In his recent Opinion in the case of
Borick v. Manley, No. 2013-CV-994 (C.P. Lacka. Co. April 4, 2018
Gibbons, J.), Judge James A. Gibbons of the Lackawanna County Court of Common
Pleas denied a Defendant’s Limited Tort Motion for Summary Judgment.
According to the Opinion, the defense argued that the
Plaintiff did not sustain any serious injury as a result of the accident. In support of this argument, the defense
asserted that the Plaintiff did not lose consciousness as a result of the
accident and that no airbag deployed. It was also asserted that the Plaintiff refused an ambulance at the scene of the accident. The defense additionally noted that the Plaintiff
left the scene of the accident and proceeded to drive to work, after which she
subsequently had her mother drive her to the emergency room.
The defense also asserted that the Plaintiff was diagnosed
in the emergency room with only cervical and thoracic strain injuries. Thereafter, the Plaintiff underwent
diagnostic studies, including x-rays, MRIs, and an EMG test, all of which
returned normal results.
Although the defense conceded that the Plaintiff continued to assert ongoing and chronic neck and back pain, it was the defense position
that the Plaintiff’s allegations alone coupled with a lack of long-term
diagnosis confirmed by any medical record, rendered the Plaintiff’s case barred
by her Limited Tort selection. As
additional support for its argument, the defense also pointed to its IME report.
In opposition, the Plaintiff emphasized the injuries and
treatment alleged and also asserted that the injuries sustained were serious
injuries as allegedly demonstrated by the impact of the accident upon the
Plaintiff’s life. In particular, the
Plaintiff asserted that, following the accident, she was unable to work in her
position as a pharmacy technician and/or as a bartender, given that she was
allegedly no longer able to remain on her feet for extended periods of time due
to her injuries. The Plaintiff
additionally noted difficulties in driving, lifting, exercising, performing
household activities, walking her dog, and other activities of daily living.
 |
Judge James A. Gibbons
Lackawanna County |
Based upon the record before it, and viewing the evidence in
a light most favorable to the non-moving party as required by the Motion for
Summary Judgment standard of review, Judge Gibbons found that genuine issues of
material fact existed as to whether the Plaintiff sustained a serious
injury.
As such, the court denied the
Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment and allowed the case to proceed to
trial.
Anyone wishing to review a copy of this decision may click
this
LINK.