Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Rule 1925 Opinion Issued in Stepanovich Post-Koken Case

The Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas has issued its Rule 1925 Opinion in a Post-Koken case that's on its way up the appellate ladder to the Superior Court - Stepanovich v. McGraw and State Farm, No. GD 10-16523 (C.P. Allegh. Co. Dec. 10, 2012).
 
At trial, both the tortfeasor defendant's defense counsel and the UIM defense counsel defended the case--with two openings, two direct exams, two cross-exams, two closing arguments, etc.--without the jury ever being informed as to the involvement of State Farm as a UIM defendant.  A defense verdict was entered by the jury.
 
The trial court judge granted the Plaintiff a new trial after ruling, on post-trial motions, that, upon further reflection, his decision not to allow an identification of the UIM insurance company defendant at trial while still allowing two defense attorneys to defend the matter violated the Plaintiff's due process rights.
 
State Farm appealed and the Stepanovich court has now issued its Rule 1925 Opinion outlining its reasoning behind the granting of a new trial in this matter.
 
Anyone wishing to review this decision may click this LINK.

I send thanks to Attorney Tim McNair from Erie, PA, as well as to Attorney Tom McDonnell from Pittsburgh PA, for bringing this Opinion to my attention.

Monday, December 10, 2012

Summary Judgment Affirmed in Slip and Fall Case

In its recent decision in the case of Alexander v. City of Meadville, No. 664 WDA 2012 (Pa. Super. Nov. 5, 2012 Stevens, P.J., Musmanno, and Allen, J.J.) (Opinion by Allen, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the trial court’s entry of judgment in favor of the Defendants in a slip and fall case.  

According to the Opinion, the Plaintiff slipped and fell on a smooth patch of ice that was covered by approximately 1 to 2 inches of snow on a ramp located on a sidewalk.  

The Superior Court addressed the liability of a municipality and the owner of land adjacent to a public sidewalk in a downtown business district area for injuries sustained by a licensee who allegedly fell while walking on a ADA sidewalk apron or ramp.   The Plaintiff was allegedly channeled to the apron by built-up long-standing ice and snow which was allegedly deposited by both owners shoveling the sidewalk and city trucks plowing adjacent streets. 

The court in this Alexander case covered a variety of subjects including the duties of possessors of land to licensees, the question of notice, the hills and ridges doctrine, the applicability of a municipal “Sidewalk Ordinance,” and the application of the Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act. 

As noted, the court ultimately affirmed summary judgment in favor of both the municipality and the owner of the commercial property.  

Although this case was originally issued as a non-precedential decision, after a motion filed by defense counsel, the Superior Court agreed to reproduce this Opinion as a published, and therefore, precedential Opinion.

Anyone wishing to review this Opinion may click HERE.  

I send thanks to Attorney Mark E. Mioduszewski of the Erie, Pennsylvania law firm of Marnen, Mioduszewski, Bordonaro, Wagner & Sinnott, LLC, who represented Defendant, Patron’s Mutual Insurance Company.  Attorney Mioduszewski noted that the Defendant, City of Meadville, was represented by Bruce Decker of MacDonald, Illig, Jones & Britton, also of Erie, Pennsylvania.

Friday, December 7, 2012

Reportedly the Largest Allegheny County Verdict Ever Handed Down by Jury

Here is a link to an article reporting on what was allegedly the largest civil litigation personal injury verdict ever handed down in an Allegheny County case -  $109 million dollars was awarded by a jury in a negligent electrocution wrongful death suit:

http://www.post-gazette.com/stories/local/neighborhoods-east/family-wins-109-judgment-in-irwin-electrocution-death-665231/

I send thanks to Attorney William Byrne of the Wilkes-Barre, PA law firm of Hoegen & Associates for the tip.

Thursday, December 6, 2012

Two Recent Premises Liability Decisions of Note from Judge Zulick of Monroe County

 Koeppel v. PNC Bank, N.A.

In his recent decision in the case of Koeppel v. PNC Bank, N.A., PICS Case No. 12-2203 (C.P. Monroe Co. Oct. 11, 2012 Zulick, J.), Judge Arthur L. Zulick of the Monroe County Court of Common Pleas found that the hills and ridges doctrine barred a Plaintiff’s negligence claim as the Plaintiff failed to present evidence that the Defendants allowed for an accumulation “in ridges or elevations of such size and character as to unreasonably obstruct travel and constitute a danger to pedestrians[.]”  As such, the Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment was granted.  

 By way of background the Plaintiffs alleged personal injuries after falling in the parking lot of the PNC Bank in Tannersville, Pennsylvania.   The record before the court was that an ice storm had passed through the area the evening before.  

Judge Zulick noted that the hills and ridges doctrine protects the possessor of land from liability for generally slippery conditions caused by ice and snowfall where the owner has not permitted the ice and/or snow to unreasonably accumulate into ridges and elevations.   It was also noted that, in order for the hills and ridges defense to apply, there must be generally icy or snowy conditions naturally arising in the area and the possessor of land must not have allowed the ice and/or snow to have accumulated into ridges and elevations.   The court emphasized that the accumulation at issue must be the result of an entirely natural occurrence, as opposed to any man made condition, for the defense to apply.  

 In this matter, the Plaintiff argued, relying upon Harvey v. Rouse Chamberlain, Ltd., 901 A.2d 523 (Pa. Super. 2006), that the hills and ridges doctrine did not apply because the accumulation at issue was not a natural occurrence, but rather, was allegedly due to the Defendant’s snow removal efforts prior to her accident.  

 In this matter, Judge Zulick found that the Plaintiff did not bring forth any evidence that the Defendants’ snow removal efforts led to the slippery conditions at issue.   Judge Zulick found the case before him to be more in line with the case of Beck v. Holly Tree Homeowners Ass’n., 689 F.Supp 2d 756 (E.D. Pa. 2001).  In this case, as in Beck, there was no evidence that the ice upon which the Plaintiff fell was formed as a result of any snow plowing efforts by the Defendant.  

 Accordingly, summary judgment was entered in favor of the defense.
This case has been appealed to the Superior Court.
Anyone desiring a copy of this decision may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Judge Arthur L. Zulick
Monroe County
Yohey v. Crupi
In his recent decision in the case of Yohey v. Crupi, PICS Case No. 12-2201 (C.P. Monroe Co. Oct. 16, 2012 Zulick, J.), Judge Arthur L. Zulick of the Monroe County Court of Common Pleas entered summary judgment in favor of a Defendant after finding that a one-half inch differential in the elevation of the sidewalk where the Plaintiff fell amounted to only a trivial defect for which the Defendants were not liable under any claim of negligence.   

At the time of the incident, the Plaintiff was leaving a pizza shop under rainy conditions.   Other patrons were running towards the restaurant to escape the rain.  The Plaintiff stepped to the right in order to make room for the oncoming patrons.   As she moved, the Plaintiff stepped on to an uneven portion of the pavement and fell.    

The court noted that, during her deposition testimony, the Plaintiff admitted that she was not looking where she was stepping and did not see what caused her to fall.   However, the Plaintiff’s daughter, who was present at the time of the incident, was able to identify the location of the fall by pointing to a photograph during her deposition  testimony.   The court noted that one portion of the sidewalk was one half inch vertically lower than the surrounding sidewalk in the area of the Plaintiff's alleged fall. 

In response to the Defendant’s trivial defect defense, the Plaintiffs asserted that the Defendants’ alleged negligence was an issue to be determined by a jury.  

Judge Zulick noted the law that “[a]n elevation, depression, or irregularity in a sidewalk may be so trivial that the court, as a matter of law, is bound to hold that there was no negligence in permitting it to exist.”   The court also noted that there was no definite or mathematically rule that determines whether or to a defect is trivial.   Rather, each case must be determined upon its own merits. 

Judge Zulick stated that “appellate courts have found that sidewalk imperfections greater in depth and overall size than at issue here were insufficient to impose liability as a matter of law.”   citing Davis, Bosack v. Pittsburgh Railways Co., 189 A.2d 877 (Pa. 1963) [and other cases].  

In concluding his Opinion and granting summary judgment in favor of the defense, the court noted that “A pedestrian should not expect a perfectly level walking surface on a sidewalk in the Poconos.”  

This case has been appealed up to the Superior Court.

Anyone desiring a copy of Judge Zulick's Opinion in the case of Yohey v. Crupi may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.



Source: "Case Digests," Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Nov. 27, 2012).

Judge Minora of Lackawanna County Allows Addition of Punitive Damages Allegations After Expiration of Statute of Limitations

In his recent decision in the case of Strain v. Cianni, PICS Case No. 12-2200 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Nov. 5, 2012 Minora, J.), Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas Judge Carmen D. Minora allowed a Plaintiff to amend the Complaint to add punitive damages after the statute of limitations had run where the Plaintiff had already previously asserted in the original Complaint allegations of willful, wanton, and reckless conduct. 

Judge Carmen D. Minora
Lackawanna County
In the decision granting the Plaintiff’s Motion to Amend, the court ruled that the punitive damages claim in this matter was not a new cause of action and the Defendants would not be prejudice by the allowance of the amendment. 

 In this case arising out of a claim for wrongful death and survival action pertaining to the death of a decedent under allegations that her death was preventable but that the Defendants allegedly did not monitor or respond to her illness in an appropriate manner, the Plaintiff had originally filed a Complaint containing allegations of willful, wanton, and reckless conduct.   The Plaintiffs were seeking to amend their Complaint to specifically add the claim of punitive damages in an effort to avoid confusion.  

 Applying Pa. R.C.P.  1033, the court determined that there would be no statute of limitations issue regarding the addition of further allegations necessary to specifically state the claim of punitive damages where the original Complaint adequately plead the underlying averments required.  

Here, the court found that the proposed amendment did not change the cause of action but merely amplified what had already been averred.   As such, the fact that the statute of limitations had expired was of no moment under these circumstances.  

The court also noted that the Plaintiff’s amendment would not prejudice the Defendant because a request for punitive damages did not constitute a cause of action but was merely incidental to a previously stated cause of action.

Accordingly, the Plaintiff’s Motion to Amend was permitted.

Anyone desiring a copy of Judge Minora's decision in Strain v. Cianni may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Source:  "Case Digests."  Pennsylvania Law Weekly (Nov. 27, 2012).

Judge Nealon Applies Attorney's Fees Statute

In his recent decision in the case of Lilac Meadows Inc. v. Panko, No. 2011-CV-4375 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Nov. 9, 2012 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas addressed a Defendant’s request for counsel’s fees after the Defendant’s demurrer to the Plaintiff’s Complaint was sustained. The Defendant’s request for counsel’s fees was based upon an argument that the Plaintiff had acted arbitrarily, vexatiously and in bad faith in filing the suit against the prevailing Defendant.

The court's decision was governed by the attorney’s fees statute found at 42 Pa. C.S.A. §2503(9).  Section 2503(9) of the judicial code provides for the recovery of counsel fees as part of taxable costs where “the
conduct of an other party in commencing the matter or otherwise was arbitrary, vexatious, or in bad faith.”

Judge Terrence R. Nealon
Lackawanna County
Judge Nealon noted that, because §2503(9) “reads in the disjunctive,” a trial court need only finds that one of the statutory factors was present, i.e., that the action was initiated arbitrarily, vexatiously, or in bad faith. [citation omitted].

The Court noted that a litigant’s conduct could be deemed to be “arbitrary” under §2503(9) “if such conduct is based on random or convenient selection or choice rather than on reason or nature.” [citations omitted].

The Court stated that a party is considered to have brought a suit “vexatiously” if (1) the suit was filed without sufficient ground in either law or in fact, and (2) the suit served the sole purpose of causing annoyance. [citations omitted].

Judge Nealon also pointed to case law holding that a party is chargeable with filing a lawsuit in “bad faith” if the party commences suit for the purposes of fraud, dishonesty, or corruption. [citations omitted].

After applying the law to the record before it, the Court ruled that the Defendant had not satisfied its burden of establishing that the Plaintiff’s actions in filing and pursuing the claim at issue were either arbitrary, vexatious, or in bad faith. Accordingly, the Petition for Attorney’s Fees was denied.

Anyone desiring a copy of this decision may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

PLEASE MARK YOUR CALENDAR FOR THE TORT TALK EXPO 2013

Please consider breaking in your new 2013 calendars by marking down the Tort Talk Expo 2013 CLE Seminar set to take place at the Mohegan Sun Casino in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania on April 18, 2013.  Here are the details:



TORT TALK EXPO 2013 CLE SEMINAR


Presented by
and



Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
FOLEY, COMERFORD & CUMMINS


at the


MOHEGAN SUN CASINO at POCONO DOWNS


Thursday, April 18, 2013


12:30 p.m. to 4:30 p.m.


2 Substantive & 1 Ethics CLE Credits


Followed by Cocktail Hour (4:30 – 6:30 p.m.) at Breakers in the Mohegan Sun



CLE CREDITS - DOOR PRIZES – RAFFLE PRIZES – NETWORKING OPPORTUNITIES




12:30 – 1:00 pm: REGISTRATION



1:00 – 2:30 pm: THE BIG 80s: AN UPDATE WITH A 1980s FLAVOR



--1:00 – 1:45 pm: THE TORT TALK AUTO LAW UPDATE
Presenter:
Daniel E. Cummins, Esq.
Foley, Comerford & Cummins

--1:45 – 2:30 pm: THE TORT TALK CIVIL LITIGATION UPDATE
Presenters:
Malcolm L. MacGregor, Esq.
Michael J. McDonald, Esq.
McDonald & MacGregor Law Firm




2:30 – 2:45 pm: BREAK


2:45 - 3:45 pm: DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT OF SHOULDER AND KNEE INJURIES
Presenter:
Dr. John Kline, Physiatrist
Northeastern Rehabilitation Associates


3:45 – 4:00 pm: BREAK


4:00 – 4:30 pm: A VIEW FROM THE BENCH: CANDOR WITH THE COURT AT SETTLEMENT CONFERENCES
Presenters:
Lackawanna County Judge Carmen D. Minora
Luzerne County Judge Michael T. Vough



COMPLIMENTARY COCKTAIL RECEPTION
TO FOLLOW AT BREAKERS


COST:

CLAIMS PROFESSIONALS - $25.00

ATTORNEYS - $175.00

Contact Dan Cummins at dancummins@comcast.net or 570-346-0745
for more information or to register.