Friday, September 16, 2011

Judge Terrence Nealon of Lackawanna County Addresses Typical Objections to Pleadings in Auto Accident Complaint

In an Opinion handed down last Friday in the case of Freethy v. Goike, No. 2011 - CV - 530 (C.P. Lacka. Co. Sept. 9, 2011 Nealon, J), Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas Judge Terrence Nealon addressed recurring issues that typically arise in the form of preliminary objections to a complaint filed in auto accident cases.

More specifically, in this case the Defendant objected to the Plaintiff's Complaint based on Connor, asserting that the Plaintiff had not cited the specific sections of the Vehicle Code that the Defendant had allegedly violated 

Judge Nealon primarily relied upon the decision in Com., Dept. of Transportation v. Shipley Humble Oil Company, 370 A.2d 438, 440 (Pa.Cmwlth. 1977) to overrule the preliminary objections in this regard.  That decision states that specific statute provisions need not be identified so long as the plaintiff avers facts that bring the claim within the statute.


The Defendant in the Freethy case also objected to the Plaintiff's allegations of wanton and reckless conduct, asserting that such allegations lacked factual support.  According to the Opinion, this matter involved a high speed accident in a construction zone.
 
Judge Nealon  pointed to  Archibald v. Kemble, 971 A.2d 513, 519 (Pa. Super. 2009), app. denied, 605 Pa. 678, 989 A.2d 914 (2010) in support of his holding that that wanton and reckless conduct are conditions of the mind that may be averred generally under Pa.R.C.P. 1019.  Accordingly, these preliminary objections were overruled as well.
 
Anyone desiring a copy of Judge Nealon's Opinion in Freethy v. Goike may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
 

Update on Luzerne County Matters

Former Luzerne County Judge Mark Ciavarella has been transferred and settled into a medium security federal prison in Illinois.  Here's a link to an article on that topic by Terrie Morgan-Besecker in the September 14, 2011 Times Leader: 

http://www.timesleader.com/news/Ciavarella_moved_to_Illinois_prison_09-14-2011.html?searchterm=Ciavarella


Former Luzerne County Judge Michael Toole is being housed in a minimum security prison in Minnesota.  Here is a link to a May of 2011 Citizen's Voice article on that topic:

http://citizensvoice.com/news/former-judge-michael-t-toole-reports-to-minnesota-federal-prison-1.1140761#axzz1Y7Q0BJ5F


Former Judge Michael Conahan is scheduled to be sentenced next Friday, September 23, 2011.  No sentencing date for former attorney Robert Powell has been scheduled yet.

Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Judge Terrence Nealon of Lackawanna County Addresses Competency of Expert Opinions and Propriety of Hypothetical Questions

It's not often that I post a write-up of a criminal court opinion but, on occasion, those opinions can contain nuggets of law useful in the civil litigation context.

For example, on pages 21-27 of Lackawanna County Judge Terrence R. Nealon's September 9, 2011 Opinion in the vile first degree murder case of Commonwealth v. Blakey, No. 2008 - Criminal - 982 (C.P. Lacka. Sept. 9, 2011, Nealon, J.), there is a discussion of the degree of certainty required for expert opinions and the evidentiary support needed to present hypothetical questions to experts at trial.

The issues centered around the prosecution's calling of a medical witness to testify on the cause of death.  That doctor noted in his testimony that his opinion was to a reasonable degree of medical certainty but, at one point, couched his opinion in terms of "most probably."

In his Opinion, Judge Nealon provides a nice recitation of the law pertaining to the certainty required of expert opinions and reconfirmed the notions that expert opinions should be reviewed in their entirety and that experts are not required to use "magic words" to render the opinion competent and admissible.

More specifically, Judge Nealon held that the fact "that an expert may have used less definitive language does not render his entire opinion speculative if at some time during his testimony he expressed his opinion with reasonable certainty.”  Vicari, 936 A.2d at 510 (quoting Carrozza v. Greenbaum, 866 A.2d 369, 379 (Pa. Super. 2004), app. denied, 584 Pa. 698, 882 A.2d 1004 (2005))."

In terms of the use of hypothetical questions to experts during trial testimony, Judge Nealon noted that the propriety of such questions remains within the discretion of the court.  He also reviewed the types of underlying facts that are acceptable within these types of questions.

Anyone desiring a copy of Judge Nealon's Opinion in the case of Commonwealth v. Blakey can contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Thursday, September 8, 2011

Justice Antonin Scalia to Give Keynote Address At Centennial Celebration of Duquesne Law School

I have been requested to pass along the following invitation:

Dean Ken Gormley and Duquesne University School of Law cordially invite all members of the Luzerne County Bar Association and the Lackawanna County Bar Association to attend a keynote address by Justice Antonin Scalia, United States Supreme Court, in celebration of the 100th anniversary of Duquesne Law School's founding.

Justice Scalia's historic Centennial address will take place at the A.J. Palumbo Center on the Duquesne Campus on Saturday, September 24, 2011 at 2:00 p.m.

There is no charge for members of the Luzerne or Lackawanna County Bar Association or their guests.

Justice Scalia's keynote speech, commemorating the Law School's Centennial, will be followed by a brief tribute to Justice Scalia on the occasion of the 25th anniversary of his own appointment to the Supreme Court.

To register for this historic event in the life of the legal profession and the organized bar in Western Pennsylvania, kindly register by clicking on the below link:

www.myduquesne.duq.edu/LawCenScalia



Cumberland County Case in Favor of Severance of Post-Koken Claims

In the first Post-Koken decision (by Order only) on the issue of consolidation vs. severance of claims I have come across out of Cumberland County, Judge M.L. Ebert, Jr. has come down in favor of the severance of claims.

In Henry v. Amin and Westfield Ins. Co., No. 11-4881 Civil (C.P. Cumberland Sept. 1, 2011 Ebert, J.), the Plaintiff had combined a negligence claim against the tortfeasor with a breach of contract claim against the UIM carrier.  There was no bad faith claim presented.

Judge Ebert granted the tortfeasor's preliminary objections to the Complaint and Ordered that the claims be severed.  The court specifically directed the Plaintiff to file a separate Complaint for the UIM claim.

In his Order, Judge Ebert also directed that the Complaint against the tortfeasor for negligence would be tried first followed by a trial on the Complaint against the UIM carrier for UIM benefits. 


According to a review of the Post-Koken Scorecard here on TortTalk.com, the Cumberland County decision tips the scales ever so slightly with arguably at least 16 counties across the Commonwealth in favor of severance and 15 counties in favor of consolidation.  To date, there still has not been any appellate decision handed down on this issue.

The Post-Koken Scorecard can always be accessed by scrolling down the right hand column of the blog and clicking on the date listed under the label "Post-Koken Scorecard."



Anyone desiring a copy of Judge Ebert's Order in the case of Henry v. Amin and Westfield Ins. Co. may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

I thank the prevailing defense attorney, Donald L. Carmelite, Esq. of the Harrisburg Office of Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin, for forwarding this decision to my attention.

Wednesday, September 7, 2011

Former Luzerne County Judge Mark Ciavarella Transferred to Oklahoma Federal Prison

According to a September 8, 2011 article by Dave Janoski in Scranton's Times Tribune, former Luzerne County Judge Mark Ciavarella has been moved from a Philadelphia detention center to a federal prison transfer center in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma.  The article notes that he will be transferred from that center to another federal prison at some point.  Ciavarella was sentenced last month to 28 years in prison.

Here's a link to the Times Tribune article:  http://thetimes-tribune.com/news/ciavarella-in-oklahoma-transfer-center-pending-prison-placement-1.1199650#axzz1XN2xe3CK

Monday, September 5, 2011

Pennsylvania Superior Court Addresses Peer Review Issue

In the case of Herd Chiropractic v. State Farm, 2011 PA Super. 178 (Pa.Super. Aug. 23, 2011 Panella, Lazarus, and Ott, JJ.)(Opinion by Lazarus, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed a Dauphin County trial court decision that an insurance company may be still be liable for attorney’s fees under the First Party Medical Benefits Statute, 75 Pa.C.S. § 1797, even when the carrier properly invokes the peer review process.

In Herd Chiropractic v. State Farm, the medical provider provided various chiropractic services to a State Farm insured. State Farm requested a peer review to assess the reasonableness and necessity of the treatment. The peer review doctor opined that the treatment rendered by the chiropractor beyond a certain date was not reasonable and necessary. Accordingly, State Farm advised the chiropractor that it would not be paying for any additional treatment.

The chiropractor filed suit in the Court of Common Pleas of Dauphin County, Pennsylvania under Section 1797 of the MVFRL demanding payment of the unpaid chiropractic bills plus attorney’s fees and treble damages.

The matter proceeded to trial non-jury before the Honorable Bruce Bratton in July 2009. In December 2009, Judge Bratton found in favor of the chiropractor and awarded it $1,380.68 in compensatory damages for the outstanding amount of the bills, plus 1 % interest.

The trial court initially denied the chiropractor’s request for attorney’s fees and treble damages. But the chiropractor moved for reconsideration and the trial court reversed itself and ended up awarding attorney’s fees of $27,047.50 to the chiropractor despite finding that “State Farm complied in all material respects with Act 6’s requirements in conducting a peer review of [the] billings at issue.”

State Farm appealed and the Superior Court affirmed. In its Opinion, the Superior Court found no error in the trial court’s decision that State Farm had properly adhered to the peer review procedure.

However, the Superior Court also agreed with the trial court’s decision that, although the carrier adhered to proper procedure, that did not preclude an award of attorney’s fees where the court determined that the care provided was indeed medically necessary.

The Superior Court's decision can be viewed online HERE.