella, P.J.E., Lane, J., and Stevens, P.J.E.) (Op. by Stevens, P.J.E.), the court affirmed a trial court’s sustaining of Preliminary Objections by Defendants based upon a claim that the Plaintiffs had released the Defendants from liability in this tort litigation under an agreement that the Plaintiff had executed which terminated the parties’ business relationship.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiffs filed a negligence action against the Defendants based upon injuries sustained by the Plaintiff at a property owned by the Defendants. The Plaintiff was injured when the leg of his pants caught on a jagged edge of a ramp provided for delivery drivers and caused him to fall and suffer a hip fracture which required surgery.

According to the Opinion, prior to the accident, the Plaintiff had entered into an independent distributor agreement in which the Plaintiff was designated as the exclusive distributor for the Defendants’ products in a particular territory.

After the accident, the parties entered into a termination, release, consent, and arbitration agreement that allowed the Plaintiff to assign his distribution rights to another party in return for the termination of his distribution agreement.

That termination agreement contained a comprehensive release clause that provided that the Plaintiff release the Defendants “from any and all actions, causes of action, claims… and compensation of any nature whatsoever…. in any way arising out of, relating to, or having any connection with the Distributor Agreement."

When this personal injury lawsuit was filed, the Defendants filed Preliminary Objections asserting that the Plaintiff’s negligence case should be dismissed because of the release clause in the business termination agreement.

The trial court found that the release clause was clear and unambiguous and and served to preclude the Plaintiff from also pursuing the personal injury claims at issue.  The Superior Court agreed.

On a procedural level, the Superior Court noted that the Plaintiffs had waived any arguments that the Defendants had improperly raised the doctrine of release by way of Preliminary Objections by virtue of the Plaintiff’s failure to file Preliminary Objections to these Preliminary Objections.

Turning to the merits of the Defendants' request for a dismissal, the Superior Court agreed that the release language was unambiguous and that the language showed the intent of the parties to release the Defendants from any claims with any causal connection to the Distributor Agreement or the Plaintiff’s role as a distributor or party. The Superior Court noted that the Plaintiff would not have been on the property or injured but for his duties to fulfill his contractual obligations under the Distributor Agreement.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “The Legal Intelligencer State Appellate Case Alert.” www.law.com (Dec. 3, 2024).

Thursday, December 19, 2024

Court Addresses Law of Liability For Items That Fall From a Wall


In the case of Inman-Clark v. Neiman Marcus Group, LLC, No. 19-CV-4717 (E.D. Pa. Nov. 13, 2024 Goldberg, J.), the court granted partial summary judgment in a premises liability case where a wall display item fell off of a wall and hit the Plaintiff.  More specifically, the item that fell was a large framed picture.

The court noted that, in cases of falling objects, the proof necessary to establish negligence under the circumstances need only be very slight. The rationale of the court was that incidents of this kind do not ordinarily occur absent negligence.

Also, in this case, the court found that no evidence supported any of the alternative possibilities raised by the Defendants in an effort to assert that the accident occurred in a non-negligent manner.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.


Wednesday, December 18, 2024

Trial Court Judge Allows Pre-Complaint Discovery in a Breach of Privacy Case

 In his decision in S.S. v. Jefferson/Lehigh Valley Hospital, No. 2024-CV-5812 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Dec. 11, 2024), Senior Judge Carmen D. Minora, by Order only, allowed for certain pre-Complaint discovery in a breach of privacy case involving medical entity Defendants.

In particular, the Court ordered the Defendants to identify for the Plaintiff the appropriate entities to be namedas defendants in the case and that the Defendants were deemed to have waived any procedural contention asserting the erroneous identification of the parties being sued.

The Court also ordered the Defendants to produce the names and contact information of any current or former employees involved in the breach at issue.

The Court also ordered the Defendants to produce an audit trail covering certain dates.

Finally, the Court additionally ordered the Defendants to produce a copy of any internal rules or regulations addressing and advising the Defendant employees that a patient's right to privacy and freedom from disclosure of personal information must not be breached.

Anyone wishing to review this Order only (no Opinion was issued) may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Michael Foley of the Foley Law Firm in Scranton, PA for bringing this case to my attention.

Court Declares United States' Independence From the Plaintiff's Lawsuit by Way of Granting Motion To Dismiss

Independence Hall
Philadelphia, PA

In the case of Chrelashvili v. United States of America, No. 2:24-cv-02241-TJS (E.D. Pa. Nov. 7, 2024 Savage, J.), the court granted a Motion to Dismiss filed by the Defendant, The United States, in a personal injury action arising out of a trip and fall in a National Historical Park.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff sued the federal government after she allegedly tripped over a tree stump that was protruding through a sidewalk in Independence National Historical Park in Philadelphia. 

The United States moved to dismiss by asserting that the discretionary function exception to the Federal Tort Claims Act’s waiver of sovereign immunity applied. The United States argued that the exception applied because the dangerous condition of the property claimed of by the Plaintiff fell within the exclusive discretion of the National Park Service, whose officials had to balance competing policy interests within the limits of human and financial resources.

Based upon the case before it, the court concluded that the United States was indeed immune from the Plaintiff’s personal injury lawsuit under the discretionary function exception to the Federal Tort Claims Act.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: “The Legal Intelligencer Federal Case Alert.” www.Law.com (Dec. 5, 2024).

Source of image:  Photo by Miguel Sanz on www.pexels.com.

Monday, December 16, 2024

Superior Court Defines Good Cause Requirement or IMEs or DMes


In the case of Verba v. Erie Insurance Exchange, No. 2633 EDA 2023 (Pa. Super. Oct. 31, 2024 Panella, P.J.E., King, J., and Stevens, P.J.E) (Op. by King, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed the standard for determining whether good cause exist to compel the Plaintiff to cooperate with a request for a medical examination, that is, an IME or a DME depending on what you call it, under Pa. R.C.P. 4010.

The court noted that the requirement of good cause set forth in Rule 4010 is designed to protect parties against an unwarranted invasion of their privacy and to preclude the use of such a medical examination for improper purposes.

The court noted that good cause can exist in a pending litigation if there is a controversy that relates to the very existence of a medical condition which goes to the validity of the cause of action and where absent proof of the Plaintiff’s medical condition a case may not proceed.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Source: The Legal Intelligencer State Appellate Case Alert. www.law.com (Nov. 20, 2024).

Source of image:  Photo by Pavil Danilyuk on www.pexels.com.