Thursday, September 29, 2011

Powell Sentencing Set for November 4th

Here is a link to a September 29, 2011 article from Dave Janoski in the Citizen's Voice regarding the November 4, 2011 sentencing date set for Attorney Robert Powell relative to his involvement in the Luzerne County matters:

http://citizensvoice.com/powell-kids-for-cash-sentencing-set-for-nov-4-1.1210843#axzz1ZN6uxEP5

Defense Verdict After 7 Week Trial in Federal Middle District (Wilkes-Barre)

Here's a link to a September 29, 2011 article by Terri Morgan-Besecker in the Times Leader reporting on a defense verdict in a large personal injury premises liability claim (over $20 million in damages claimed) after a seven (7) week trial in the Federal Middle District Court located in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania:

http://www.timesleader.com/news/Jury_rejects_area_woman_rsquo_s__20M_injury_suit_against_Toys_R_Us_09-28-2011.html

Monday, September 26, 2011

Ejected and Rejected: Household Exclusion Upheld in Motorcycle Accident Case

Tort Talkers may recall that I previously reported on the household exclusion case of Allstate v. Hymes, in which Judge O'Brien of the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas ruled that the Court agreed with Allstate that the clear and unambiguous language of the household exclusion applicable to that case barred the injured party’s UIM claim. 

The claimant in that case was a motorcyclist, who was injured when he was thrown from his motorcycle during the course of an accident.  The claimant made the novel argument that provisions of the Allstate policy were not implicated and should therefore not apply because he was not "on" his motorcycle at the time he was injured; rather, the motorcyclist was allegedly not injured until he impacted 20 feet away from his motorcycle.  More details on the case and the issues presented can be viewed at this prior Tort Talk posting on the trial court's decision: 

http://www.torttalk.com/2010/08/that-hurts.html.

Recently, on September 13, 2011, the Pennsylvania Superior Court issued an Opinion in which they affirmed the trial court's decision.  See Allstate v. Hymes, 2011 WL 4036094 (Pa.Super. Sept. 13, 2011 Panella, Shogan, Colville, JJ.)(Opinion by Panella, J.)(Dissent by Colville, J.).

The Superior Court reviewed the law of contract/policy of insurance construction and agreed with the trial court's decision that the clear and unambiguous language of the Household Exclusion served to preclude coverage under the facts presented.

The Superior Court's Opinion in Allstate v. Hymes can be viewed here.

Friday, September 23, 2011

Former Luzerne County Judge Michael T. Conahan Sentenced to 17.5 Years in Prison

On Friday, September 23, 2011, former Luzerne County President Judge Michael T. Conahan, 59, was sentenced by Federal Middle District Court Judge Edwin M. Kosik to 210 months, or 17.5 years,  in federal prison for his part in the Luzerne County judicial scandal.  Conahan pled guilty to his crimes and received a sentence of almost 10 years less than co-Defendant, former Luzerne County Judge Mark A. Ciavarella.
 
Kosik additionally ordered Conahan to pay more than $874,000 in restitution, along with other fines. Judge Kosik also recommended that Conahan be sent to a prison in Delray Beach, Florida "not for convenience" but so that his family can be in close proximity
 
Before the sentence was handed down, Conahan sat as he read a prepared statement accepting responsibility for his actions and apologizing to all of those he harmed.  He told the court, "...the system was not corrupt.  I was corrupt."
 
Here's a link to a September 23, 2011 article from the Times Leader on Conahan's sentencing:  http://www.timesleader.com/news/Conahan-sentenced-to-.html
 
 

Thursday, September 22, 2011

TORT TALK NOMINATED BY LEXISNEXIS AS CANDIDATE FOR TOP 50 INSURANCE LAW BLOGS OF 2011



I received the below email from LexisNexis advising me that Tort Talk (http://www.torttalk.com/) has been nominated as a candidate for the LexisNexis Top 50 Insurance Law Blogs of 2011.

A comment period has opened and the LexisNexis representatives will give great weight to the commentary in favor of the nominees.  If you are willing and able, it is my hope that you will please consider offering commentary in favor of Tort Talk for this nomination. 

Here is the description LexisNexis gave for Tort Talk:


Tort Talk

http://www.torttalk.com/

Published by Daniel E. Cummins

This blog provides updates, trends and thoughts about Pennsylvania Civil Litigation Law. It's a nice mix of good writing, interesting topics and practical information for the insurance defense crowd.


Below is a copy of the email I recieved and information on how to offer up comments. 

Thanks for reading Tort Talk and thanks for your time and consideration with respect to this request:


Dear Daniel:

Each year, LexisNexis honors a select group of blogs that set the online standard for a given industry. I’m pleased to notify you that your blog is one of the nominated candidates for the LexisNexis Top 50 Insurance Law Blogs of 2011, featured on the LexisNexis Insurance Law Community.


We are inviting Insurance law practitioners to comment on our list of nominees. If you’d like to request that readers support your nomination, please ask them to comment on the announcement post on our LexisNexis Insurance Law Community.

To submit a comment, visitors need to log on to their free LexisNexis Communities account. If you haven’t previously registered, you can do so on the Insurance Law Community Insurance Law Community for free. The comment box is at the very bottom of the blog nomination page. The comment period for nominations ends on October 7, 2011. Our Matthew Bender Insurance editors and our Insurance Law Advisory Board will then give strong consideration to the comments received when they review all of the nominees and select the Top 50 Insurance Law Blogs of 2011 next month.

Congratulations on your nomination, and good luck!

Very truly yours,

Ted

Ted Zwayer
Community Manager, Insurance Law Community
LexisNexis
Legal & Professional

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

Judge Terrence Nealon of Lackawanna County Allows Slip and Fall Case to Proceed Based Upon Circumstantial Evidence of Constructive Notice

In his September 15, 2011 Opinion in the Lackawanna County slip and fall case of Filippova v. Community Bank and Trust Co., No. 2009 - Civil - 6184 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Sept. 15, 2011 Nealon, J.), Judge Terrence Nealon discussed the recurring issue of the sufficiency of circumstantial evidence of a property owner's constructive notice of the presence of a dangerous condition (i.e., water on the floor).

This matter involved a personal injury suit brought against a bank based upon a slip and fall allegedly as a result of water on the tile floor of a bank lobby.  In his Opinion, Judge Nealon provides a thorough analysis of the law of actual and constructive notice of defective conditions in premise liability slip and fall matters.

The Opinion also more specifically reviews how circumstantial proof of constructive notice can be particularly challenging with indoor falls on water since "[u]nlike produce which may change in composition or color as it remains on a floor surface for an extended period, water evaporates with the passage of time."  The Opinion goes on to analyze the decisional precedent on constructive notice, which authority dates as far back as the 1950s and 1960s.

In response to the Defendant's motion for summary judgment based upon the lack of any actual or constructive notice of any allegedly dangerous condition on the bank lobby floor in the form of melted snow or water, the Court reviewed the matter in a light most favorable to the Plaintiff as required by the standard of review.

The Court noted that there was no dispute that the Plaintiff slipped and fell in the lobby.  Although the Plaintiff admittedly could not state how long the water was located on the lobby floor, she did offer evidence of the official weather reports confirming that snow and freezing rain fell over the 24 hours leading up to the event.  Evidence was also produced by the Plaintiff that the Bank's representatives admitted that they were aware that wet floors caused customer falls and that the bank placed "Caution" signs and extra carpet mats in the lobby when needed.

Based on this evidence, the Plaintiff contended that it was a jury question to determine whether, during the winter months in Northeastern Pennsylvania, a business owner should have appreciated and remedied the risk to business invitees when wet weather outside was likely to be tracked inside and onto a tile floor, which conditions the business owner should have also known would likely cause a hazardous condition to business invitees.

In his decision, Judge Nealon emphasized that the Plaintiff noticed, after her fall, that the water on the lobby floor was allegedly spread over a wide area all around the area of her fall.  Accepting this as true under the applicable standard of review and keeping in mind the highest duty of care owed by the business owner to business invitees, Judge Nealon found that there were triable issues of fact as to whether or not the bank had constructive notice of the water on the floor under the facts presented.

The Court also found that the testimony relating to the bank's safety practices, including putting out "Caution" signs in times of bad weather along with extra carpeting, also created genuine triable issues of fact on the breach of a duty of care issue sufficient to deny the Defendant's motion for summary judgment. 

Anyone desiring a copy of Judge Nealon's Opinion in the case of Filippova v. Community Bank and Trust Company may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Check Out New AttorneyFee Website

A legal startup website called AttorneyFee launched this week. AttorneyFee is a comparison engine that enables consumers to instantly compare attorney fees from from hundreds of local attorneys at once.  The site also syncs up with attorneys’ calendars, giving consumers the ability to gauge lawyers’ availability and request appointments without making a single phone call. The service is completely free for both attorneys and consumers. The site went live on September 15th in 20 cities across America with prices from nearly 20,000 attorneys. AttorneyFee hopes to continue to expand across America.


For full disclosure purposes I note that AttorneyFee agreed to post a link to Tort Talk on its site in exchange for this posting.