Monday, January 3, 2022

TORT TALK AS A RESEARCH TOOL

 


Most Tort Talkers receive their Tort Talk info by way of email. If you are not already an email subscriber to Tort Talk and would like to become one (it's FREE!), please go to Tort Talk at www.TortTalk.com and insert your email address into the Email Subscription box in the upper right hand corner of the blog and follow the instructions to complete the process.

Once you are up and running, you will automatically receive the updated posts added to Tort Talk (an average of 2-3 per week) on notable cases and trends in Pennsylvania Civil Litigation Law.

In addition to Tort Talk being a way to get free continuing updates on notable new cases and trends, it can also serve to kickstart your legal research in a streamlined fashion if you actually go to the Tort Talk site at www.TortTalk.com.  

On the site itself there are a number of research tools to help you find the case(s) or article(s) you are looking for.

Please note that Tort Talk is NOT an exhaustive legal research site--you should always supplement your research on your issue(s) presented elsewhere to ensure that you have a thorough review of the area of law in question.  Also, any case you find should be "Shepardized" to see if there has been any more recent, adverse rulings.

Here are the research tools available on Tort Talk that you can use to kickstart and streamline your research:


Search This Blog Box

The "Search This Blog" Box in the upper right hand column of the site allows readers to type in search terms or key words to look for posts on that particular topic. 

By typing in your search term in the white box (delay damages, limited tort, slip and fall, or a case name, etc.), you will be sent to a page that will list each Tort Talk post that covers that topic. You can then click on the Link in each post that comes up to read the actual decision of the court.   

If the blog post does not have a Link to the decision but instead notes that you can email me for a copy, please do not hesitate to send me an email request for a copy of the decision.


Post-Koken Scorecard

You can always access the Post-Koken Scorecard to check on the status of decisions in your county on Post-Koken issues by scrolling down the right hand column of the blog and clicking on the date under the Label "Post-Koken Scorecard."


Facebook Discovery Scorecard

You can always access the Facebook Discovery Scorecard to check on the status of Pennsylvania decisions on Facebook Discovery issues by scrolling down the right hand column of the blog and clicking on the date under the Label "Facebook Discovery Scorecard."


Labels

Also further down on the right hand column of the Tort Talk blog is a section called "Labels," which is another tool that you can use to find cases or articles on a specific topic.  

The topics, or Labels, are listed in alphabetical order.  

By clicking on the Label that's specific to your research ("Bad Faith," "Limited Tort," "Future Medical Expenses," etc.) you will be sent to a page that list each and every Tort Talk post that touches upon that topic.


Published Articles

If you type the word "Article" in the Search Box on the upper right hand corner of the blog, you will get to a number of different articles on various civil litigation issues.

You can get more specific in your search for an article as well, such as typing "Article recklessness," and that will bring you to an article on that topic.


Links

Last but certainly not least, down on the right hand column is a list of "Links" I have created to other sites, including my Firm's website and other online professional profiles that I have created along with links to some other legal and non-legal-related websites that may be of interest.



Thanks again for reading Tort Talk and thanks to all who have provided tips on breaking news and cases of note. I am grateful for your interest and support.  Please feel free to send me a copy of any notable decisions you may generate in your practice for possible highlighting here on Tort Talk.

If I should be able to you help out in any way, please do not hesitate to contact me at dancummins@CumminsLaw.net.  


Please also contact me should you need any help with setting up a Mediation with Cummins Mediation Services.


(570) 319-5899

dancummins@CumminsLaw.net



Thursday, December 30, 2021

HAPPY NEW YEAR FROM TORT TALK

 


SENDING BEST WISHES FOR A
HAPPY NEW YEAR 
TO
YOU AND YOUR FAMILY


Link to Compilation of COVID-19 Business Interruption Coverage Cases Nationwide

 


The University of Pennsylvania School of Law has been tracking COVID-19 Business Interruption Coverage cases on a nationwide basis. That compilation can be found at this Link:  

https://cclt.law.upenn.edu/.

Motion To Remand Denied in COVID-19 Business Interruption Coverage Case


In the case of Greenwood Racing, Inc. v. American Guar. & Liability Ins. Co., No. 2:21-CV-01682-GJP (E.D. Pa. Oct. 20, 2021 Pappert, J.), the court denied a Motion by a Plaintiff to remand a case back to state court from federal court in a matter involving a declaratory judgment action on business interruption coverage issues related to the COVID-19 pandemic.
The entity involved is a casino and racetrack.   

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff had initially filed the matter in a state court seeking a judicial declaration that their insurers were required to insure losses sustained by the Plaintiff as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. The carrier removed the case to federal court and the Plaintiff moved to remand the case back.

The court noted that it was denying the motion in light of recent guidance from the Third Circuit Court of Appeals on the standard of review applicable to motions to remand as set forth in the case of DiAnoia’s Eatery, LLC v. Motorists Mut. Ins. Co., 10 F.4th 192 (3d Cir. 2021).

After reviewing the recent decision by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, the federal trial court in this Greenwood declined to remand this declaratory judgment coverage action back to the state court where the federal court found that the case did not involve any novel issues of state law and where there was no parallel state proceeding pending. As such, the Plaintiff’s Motion to Remand was denied.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this October 20, 2021 decision on the motion to remand may click this LINK.


And here is another LINK, this one to the same Court's November 1, 2021 dismissing the Complaint before it after finding that the allegations of the Plaintiff's Complaint primarily seeking coverage under the pollution event clause was vague and speculative.  Leave to amend was granted.  The companion Order to that decision can be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Nov. 18, 2021).

Source of image:  Photo by Drew Rae from www.pexels.com.

COVID-19 Business Interruption Coverage Claims by Medical Practice Dismissed by Pennsylvania Federal Court


In the case of Delaware Mgmt., LLC v. Continental Cas. Co., No. 2:20-CV-4309 (E.D. Pa. Nov. 11, 2021 Goldberg, J.), the court ruled that the insureds were not entitled to business interruption coverage for economic losses allegedly sustained due to COVID-19 Executive Orders where the coverage under the policy was only triggered by physical damage or loss of covered property. The court found that the Plaintiff had not pled any such damages or losses.

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiffs before the court owned and operated a group of thirteen (13) affiliated medical practices.

The court noted that the Plaintiffs’ facilities remained opened during the duration of the Executive Orders, although the operations of the business were limited. The court rejected the Plaintiffs’ interpretation of “loss” to include a partial loss of use of their facilities.

The court also rejected the Plaintiffs’ argument that the public fear of indoor establishments due to COVID-19 caused a “physical loss of or damage to” the property in order to trigger coverage. Rather, the court held that the physical loss of damage language in the policy required a tangible physical alteration of the property itself.

The court additionally ruled that the civil authority endorsement did not provide the Plaintiff with coverage as the endorsement required that the civil action be taken in response to any physical loss or physical damage. Because the Plaintiff had not alleged any such loss or damage to their property or to any nearby properties the court ruled that the Plaintiff could not rely upon the civil authority endorsement in this case.

Also, in footnote 1 of the Opinion, the court notably indicated that the University of Pennsylvania School of Law has been tracking these cases on a nationwide basis. That compilation can be found at this Link:  https://cclt.law.upenn.edu/.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  The Court's companion Order can be viewed HERE.


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Dec. 3, 2021).






HAPPY NEW YEAR FROM CUMMINS MEDIATION SERVICES

 WISHING YOU A HAPPY NEW YEAR 

OF MANY AMICABLE RESOLUTIONS




COULDN'T GET THAT MEDIATION SCHEDULED DURING THE END-OF-YEAR RUSH?

PLEASE CONSIDER SCHEDULING IT NOW WITH CUMMINS MEDIATION SERVICES

(570) 319-5899 

or

dancummins@Cummins Law.Com


Wednesday, December 29, 2021

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Limits the Reach of the Jurisdictional Long-Arm Statute Over Foreign Corporations

Pennsylvania State Capitol Building
Home of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court

In the case of Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co., No. 3 EAP 2021 (Pa. Dec. 22, 2021) (Maj. Op. by Baer, C.J.)(Concurring Op. by Mundy, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court recognized that a recent decision by the United States Supreme Court precluded the exercise of general personal jurisdiction by a Pennsylvania court over a party solely on the basis of the fact that a foreign corporation had registered to do business in Pennsylvania. As such, that aspect of the Pennsylvania long-arm statute has been declared unconstitutional in this Mallory decision.

In this matter, a Virginia resident filed an action in Pennsylvania against a Virginia corporation, under an allegation of injuries sustained in Virginia and Ohio.

The Plaintiff asserted that the Pennsylvania courts have general personal jurisdiction over the case based exclusively upon the fact that the foreign corporation registered to do business in Pennsylvania. 

In this regard, the Plaintiff had relied upon 42 Pa. C.S.A. §5301(a)(2)(i). The Pennsylvania Supreme Court agreed with the trial court decision that the Pennsylvania statute, affording Pennsylvania court general personal jurisdiction over a foreign corporation that registers to do business in Pennsylvania regardless for the lack of continuous and symptomatic contacts within the state by that corporation, fails to comport with the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution.

In other words, the Court held that Pennsylvania's "statutory scheme is unconstitutional to the extent that it affords Pennsylvania courts general jurisdiction over foreign corporations that are not at home in the Commonwealth."  See Op. at p. 44.    

Anyone wishing to review a copy of the Majority Opinion of this decision may click this LINK.  The Concurring Opinion by Justice Mundy can be viewed HERE.

I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Reed Smith law firm in Philadelphia for bringing this case to my attention.


Source of image:  Photo by Andre Frueh on www.unsplash.com.