Thursday, January 6, 2022

Section 1983 Claims Allowed to Proceed Against Police Officers


In the case of Estate of Ronald Singletary v. City of Philadelphia, No. 2:19-CV-00190-JMY (E.D. Pa. Nov. 10, 2021 Young, J.), the court granted in part and denied in part, a Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Defendant police officers and the City of Philadelphia for summary judgment in response to the Plaintiff’s §1983 excessive force, failure to train, and state-created danger cause of action.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff alleged that the officer shot the Plaintiff’s decedent while trying to arrest him for contempt of court.

In reviewing the record before it, the court found that there was sufficient evidence to show that the officers’ conduct amounted to excessive force and was the proximate cause of the Plaintiff’s death.

However, the court dismissed the claims of municipal liability and state-created danger.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Dec. 3, 2021).


Source of image:  Photo by Michael Fortsch on www.unsplash.com.



Third Circuit Court of Appeals Addresses Qualified Immunity for Police Officers in Civil Rights Actions


In the case Third Circuit Court of Appeals case of Jefferson v. Lias, No. 20-2526 (3d. Cir. Dec. 16, 2021)(Maj. Op. by Restrepo, J.), the Court addressed the circumstances under which a Defendant police officer may be entitled to qualified immunity under a civil rights action brought under 42 U.S.C. §1983.

In this case, the district court had granted a Defendant police officer’s summary judgment motion as to the alleged use of excessive  force in violation of the Fourth Amendment. The city was also granted summary judgment as to the Plaintiff’s alleged Monell claims. 

At the lower court level, the court found that the Defendant police officer’s use of deadly force was reasonable under the circumstances, but that, even assuming it was not, the police officer was shielded from liability in any event by the doctrine of qualified immunity because his actions did not violate any  clearly established law.

On appeal, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals found that the district court had improperly weighed evidence in determining that the Plaintiff allegedly presented a danger to those in the area based upon his escape and the court found that there were factual issues to be decided by the jury.

The Third Circuit Court of Appeals then also discussed the doctrine of qualified immunity and provided clarification as to how it should be determined whether a right at issue is clearly established at the time of the alleged violation.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK

Wednesday, January 5, 2022

Pennsylvania Superior Court Addresses Validity of a Concise Statement of Matters Complained of on Appeal; Also Upholds Exculpatory Clause in a Lease


In the case of Keystone Specialty Services Co. v. Ebaugh, No. 1289 WDA 2020 (Pa. Super. Nov. 22, 2021 Olson, J., Nichols, J., and Collins, J.) (Op. by Collins, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the entry of summary judgment in favor of landlord Defendants in a breach of contract and negligence action that the Plaintiff filed.

The case arose out of alleged damage to equipment and other personal property that the Plaintiff stored in a building owned by the landlord. The Plaintiff’s property allegedly sustained water damage from water flowing from a broken pipe in the building.

The landlord Defendants asserted that exculpatory provisions in the lease agreement protected the landlords from any liability exposure. The trial court entered summary judgment on the basis of the exculpatory clauses and the Plaintiff eventually appealed.

With regard to an appellate procedure issue of note, the court found fault with the Plaintiff’s sparse Concise Statement of Errors Complained of on Appeal required by Pa. R.A.P. 1925(b). The Plaintiff had responded that it was unable to discern from the lower court’s Order as to the reasons relied upon by the trial court in entering its decision.

In this regard, the Pennsylvania Superior Court noted that, if a party feels that it cannot discern the basis for the trial court’s Order sufficiently in order to identify the issues that the party intends to raise on appeal, the party is required to preface the [Rule 1925(b)] Statement with an explanation as to why the Statement has identified the errors only in general terms.  See Pa. R.A.P. 1925(b)(4)(i).

On this basis, in terms of the Plaintiff’s failures with its Concise Statement, the court found that the Plaintiff’s appeal was barred by the Doctrine of Waiver. The Pennsylvania Superior Court also went on to note that the Plaintiff’s appeal failed on the merits in any event.

In this regard, the court upheld the exculpatory clause relied upon by the Defendant. The court noted that exculpatory clauses and contracts are valid (1) where they do not contravene public policy, (2) where the clauses are between persons relating entirely to their own private affairs, and (3) where each party was a free bargaining agent to the agreement. See Op. at 9.

As such, the trial court’s entry of summary judgment was affirmed by the Pennsylvania Superior Court for these multiple reasons noted.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rules That a Plaintiff Can Rely on Both Concrete Evidence and Doctrine of Res Ipsa Loquitur to Prove Negligence in the Same Case


In the Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision of Lageman v. Zepp, No. 21 MAP 2021 (Pa. Dec. 22, 2021) (Op. by Wecht, J.), the Court thoroughly addressed the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur and its continuing validity in Pennsylvania.

The court noted that the American law translation of that phrase is “the thing speaks for itself.”

Justice Wecht noted in his Opinion that the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur has been recognized in Pennsylvania as allowing for a category of circumstantial evidence which may suffice to establish negligence where more specific and concrete evidence of the events leading up to the injury eludes even diligent investigation. 

In essence, the doctrine was noted to recognize that one may conclude by the exercise of common sense that an injury could not have occurred under certain circumstances but for the negligence of another person even where that negligence cannot be concretely proven. 

Justice Wecht opened his engaging Opinion with the example of a Plaintiff walking on a public street and passing a Defendant’s shop at which point a barrel of flour fell upon the Plaintiff from a window above, resulting in serious injuries to the pedestrian Plaintiff.  The Court noted that this set of facts represented a classic example of when the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur should be applied.

This Lageman case arose out of a medical malpractice action. The issue before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court was whether the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur is precluded in a case where the Plaintiff has allegedly introduced enough “direct” evidence of the Defendant's negligence such that the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur is not the only avenue towards a finding of liability.   In other words, whether the two (2) approaches to satisfying the Plaintiff’s evidentiary burden of proof are mutually exclusive. 

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that these avenues of satisfying the Plaintiff's burden of proof are not mutually exclusive and that, therefore, the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur may still apply even in a case where a Plaintiff has also produced direct evidence of negligence on the part of a Defendant.

In so ruling, the Majority of the Court noted that it has long been the law of Pennsylvania that a Plaintiff has no obligation to choose one theory of liability to the exclusion of another. The Court reasoned that permitting a Plaintiff to present direct evidence while simultaneously invoking the res ipsa loquitur doctrine will only disadvantage a Defendant as to whom the claims becomes more facially meritorious as more competent evidence emerges.

The Court did note that, a Plaintiff must still make out a prima facie case to support a res ipsa loquitur jury instruction. In other words, a Plaintiff must prove that he or she has been injured by a casualty of a sort that normally would not have occurred but for negligence on the part of a Defendant.

In this regard, the Court noted that the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur would obviously apply in the case of where a surgeon leaves a sponge in a patient and sews up the patient at the end of a surgery, an injury would seemingly not occur in the absence of negligence. 

Where, however, a jury is presented with two (2) versions of the event through conflicting evidence and may decide, based upon that evidence, what, in fact, occurred to lead to the injury, then perhaps the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur would not be applicable. 

Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Majority decision written by Justice Wecht may click this LINK.  The Concurring and Dissenting Opinion by Chief Justice Baer can be viewed HERE.  The Dissenting Opinion by Justice Saylor can be viewed HERE.


I send thanks to Attorney Dale G. Larrimore of the Philadelphia law firm of Larrimore & Farnish, LLP for bringing this case to my attention.

Source of image:  Photo by Karolina Grabowska from www.pexels.com.

Tuesday, January 4, 2022

A Nice Primer on the Hearsay Rule

Here's a decision that gives a nice reminder of how the rules of hearsay work in a trial setting.

In the case of Nitkin v. Main Line Health, No. 2:20-CV-04825-KSM (E.D. Pa. Oct. 26, 2021), the Federal District Court in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania ruled that notes taken by the medical director of the Plaintiff’s former employer were non-hearsay and, as such, were deemed to be admissible as they fell within the party-opponent exclusion found under F. R.E. 801(d)(2)(D).

The Court noted that F.R.E. 801(d)(2)(D) allows for the admission of statements made by an employer’s agent or employee on matters within the scope of that relationship and while that relationship existed.

With regards to some other out-of-court statements, the Court rejected the argument that such statements were not being offered for the truth of the matter asserted within the statements and, therefore, were admissible.  In reviewing the potential evidence within the context of the case, the Court ruled that it appeared that the statements would be offered for the truth of the matter and were, therefore, inadmissible as hearsay.

Based upon this ruling, the court denied in part, and granted in part, the Defendant’s Motion In Limine.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Nov. 18, 2021).




Motion to Remand Regular Use Exclusion Issues Back to State Court Denied


In the case of Dayton v. The Auto Ins. Co. of Hartford, Conn., No. CV-3:20-1833 (M.D. Pa. Nov. 5, 2021 Mannion, J.), the federal court applied the Reifer factors and refused to remand this automobile insurance coverage action involving a dispute over the application of the regular use exclusion relative to the Plaintiff’s underinsured motorist coverage. 

The court found that, as of the date of its decision in this case, the law of Pennsylvania and regular use exclusion was settled and, as such, this issue did not constitute a reason in support of remanding the matter to the state court.

The court otherwise granted the Defendant’s carrier’s Motion to Dismiss the Complaint for failing to plead specific facts sufficient to make out a plausible bad faith claim. The court did allow the Plaintiff an opportunity to file an Amended Complaint.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Lee Applebaum of the Philadelphia law firm of Fineman Krekstein & Harris, and also the writer of the excellent Pennsylvania and New Jersey Insurance Bad Faith Case Law blog, for bringing this decision to my attention.

Source of image:  Photo by Jim Wilson on www.unsplash.com.

Monday, January 3, 2022

TORT TALK AS A RESEARCH TOOL

 


Most Tort Talkers receive their Tort Talk info by way of email. If you are not already an email subscriber to Tort Talk and would like to become one (it's FREE!), please go to Tort Talk at www.TortTalk.com and insert your email address into the Email Subscription box in the upper right hand corner of the blog and follow the instructions to complete the process.

Once you are up and running, you will automatically receive the updated posts added to Tort Talk (an average of 2-3 per week) on notable cases and trends in Pennsylvania Civil Litigation Law.

In addition to Tort Talk being a way to get free continuing updates on notable new cases and trends, it can also serve to kickstart your legal research in a streamlined fashion if you actually go to the Tort Talk site at www.TortTalk.com.  

On the site itself there are a number of research tools to help you find the case(s) or article(s) you are looking for.

Please note that Tort Talk is NOT an exhaustive legal research site--you should always supplement your research on your issue(s) presented elsewhere to ensure that you have a thorough review of the area of law in question.  Also, any case you find should be "Shepardized" to see if there has been any more recent, adverse rulings.

Here are the research tools available on Tort Talk that you can use to kickstart and streamline your research:


Search This Blog Box

The "Search This Blog" Box in the upper right hand column of the site allows readers to type in search terms or key words to look for posts on that particular topic. 

By typing in your search term in the white box (delay damages, limited tort, slip and fall, or a case name, etc.), you will be sent to a page that will list each Tort Talk post that covers that topic. You can then click on the Link in each post that comes up to read the actual decision of the court.   

If the blog post does not have a Link to the decision but instead notes that you can email me for a copy, please do not hesitate to send me an email request for a copy of the decision.


Post-Koken Scorecard

You can always access the Post-Koken Scorecard to check on the status of decisions in your county on Post-Koken issues by scrolling down the right hand column of the blog and clicking on the date under the Label "Post-Koken Scorecard."


Facebook Discovery Scorecard

You can always access the Facebook Discovery Scorecard to check on the status of Pennsylvania decisions on Facebook Discovery issues by scrolling down the right hand column of the blog and clicking on the date under the Label "Facebook Discovery Scorecard."


Labels

Also further down on the right hand column of the Tort Talk blog is a section called "Labels," which is another tool that you can use to find cases or articles on a specific topic.  

The topics, or Labels, are listed in alphabetical order.  

By clicking on the Label that's specific to your research ("Bad Faith," "Limited Tort," "Future Medical Expenses," etc.) you will be sent to a page that list each and every Tort Talk post that touches upon that topic.


Published Articles

If you type the word "Article" in the Search Box on the upper right hand corner of the blog, you will get to a number of different articles on various civil litigation issues.

You can get more specific in your search for an article as well, such as typing "Article recklessness," and that will bring you to an article on that topic.


Links

Last but certainly not least, down on the right hand column is a list of "Links" I have created to other sites, including my Firm's website and other online professional profiles that I have created along with links to some other legal and non-legal-related websites that may be of interest.



Thanks again for reading Tort Talk and thanks to all who have provided tips on breaking news and cases of note. I am grateful for your interest and support.  Please feel free to send me a copy of any notable decisions you may generate in your practice for possible highlighting here on Tort Talk.

If I should be able to you help out in any way, please do not hesitate to contact me at dancummins@CumminsLaw.net.  


Please also contact me should you need any help with setting up a Mediation with Cummins Mediation Services.


(570) 319-5899

dancummins@CumminsLaw.net