Tuesday, October 12, 2021

Superior Court Upholds Transfer of Venue Under Doctrine of Forum Non Conveniens

Headed Back to Reading


In the case of Doe v. Bright Horizons Children’s Center, LLC, No. 1733 EDA 2020 (Pa. Super. Sept 10, 2021 Bowes, J. and Musmanno, J.) (Op. by Bowes, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed a trial court’s granting of a request to transfer a case under the doctrine of forum non conveniens.

The Plaintiffs had filed suit in Philadelphia County on claims that their child had allegedly been abused at a daycare center located in Reading, Berks County, Pennsylvania.  

After reviewing the record before the court, the appellate court agreed that all relevant actions took place in Berks County over a two (2) year period. The court additionally noted that none of the parties or witnesses were located in Philadelphia where the case was filed.

The court otherwise noted that, given the logistical issues that a Philadelphia trial would entail, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in transferring venue.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney James M. Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Reed Smith law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Monday, October 11, 2021

Upcoming CLE Presentations

 

Below is a listing of upcoming virtual and live CLEs that I am participating in as a presenter.  Should you need CLE credits, I am hoping you might consider these CLEs.


October 22 - 10 a.m. - Wayne County Bench Bar Conference (LIVE ATTENDANCE ONLY, BUT MY PRESENTATION WILL BE ZOOMED IN TO THE EVENT)

"Back to School With Tort Talk:  A Civil Litigation Update" (encore presentation)

A review of the notable civil litigation decisions from around the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania as highlighted on the Tort Talk blog presented by Daniel E. Cummins of Cummins Law.

This LIVE CLE will take place at Tick Toc's On the Terrace, 760 Terrace Street, Honesdale, PA.  Although this all day CLE is a live event my presentation at 10 a.m. will be via Zoom as I am presenting at the Lackawnna Bench Bar Conference in Scranton on the same day.

Non-members are invited and welcome to attend.  The cost to attend is $50.  The price includes a light breakfast, lunch and the CLE credits.

To review the full Agenda of courses for this event and/or to register, please email the Chairman of the Wayne County Bench Bar, Attorney Joseph Rydzewski at joerr@poconolawyers.net.  Payment must be made when you arrive at the CLE.  


October 22 - Lackawanna County Bench Bar Conference (VIRTUAL)

"Best Litigation Practices in the Covid Era"

Tips for improving your practice while utilizing advanced commuication technology such as Zoom. Presented by Daniel E. Cummins of Cummins Law, Paul Oven of Dougherty, Leventhal & Price, and JP Cardoni and Leah Kane of Exhibit A. Program to be Moderated by Thomas P. Cummings of Dougherty, Leventhal & Price.  This particular presentation of the Bench Bar will be at 2:15 p.m.

Free to Lackawanna County Bar Members.

Please contact Kaitlin McDonough of the Bar Association at kmcdonough@lackawannabar.org to register.  Must register by Friday, October 15, 2021.


October 29 - Noon - Pennsylvania Defense Institute (Non-members welcome)(VIRTUAL)

"Back to School With Tort Talk:  A Civil Litigation Update" (encore presentation)

A review of the notable civil litigation decisions from around the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania as highlighted on the Tort Talk blog presented by Daniel E. Cummins of Cummins Law.

Free for PDI Members

Non-Members welcome and invited to attend; Fee for Non-Members is $35.00.


REGISTRATION AND PAYMENT METHODS:

Complete Form and mail with check (if applicable) payable to “PDI” to: Pennsylvania Defense Institute, P.O. Box 6099, Harrisburg, PA 17112 and e-mail Registration to cwasilefski@padefense.org or lgamby@padefense.org.

Register online https://us06web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_6nqKJwHUTdyKESaf4tlF4g and mail a check (if applicable) payable to “PDI” at Pennsylvania Defense Institute, P.O. Box 6099, Harrisburg, PA 17112.

Go to PDI website: www.padefense.org and register using for provided on Events Page and pay via PayPal.

Upon receipt of Registration and Fee, Registrant will receive information for joining Webinar and required submission following Webinar via e-mail.


November 4 - Luzerne County Bench Bar Conference (LIVE)

"Using Social Media as a Weapon for the Plaintiff and the Defendant"

Attorney Daniel E. Cummins of Cummins Law and Attorney Jamie Anzalone of Anzalone Law will co-present and provide an overview of the law of Pennsylvania regarding the discoverability and admissibility of social media evidence in civil litigation matters.  The presenters will also review how social media evidence has been used for the benefit of Plaintiffs and Defendants at trial.  This particular presentation will be at 1:15 p.m.

The Fee to register for Wilkes-Barre Law Library Association Members is $49 if paid by October 26th.  After that date the Fee is $69.00.

Non-members welcome and invited to attend.  Fee for Non-Members is $100 if paid by October 26th..  After October 26th, that fee for non-members jumps to $125.

You can register for this CLE through the Bar Association's website HERE.






Friday, October 8, 2021

Latest Stacking Case from Pennsylvania Superior Court


In the case of Franks v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., No. 2784 EDA 2019 (Pa. Super. Sept. 24, 2021) (en banc) (Op. by Lazarus, J.) (dissenting Op. by McCaffery, J.), a majority of an en banc Pennsylvania Superior Court panel reversed a prior three (3) judge Pennsylvania Superior Court’s panel’s decision and held that the removal of a vehicle from a policy does not constitute a purchase of coverage that requires the insured to be provided the opportunity to wave stacking in writing at the time of that removal of the vehicle.

After providing a detailed review of Pennsylvania jurisprudence on the issue of stacking under the trilogy of Sackett cases, all of which involved the issue of adding or replacing vehicles on auto insurance policies, the Court in this Franks case noted that there did not appear to be any prior decisions covering the facts of this case which involved the removal of a vehicle from a multi-vehicle policy.

In the end, the Court in this case found that the deletion of a vehicle from the policy could not be viewed in any way as a "purchase" of coverage as that term is utilized under 75 Pa.C.S.A. Section 1738 so as to trigger any need to secure new written stacking waivers.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.


I send thanks to Attorney Thomas Helbig for bringing this case to my attention via an email blast to all of his contacts.

Source of image:  Photo by James Sutton on Unsplash.com.

Thursday, October 7, 2021

UM Bad Faith Claim Regarding Disagreement Over Value of Claim Dismissed


In the case of Brown v. LM Gen. Ins. Co., No. 21-2134 (E.D. Pa. Aug. 24, 2021 Pratter, J.), the court granted a Defendant carrier’s Motion to Dismiss a Plaintiff’s bad faith claim in a UM matter after finding that the Plaintiff could not sustain a bad faith claim against the insurance company where the allegations in her Amended Complaint boiled down to a disagreement between the parties over the amount of a settlement for uninsured motorist benefits.

In this matter, the Plaintiff had alleged that the carrier, among other things, failed to conduct a medical evaluation, review the Plaintiff’s medical records, or otherwise invest the claims presented prior to offering a settlement. The Plaintiff also claimed that the carrier was dilatory in its claims handling practices when it allegedly mispresented that it would resolve the claim and then continuously and endlessly requested documentation before ignoring that documentation.

The defense argued that the Plaintiff had simply recycled the same allegations as in the initial pleading. The carrier also asserted that the Amended Complaint again came down to a claim by the Plaintiff that, because the carrier allegedly failed to offer an amount to which the Plaintiff believed she was entitled, the carrier allegedly acted in bad faith. The carrier also emphasized that there was a serious dispute in this case as to whether or not the Plaintiff was even entitled to coverage under the applicable policy.

After reviewing the current status of Pennsylvania law regarding bad faith claims, the court found that, although the Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint listed thirty-eight (38) ways in which Liberty Mutual allegedly acted in bad faith, the list was a list of conclusions, not facts. The court found that there were no details offered by the Plaintiff that would describe or was supposedly unfair about the process.

Relative to the claim that the carrier acted in a dilatory fashion, the court noted that the Plaintiff failed to meet her requirement of asserting specific facts to support that allegation such as the number of months between a demand and a settlement offer. 

The court noted that, in the end, the Amended Complaint simply reflected a disagreement between the parties over the amount of an appropriate settlement of the claims presented. The court reiterated a well-settled law that an insured must do more than allege an allegedly “low-ball” offer.

The court also emphasized that “a policy limit- -as its name suggests- -is the theoretical maximum that an insured could recover. ‘It is not the de fecto value of a claim.’” See Op. at p. 5.

Given that the Plaintiff had failed to support her claim for bad faith with facts, this claim was dismissed with prejudice.

The court also addressed the carrier’s Motion to Strike all references in the Plaintiff’s Complaint that the carrier’s conduct was reckless, wanton, and willful relative to the declaratory judgment and breach of contract claims.

The court found that, in order to prevail on a Motion to Strike allegations, the allegations must not only be unrelated to the claim presented but the moving party must show how the moving party will be prejudiced if the allegations are allowed to remain in the pleadings.

Given that the carrier failed to explain how it will be prejudiced in this matter if the challenged allegations are not stricken, the court denied the Motion to Strike. The court also noted that a bald assertion that the carrier acted willfully or recklessly is only a legal conclusion that the court need not accept as true.

Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.  


Source: “Digest of Recent Opinions.” Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Sept. 17, 2021).

Wednesday, October 6, 2021

Motion For Summary Judgment Entered in Favor of PennDOT in Pothole Case



In the case of Teixeira v. Com. of Penna., Dept. of Transp., No. 7917-CIVIL-2019 (C.P. Monroe Co. Aug. 5, 2021 Williamson, J.), Judge David J. Williamson of the Monroe County Court of Common Pleas granted the Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment in a matter involving a motorcycle accident.

The Plaintiff motorcyclist alleges that he hit a large pothole on Interstate Route 80 in Monroe County as a result of which he crashed and sustained multiple injuries.

The court noted that the issue before it concerned the pothole exception to the sovereign immunity allowed under the Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act, 42 Pa. C.S.A. §8522(b)(5). The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania asserted that it was protected from civil suits based in tort under the doctrine of sovereign immunity unless one of the ten narrow exceptions to the law apply. As noted, the Plaintiff was arguing the potholes and other dangerous conditions exception to the Act.

The court noted that a Plaintiff seeking to utilize this exception must prove that there was sufficient prior written notice provided to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania of the allegedly dangerous condition.

Here, the court accepted PennDOT’s argument that the Plaintiff failed to show that there was actual written notice provided to PennDOT of the pothole in question. 

The court noted that, while the record revealed that various complaints were called in by members of the public and reduced to writing by the PennDOT call center, those complaints identified problems with Route 80 in general and varied widely in terms of complaints with respect to the area where potholes existed. 

The court additionally noted that nothing was submitted in actual writing by the actual complainants themselves to PennDOT. 

The court additionally confirmed that none of the complaints identified in the records reference the exact pothole that was involved in this accident. Nor were any of the complaints specific to the mile marker at the location of the accident. Rather, the complaints were generally applied to Route 80 which stretches at least 20 miles through Monroe County.

As such the court found no genuine issue of material fact was presented in this case on the question at issue of whether any actual notice of the pothole in question was provided to PennDOT prior to the subject incident. As such, the court granted PennDOT’s Motion for Summary Judgment.


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.

Tuesday, October 5, 2021

Please Consider Attending 13th Annual Virtual Fundraising Gala

 



Motion To Bifurcate Lackawanna County Post-Koken Trial Denied


In the case of Nebesky v. Pagnotti, No. 2019-CV-3170 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Sept 15, 2021 Gibbons, J.), the court addressed a Motion to Bifurcate the Trial in this post-Koken automobile accident litigation. After reviewing Pa. R.C.P. 213(b) and after noting that the parties had cited two (2) court decisions at the trial court level from around the Commonwealth, this court chose to deny the Motion to Bifurcate.

Judge Gibbons noted that he believed that the attorneys involved would be able to outline their respective positions on the third party negligence claims and the UIM breach of contract claims to the jury in such a way as to avoid any confusion or prejudice. The court additionally felt that any potential prejudice to the third party Defendant in having an insurance company as a Co-Defendant could be rooted out in Voir Dire.

Judge James A. Gibbons
Lackawanna County

The Court also noted that the jury would be properly instructed on the law applicable to the negligence claims as well as the breach of contract claims.

Judge Gibbons also noted that he wished to remain consistent with the prior decisions out of Lackawanna County denying Motions to Bifurcate in post-Koken matters.


Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click this LINK.