Tuesday, January 18, 2022

Request For Consolidation of Cases "For All Purposes" Denied Where Each Action Sought Different Remedy


In the case of Montage Mountain Resorts, L.P. v. PA American Water Company, No. 20-CV-4926 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Jan. 7, 2022 Nealon, J.), the court addressed a Motion by the Plaintiff seeking to consolidate two (2) related lawsuits “for all purposes.” This request was opposed by the Defendant.

The courted noted that the Plaintiff ski resort initially commenced a tort action against a water utility company seeking compensatory and punitive damages based upon the utility’s alleged discharge of pellets from its water treatment facility into the reservoir which also served as the water source for the resort’s snowmaking systems. The resort asserted that the improperly released pallets clogged its snowmaking machinery which resulted in substantial repair costs, lost snowmaking capacity, closed ski trails due to inadequate snow, and diminished ski season revenue.

The ski resort later instituted a second action against the utility company under the Clean Streams Law in which the ski resort requested the abatement of an alleged public nuisance allegedly created by the utility company’s alleged discharge or pollution.

Before the court in this case was the ski resort’s Motion to Consolidate its two (2) lawsuits “for all purposes.”

Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas reviewed the Motion under the applicable standards set forth pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 213(a), regarding consolidation of actions. 

The court noted that matters may be consolidated where they involve common questions of law or fact or arise from the same occurrence. The court found that this standard was met by the allegations in the two (2) lawsuits at issue in this case. The court also noted that consolidation of the matters would reduce the parties’ litigation expenses, would avoid duplicate trials, and would promote judicial economy.

However, the court rejected the request for a “complete consolidation” of the separate actions “for all purposes” as there was not a complete identity of parties, claims, defenses, and issues as required by the law. 

The court also noted that the Plaintiff was seeking different relief in each action in that the first tort action sought a monetary relief from a jury, whereas the second nuisance action sought an abatement remedy from a judge and did not require a finding of negligent fault and which involved different elements of proof.

Given that the claims, defenses, and legal issues in both matters were not identical, the request for a complete consolidation for all purposes was denied.

In the end, the court granted the resort’s request to consolidate the actions for purposes of discovery and trial but noted that each action would retain its separate identity and require its own judgment.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Monday, January 17, 2022

Mock Trial Jurors Needed -- Please Help!

 


Doctrine of In Pari Delicto Reviewed by Pennsylvania Supreme Court


In the case of Albert v. Sheeley’s Drug Store, Inc., No. 5 MAP 2021 (Pa. Dec. 22, 2021) (Maj. Op. by Wecht, J.)(Dissenting Op. by Dougherty, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed the issue of whether claims brought against a pharmacy on behalf of a decedent who overdosed on illegally obtained prescription drugs are barred by the doctrine of in pari delicto.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that the trial court in Lackawanna County correctly applied the in pari delicto doctrine and, as such, the lower court’s decision was affirmed.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff’s decedent was struggling with substance abuse issues.  The decedent had a friend who had a mother who was suffering from blood cancer. The friend’s mother had been prescribed several opioid pain medications which she filled at a particular pharmacy. Family members called the drug store and placed a restriction on who could pick up the mother’s prescriptions.

The decedent and/or his friend allegedly were allowed by the pharmacy to pick up the sick mother's medication.  The decedent then allegedly ingested some of that medication and allegedly passed away as a result.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court noted that the doctrine of in pari delicto is an equitable doctrine that precludes plaintiffs from recovering damages if their cause of action is based, at least partially, on their own illegal conduct. Other jurisdictions call this doctrine the wrongful conduct rule. The Latin phrase translates to English to “in equal fault.”

The rule of the doctrine is rooted in the theory that the court should not lend their aid to a Plaintiff whose cause of action stems from his or her own illegal conduct.

The trial court below in this matter entered judgment for the pharmacy concluding that the in pari delicto doctrine barred recovery given that the decedent’s death was caused, at least partially, by his own criminal conduct, i.e., possessing and consuming a controlled substance that was not prescribed to him.

After reviewing the case before it, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court found that the lower courts had correctly applied the in pari delicto on the facts presented.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Majority Opinion by Justice Wecht may click this LINK.  The Dissenting Opinion by Justice Dougherty may be viewed HERE.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck for bringing this case to my attention.


Source of image:  Photo by Markus Winkler on Unsplash.com.

Thursday, January 13, 2022

Coverage Found Under a Homeowner's Policy For a Drug Overdose at a House Party


In the case of Kramer v. Nationwide Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co., No. 726 EDA 2021 (Pa. Super. Dec. 2, 2021 Lazarus, J., Dubow, J., and Pellegrini, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed an insurance coverage action arising out of an incident during which the insured’s son hosted a house party at his parents’ home while they were out of town. Early in the morning thereafter, the decedent partygoer was found dead and a coroner later determined that the cause of death was a drug overdose.

The decedent’s mother filed a wrongful death and survival action against the homeowners and their son. The Plaintiffs asserted that the son who hosted the party was negligent in supplying the decedent with the drugs that caused his overdose. The Plaintiffs also allege in both the survival and wrongful death claims that the homeowners were negligent in allowing their son to use the home in such regard.

At the time of the incident, Nationwide was the insurance company for the parents at whose house the party was held. Nationwide denied coverage under the case presented.

According to the Opinion, the insurane policy at issue provided that Nationwide must “pay damages and insured is legally obligated to pay due to an occurrence resulting from negligent personal acts or negligence arising out of the ownership, maintenance, or use of real or personal property.”

In asserting that it did not have to provide a defense, Nationwide relied upon coverage exclusions in the policy which applied when certain damages arise from criminal conduct or the use of controlled substances.

The trial court had ruled that Nationwide had a duty to defend and the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed this decision.

Although the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed the policy exclusion noted above, it ruled, in part, that the carrier was required to defend its insured in this suit arising from an alleged accidental drug overdose death because the damages under the Wrongful Death Act did not implicate the term “bodily injury” under the policy definitions.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Matthew D. Vodzak of the Philadelphia office of Fowler Hirtzel McNulty & Spaulding, LLP for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, January 10, 2022

Corrected Link to Capenos v. Greentree Hardware Case

 

Here is the corrected LINK for the case of Capenos v. Greentree Hardware & Electric, Inc., No. GD-20-010087 (Dec. 17, 2021 Ignelzi, J.), highlighted on Tort Talk yesterday, in which the court issued an Order ruling that surveillance footage of an automobile accident was required to be produced to Plaintiff’s counsel prior to the completion of the Plaintiff’s deposition.


Sorry for the faulty Link yesterday and thank you for reading Tort Talk.

Trial Court Judge Rules That Defense Must Produce Video of Accident Before Plaintiff's Deposition


In the case of Capenos v. Greentree Hardware & Electric, Inc., No. GD-20-010087 (C.P. Alleg. Co. Dec. 17, 2021 Ignelzi, J.), the court issued an Order ruling that surveillance footage of an automobile accident was required to be produced to Plaintiff’s counsel prior to the completion of the Plaintiff’s deposition.

According to one of the litigating attorneys, it does not appear that there is any Pennsylvania state appellate court decision on this particular issue.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK


I send thanks to Attorney Brad D. Trust, Esquire of the Pittsburgh law office of Edgar Snyder & Associates, LLC for bringing this Order to my attention.

Source of image: Photo by Pawel Czerwinski of Unsplash.





Thursday, January 6, 2022

Corrected Link to Jefferson v. Lias Qualified Immunity Case

Yesterday, the case Third Circuit Court of Appeals case of Jefferson v. Lias, No. 20-2526 (3d. Cir. Dec. 16, 2021)(Maj. Op. by Restrepo, J.), was reviewed here on Tort Talk.

In that case the Third Circuit Court of Appeals addressed the circumstances under which a Defendant police officer may be entitled to qualified immunity under a civil rights action brought under 42 U.S.C. §1983.

Here is the corrected LINK for that decision.

I apologize for any confusion that may have been caused by the faulty original link.