Thursday, August 18, 2011

Spoliation of Evidence Sanction Granted Against A Plaintiff

In the case of Pa. Trust v. Dorel Juv. Grp.,  2011 WL 2789336, No. 07-4029 (E.D.Pa. July 18, 2011 Schiller, J.), the Eastern District Federal Court imposed a spoliation sanction against a plaintiff in a an auto accident case in which a claim was made that a child booster seat was improperly designed.

After noting that the plaintiff failed to take pictures of the seat before signing the title over to the towing service following the accident, the court found that the elements to support a spoliation sanction were established by the defense. 

The court precluded the plaintiff's testimony regarding the use of the child booster seat on the day of the accident and granted the defense an adverse inference jury instruction.

This Opinion may be viewed online here.

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Plans to Televise its Proceedings

According to an August 15, 2011 article in The Legal Intellegencer by Ben Present entitled "PA Supreme Court to Televise Arguments," the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has announced its intention to allow its proceedings to be televised on the Pennsylvania Cable Network.  The televising of the proceedings, which will not air live, is set to begin in the near future.  The cameras will be set up to allow for a wide angle shot of all of the justices as well as close-ups of the Justices when they speak as well as of the arguing attorneys.

How long will it be before make-up artists start advertising their services to attorneys just as court reporters, subpoena vendors, and private investigators do?

Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Former Judge Michael Toole of Luzerne County and Former Superior Court Judge Michael T. Joyce Sanctioned by Court of Judicial Discipline

On July 26, 2011, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Court of Judicial Discipline in Pennsylvania issued Orders sanctioning former Luzerne County Judge Michael Toole and former Superior Court Judge Michael T. Joyce officially removing them from the bench and prohibiting them from ever holding judicial office again in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.

The Court of Judicial Discipline filings and findings with regards to former Luzerne County Judge Michael Toole can be viewed here , here, and here.

The Court of Judicial Discipline filings and findings with regards to former Superior Court Judge Michael T. Joyce can be viewed here, here, and here.

Source of news tip:  August 16, 2011 news article in The Legal Intelligencer by Zack Needles entitled "Court of Judicial Discipline's Order May Cost Joyce Pension."

Municipality Immune From Suit Involving Car Accident Caused by Black Ice on Roadway

In its July 18, 2011 decision in the case of Page v. City of Philadelphia, 2011 WL 2749671, No. 1542 C.D. 2010 (Pa.Cmwlth. July 18, 2011, McGinley, Brobson, Friedman, J.J.)(Opinion by Friedman, S.J.), the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania affirmed the entry of a summary judgment in favor of municipality defendants against a claim that the subject car accident was caused by black ice.

The Plaintiffs had claimed that the black ice developed on the roadway by the melting an re-freezing of improperly removed snow and ice.  The Court found that real estate exception and the streets exception to sovereign immunity and governmental immunity were inapplicable because the ice did not derive or originate from the roadway and because the ice was not caused by an improper design or inherent defect of the street itself.

The Opinion in Page v. City of Philadelphia can be viewed online here.

Sunday, August 14, 2011

Another Lackawanna County Decision by Judge Mazzoni in Favor of Consolidation of Post-Koken Claims

On August 5, 2011, in the case of Knott v. Walters and Nationwide Mutual Automobile Ins. Co., No. 2010 CV 4745 (Lacka. Co. Aug. 5, 2011, Mazzoni, J.),  Judge Robert A. Mazzoni of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas issued another decision, by way of a detailed Order, in favor of the consolidation of post-Koken cases, at least through the pre-trial stage.  In the Order, the court denied the preliminary objections filed by the tortfeasor defendant claiming, in part, a misjoinder of actions under the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.

In so ruling, Judge Mazzoni cited to his own previous Opinion on the same issue in the case of Richards v. McPhillips and Progressive Ins. Co., No. 2010 CV 7020 (Lacka. Co. June 10, 2011, Mazzoni, J.) as well as the Opinion of fellow Lackawanna County Judge Terrence Nealon in the case of Bingham v. Voswistilo, 2010 CV 6026 (Lacka. Co. April 8, 2011 Nealon, J.).

The majority rule in Lackawanna County on this issue is that the cases will remain consolidated at least up through the time of trial.  In their respective decisions, both Judge Mazzoni and Judge Nealon expressly state that, at the time of trial, the assigned trial judge shall retain the discretion to address motions to bifurcate or sever the claims presented.

I thank the prevailing Plaintiff's attorney in the Knott case, Attorney Doug Yazinski of the Pisanchyn Law Firm, for bringing the Knott decision to my attention.

Anyone desiring a copy of any of the decisions noted above may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

A Review of Tools on Tort Talk

There are a number of tools on Tort Talk (http://www.torttalk.com/) I wanted to highlight by way of this post.

First of all, I have updated the Post-Koken Scorecard as of today to add a number of new decisions that were already previously reported on Tort Talk.  To make the Scorecard more orderly, I also put the various county listings in alphabetical order.  Within each county listing of cases, I have tried to list the oldest cases first and add the more recent decisions at the bottom of each listing.

You can always access the Post-Koken cases to check on the status of decisions in your county at issue by scrolling down the right hand column of the blog and clicking on the date under the Label "Post-Koken Scorecard."

Speaking of Labels, that's another tool that you can use to find cases or articles on a specific topic.  If you scroll further down the right hand column of the blog, you will find a section marked "Labels" with a variety of topics listed thereunder.  By clicking on the Label that's specific to your research, you will be sent to a page that list each and every Tort Talk post that touches upon that topic.  You can then click on each title to read further.

Another way to conduct research on a particular topic is to use the "Search This Blog" tool that is closer to the top of the right hand column of the blog.  By typing in your search term in the white box (delay damages, limited tort, slip and fall, or a case name, etc.), you will be sent to a page that will list each Tort Talk post that covers that topic.  You can then click on each post to read further.

Down in the middle of the right hand column of the blog is also a box under the Label "My Published Articles" in which are listed some of the most recently published articles of mine that have been posted online at the JDSupra.com website.  If you are looking for older articles you can always click on the JDSupra box to go to that site where a full listing of the articles can be accessed and searched.

Last but certainly not least, down on the right hand column is a list of "Links" I have created to other sites, including my Firm's website and other online professional profiles I have created along with links to some other legal and non-legal-related websites that may be of interest.

Thanks again for reading Tort Talk and thanks to all who have tipped me off to breaking news and cases of note.  I am grateful for your interest and support.  If I should be able to provide you with any assistance on any matters you may have in the Northeastern Pennsylvania region where I practice, or if I can possibly help out in any other way, please do not hesitate to contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.


Thanks.

Thursday, August 11, 2011

Former Judge Ciavarella Sentenced to 28 Years in Prison

This morning Federal Middle District Court Judge Edwin M. Kosik handed down the sentence against former Luzerne County Judge Mark A. Ciavarella sending him to prison for 28 years (336 months).  Ciavarella is 61 years old.  Judge Kosik also immediately remanded Ciavarella to prision as opposed to allowing him to go free on bail to put his affairs in order.

Currently, there are still no sentencing dates scheduled yet for other figures associated with this matter, including former Judge Michael Conahan and attorney Robert Powell.