Sunday, June 12, 2011

Federal Middle District Allows Bad Faith Claim to Proceed on Basis of Invalid Rejection of UM Form

In the case of Grassetti v. Property & Casualty Insurance Company of Hartford et al., No. 3:10-cv-2068, 2011 WL 1522326 (M.D. Pa. Apr. 20, 2011), Judge James M. Munley held that a policyholder who signed a form rejecting uninsured motorist coverage could move forward with his bad faith claim because the insurer failed to use language specified by state law on the UM rejection form.

The Plaintiff was allegedly injured as a result of a May of 2007 motor vehicle accident.  As the driver of the other vehicle was never identified, an uninsured motorist claim was pursued by the injured party.  Coverage was denied by the UM carrier on the grounds that the injured party had rejected UM coverage during the application process.

In his bad faith action against the carrier, the injured party argued that the carrier had acted unreasonably in denying coverage.  The injured party essentially asserted that the UM rejection form was invalid because it did not strictly comply with the requirements of Pennsylvania's Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law, 75 Pa.C.S. § 1731(b), pertaining to the content of the rejection of coverage form.

Citing the rejection form signed by the injured party, the carrier moved to dismiss the bad-faith claim. Generally speaking, under Pennsylvania law, although uninsured motorist coverage is optional, an insured must sign a rejection form that uses language specified in the statute in order to waive such coverage.

The carrier’s form was found to deviate from the statutorily required language in one respect.  The carrier's form referred to “Uninsured Motorists Coverage,” while the statutory language referred only to “Uninsured Coverage.”

The court noted that 75 Pa.C.S. Section 1731(c)(1) states, in pertinent part, that "[a]ny rejection form that does not specifically comply with this section is void."

The court accepted the Plaintiff's citation of American Int'l Ins. Co. v. Vaxmonsky, 916 A.2d 1106 (Pa.Super.2006), in which the Pennsylvania Superior Court held that an insurer's underinsured motorist (“UIM”) coverage waiver was null and void for failure to comply with Section 1731(c) of the MVFRL.

For purposes of motion to dismiss standard of review at issue in this Grassetti case, the court found Vaxmonsky persuasive on the issue of interpreting the specific compliance requirements of Section 1731(c)(1). 

Judge Munley held that, in reading the Complaint in a light most favorable to the Plaintiff, it appeared that the Plaintiff had adequately pled a cause of action under Pennsylvania's Bad Faith Statute, 42 Pa.C.S. § 8371 given that Section 1731(c)(1) of the MVFRL requires strict compliance waiver language of section 1731(b) and given that the Plaintiff had adequately asserted in the Complaint that the Defendants withheld payment upon a claim without a reasonable basis and that Defendants did so knowing they did not have a reasonable basis.

I send thanks to Attorney Brian Bevan of the Pittsburgh law firm of DiBella, Geer, McAllister & Best, P.C. for advising me of this recent decision.

Thursday, June 9, 2011

Inspirational Speech by Judge Thomas I. Vanaskie of U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals

United States Third Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Thomas I. Vanaskie was the Keynote Speaker at the Lackawanna Bar Association's Interfaith Prayer Service on Friday, May 13, 2011, and his words were inspirational. For those of you not able to attend, below is a copy of Judge Vanaskie's remarks:



Good afternoon. It is an honor to be here with you at the annual Interfaith Prayer Service and to be with my colleagues on the Federal and State Courts for whom I have much admiration.

“Fall in love, stay in love, and it will decide everything. Love will decide what will get you out of bed in the morning, what you will do with your evenings, how you will spend your weekends, what you read, who you know, what breaks your heart and what amazes you with joy and gratitude.” Words of advice, not from Tom Vanaskie, but from Father Pedro Arrupe, and they are indeed sage words. Look at your experiences, from childhood to adulthood, and you will see how love has pervaded your being, from children at play, to teens experiencing first relationships, to marriage, to bringing up children, to your interactions with nieces and nephews, to how you love and are loved by your grandchildren.

And of course, this power of love transcends individual relationships. Those fortunate to be able to pursue a profession or vocation they love do not consider themselves at work. They don’t count the hours or watch the clock, and they are fulfilled by pursuit of their love. Not many, of course, are blessed with the ability to earn a living pursuing something they love, so they turn to other endeavors, whether it is some sport, like running, or perhaps it is tutoring, gardening, cooking, or just taking care of others. They are engaged. They are the opposite of indifference.

There is a line from a movie that strikes me when I think of this subject of the power and meaning of love. An old, grizzly tough guy played by Robert Duvall gives this advice to a young boy. He said that “sometimes the things that may or may not be true are the things a person needs to believe in the most. That people are basically good; that honor, courage, and virtue mean everything; that power and money mean nothing; that good always triumphs over evil;” and then he said, “I want you to remember this, that love…true love never dies.” He concluded that a person should believe in those things because those are the things that are worth believing in.

If you want to do good in this crazy society of ours, you must have those beliefs: that honor, courage, and virtue mean everything, and that people are basically good, and that good always triumphs over evil. America was built upon dreamers with such beliefs. We have had our share of bad and evil people. They are usually the cynics. They prey on vulnerabilities and judge on appearances. They are opinionated and judgmental. But those who share those things that are worth believing in are slow to judge, assist the vulnerable, and are optimists.

In a novel a great friend recommended to me, The Shack, a father whose four year old daughter is abducted, sexually assaulted and murdered without her body being recovered has lost his faith in a benevolent deity. The book is one of redemption of the soul as the dad returns to the shack where it is believed his daughter was murdered ten years after she went missing. There he encounters God, or as this book is written from a Christian perspective, the three persons in one God. The book contains some pearls of wisdom that are agnostic, but reflect this power that love creates. One passage I particularly think is compelling goes as follows, “relationships are never about power…one way to avoid (taking advantage of power) is to choose to limit oneself – to serve. Humans often do this in touching the infirmed and sick, in serving the ones whose minds are left to wander, in relating to the poor, in loving the very old and the very young.”

We see so many examples of love prodding a person to limit himself or herself. Justice Sandra Day O’Connor left the Supreme Court to spend time with her husband, stricken with Alzheimer’s. I saw Ruth Davies limit herself in caring for her daughter, Julia. Indeed, each and every person has at one time or another limited himself or herself as part of a true relationship.

In the words of the God figure in The Shack, “you choose to limit yourself so as to facilitate and honor that relationship. You will even lose a competition to accomplish love. It is not about winning and losing, but about love and respect.”

This limitation of oneself to build enduring relationships shows that we are all, to use a phrase close to the heart of Sondra Myers, interdependent. We have a mutual need for the talents, intellect, and hard work of each other.

Another book I read in the more distant past on the recommendation of my children was the Life of Pi. It approaches the mysteries of life and our existence through the lens of different major religions. But each religion has come to the “realization that the founding principle of existence is what we call love, which works itself out sometimes not clearly, not immediately, but nonetheless ineluctably.”

Ultimately, the work we do in the law must be premised upon those things worth believing in and on love for our fellow human beings. Those who embrace this value system recognize that we are truly interdependent and not independent creatures. And pursuing this approach often necessitates a limitation of oneself. Consider a couple examples, one historical and one current.

In 1797, John Adams, became our nation’s second President and the first of many lawyer-presidents. He was also a courageous defender of those he thought unjustly accused and the man who first penned the famous phrase, “a government of laws and not of men.” But let’s go back to 1770, 27 years before Adams became President and five years before the Revolutionary War began.

Adams was in Boston, already a leader in Massachusetts Colony’s growing resistance to British rule and especially British taxes. By 1770, Boston had about 20,000 residents plus 4,000 British soldiers sent to keep order among those unruly colonists and to collect those taxes. Tensions ran high. Late one cold winter evening, March 5, 1770, protesters gathered downtown, near a small group of soldiers. Things got loud and confusing and suddenly the soldiers shot into the crowd. Five civilians died (the Boston Massacre). The public was incensed. The atmosphere in Boston was poisonous. John Adams’ cousin, Sam Adams, one of the leaders of the Colonists, called the killings a bloody butchery and distributed a print published by Paul Revere vividly portraying the scene as a slaughter of the innocent, an image of British tyranny that would become fixed in the public’s mind.

The soldiers and their leader, Captain Tom Preston, were arrested for murder. But some people called it a riot, not a massacre, saying the soldiers had been threatened and pelted with rocks, snowballs and the like. The following day 34 year old John Adams was asked to defend the soldiers and their captain when they came to trial. No one else would take the case.

Even though John Adams was a leader in the resistance to British rule, he believed these Brits (Preston and his soldiers) deserved a defense, and he gave them a fine one. He won acquittal of the Captain by convincing a jury that the officer had not ordered his troops to fire. He defended the soldiers on grounds of self defense against a mob. Six were acquitted, two others convicted of manslaughter. The trial was the first time a judge used the phrase “reasonable doubt,” a concept our courts later found inherent in the phrase “due process of law.”

Taking their cases was a very unpopular act. During the trial, threats were made on his life and his family. John Adams’ defense in the Boston Massacre trials was a courageous example of adherence to the rule of law and defense of the rights of the accused. It showed his love for justice and, by the way, his Country. Years later, John Adams wrote that this defense, in light of so much public scorn, was one of the finest things he’d ever done for his Country.

That love for justice and adherence to the rule of law is never more important than when advocates represent unpopular clients in times of heated public controversy and times of turmoil.

Many lawyers have volunteered to test the rules of detention of Guantanamo Bay detainees and get the prisoners access to counsel and to some process and some Supreme Court rulings. In fact, of the50 largest law firms in the United Sates, at least 34 have either represented detainees or filed amicus briefs in support of detainees.

Many of these lawyers and their law firms have been attacked by leaders in the other two branches of our government. As an example, a high ranking Pentagon official in 2007, after reciting the names of some of these law firms said, “I think, quite honestly when corporate CEOs see that those firms are representing the very terrorists who hit their bottom line back in 2001, those CEOs are going to make those law firms choose between representing terrorists or representing reputable firms, and I think that is going to have major play in the next few weeks. And we want to watch that play out.”

Many of these same lawyers went to work in the Department of Justice. Members of Congress have questioned whether they should be employed by the Department after their work on behalf of detainees. At an oversight hearing, Attorney General Holder, in April of 2010, was asked by a member of the judiciary committee:

Question: So a very simple yes or no question: would you provide the names of political appointees at the department who have previously represented detainees or advocated on detainee issues?


Holder: With all due respect, Senator, and I know that your request comes from what I will call a good place. Yours was an honorable request. And the hesitance that I had, I think has been borne out by what I have seen. There has been an attempt to take the names of the people who represented Guantanamo detainees and to drag their reputation through the mud. There were reprehensible ads used to question their – in essence to question their patriotism. I’m not going to allow these kids – I’m not going to be part of that effort. And so with all due respect, their names are out there now, and the positions that they hold are out there. That’s all been placed in the public record; I am simply not going to be a part of that effort. I will not allow good decent lawyers who have followed the greatest traditions of American Jurisprudence, done what John Adams, done what our Chief Justice has said is appropriate, I will not allow their reputations to be disparaged. I will not be part of that.


So as you can see, John Adams’ legacy continues to inspire lawyers to this day. The lawyers of today, just as John Adams, are dreamers and believers in those values worth believing in; that the rule of law must predominate in tumultuous times, that virtue, honor and courage are everything, and that the good will ultimately triumph over evil by remaining good.

As former Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor warned in the 2004 decision of Hamdi v. Rumsfeld, a case that involved an American citizen who was detained as an enemy combatant, “it is during our most challenging and uncertain moments that our Nation’s commitment to due process is most severely tested, and it is in those times that we must preserve our commitment at home to the principles for which we fight abroad.”

Lawyers are called to follow in Adams’ footsteps, and it’s not easy. The practice of law is not a popularity contest. Rather, it is a noble profession whose aim is to do what’s right on the evidence and under the law, in spite of popular sentiment at any given time. It can involve great sacrifice, but the costs to the nation and the world, would be far greater were we to lose these ideals. Those of us who have fallen in love with this profession certainly understand that.


Thank you.

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Choice of Laws Decision Issued by Judge Caputo of Pennsylvania Federal Middle District Court

In the case of Flickinger v. Toys R Us, Inc., No. 3:10-CV-305 (M.D.Pa. May 31, 2011, Caputo, J.), the court provided a detailed Choice of Laws analysis and ultimately concluded that a Pennsylvania Plaintiff's claims filed in a Pennsylvania federal court should be governed by New York law.

The Plaintiff, Mary Beth Flickinger ,claimed that she sustained injuries to her cervical spine when a bin filled with M&Ms fell on her at a Toys R Us store in Times Square, New York City.  The Plaintiff presented a substantial loss of future earning capacity claim as part of the case.

Judge Caputo's decision addresses a number of pre-trial motions in limine and is his opinion is notable with respect to the Plaintiffs’ Motion requesting the Court to apply Pennsylvania law on damages and liability to this case.

As indicated, the Toys R Us store was in NYC and that company was incorporated in Delaware.  According to the Opinion, the Plaintiffs resided and worked in Pennsylvania.  Also, the Plaintiff's medical providers were in Pennsylvania as well.

After presenting a detailed description of the Choice of Laws analysis, Judge Caputo ruled that the more conservative New York damages law should be applied.  Should you have this issue come up, this case may be a good one to kickstart your legal research on the question presented.

The prevailing defense attorneys include Tony Trozzolillo, Dan Stofko, Lauren Dobrowalski, Judy Moses, and Jamie Lenzi of the law firm of Cipriani & Werner.

Anyone desiring a copy of this case may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Recent Cases of Note on Various Civil Litigation Issues

In the case of Silver v. Thompson, PICS No. 11-0950 (Pa.Super. May 27, 2011 Lazarus, Bender, Strassburger, JJ.)(Opinion by Lazarus, J.), the Pennsylvania Superior Court reversed a Philadelphia County trial court ruling that venue in Philadelphia was improper when a defendant had been served personally in Philadelphia.

The trial court judge had granted the Defendant's preliminary objections to venue within Philadelphia in a car accident case because the underlying car accident occurred in Bucks County, all the litigants reside in Bucks County and the witnesses are located in Bucks County.  The trial court judge transferred venue to Bucks County.

According to the Opinion, the Defendant had been personally served with the Complaint at her workplace in Philadelphia.

The Superior Court, however, pointed to Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1006, which provides that venue is proper in the county in which the individual may be served.  The appellate court also noted that Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 402(a) allows for an individual to be served by handing a copy to the defendant or by handing a copy at any usual place of business of the defendant.

While the trial court judge had ruled that the Defendant had to be served at her place of business for venue to be proper in Philadelphia, the Superior Court instead found that Rule 402(a) "clearly states that service may be effected by 'handing a copy to the defendant.'"

According to an article on the case by Amaris Elliott-Engel in the June 9, 2011 Legal Intelligencer, the case of Silver v. Thompson was originally issued as an unpublished memorandum April 27, and was then issued as a published opinion May 27.

______________________________________________________________

In the recent case of Bloomer v. Ford Motor Company, PICS Case No. 11-0854 (Pa. Super. May 6, 2011) Allen, J.; Shogan, J., concurring and dissenting), the Pennsylvania Superior Court addressed the novel issue of the admissibility of remedial measures taken before an accident occurred in products liability cases.

The Bloomer case involved a Plaintiff who was employed as a tow truck driver who was killed while in the process of towing another vehicle when his truck ran over him. The injured party alleged that Ford’s defective design of the parking brake caused it to disengage. A jury eventually entered a verdict in favor of the Plaintiff’s estate in excess of $10 million dollars after the original amount was molded to add delay damages.
On appeal, the Ford Motor Company argued, in part, that the trial court erred in admitting evidence of design changes in the Ford truck’s brake system, claiming that the designed changes were in admissible as subsequent remedial measures.

The Plaintiff Superior Court disagreed and noted that the design changes at issue were contemplated by Ford prior to the Plaintiff’s accident. Although the design changes may have been considered “remedial measures,” the court found that the plain language of Pa. R.E. 407 only restricts the introduction of remedial measures that were made after the subject injury or harm. As such, Pennsylvania Superior Court concluded that changes in design that were devised prior to the subject accident were not barred as a subsequent remedial measure.

____________________________________________________________


Another case that has been touted as one of the most requested Opinions recently in the Pennsylvania Law Weekly Instant Case Service is the Decision of Touchete v. Weis Markets, Inc., PICS Case No. 11-0713 (Monroe Co., March 3, 2011, Worthington, J.) in which the Monroe County Court of Common Pleas ruled that a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment should be granted under the argument that a Plaintiff assumed the risk of her injury when she knowing and voluntarily walked over snow and ice.  This cases supports the argument that the assumption of risk defense remains alive and well in Pennsylvania.

____________________________________________________________


In the recent Federal Middle District Court case of M.S. v. Secret Bridge Mil. Acad., No. 1:08-CV-2271 , PICS Case No. 11-0912 (M.D.Pa. May 13, 2011 Carlson, M.J.), Magistrate Judge Carlson ruled that, under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 35, the Plaintiff's attorney is not permitted to be present at a psychiatric examination of a minor party in a negligence action filed by parents on behalf of the minor plaintiff.

The Court in M.S. additionally ruled that the parents of the minor could not be compelled to participate in interviews as part of that psychiatric examination of the child.


Here's a link to other posts on Tort Talk regarding psychiatric IME issues: 

http://www.torttalk.com/search/label/Independent%20Psychiatric%20Examinations




Anyone desiring a copy of any of the above cases may contact the Pennsylvania Law Weekly Instant Case Service at 1-800-276-7427 and provide the PICS Case Number noted and pay a small fee.

Source:  Pennsylvania Law Weekly Digests (May 31, 2011)// Legal Intelligencer (June 9, 2011)

Pennsylvania Association For Justice Hosting a Retreat (CLE Seminars) in Philadelphia - June 23-26, 2011

The Pennsylvania Association for Justice is hosting 4 CLE Seminars in Philadelphia at its Annual Retreat on June 23-26, 2011 at The Westin Philadelphia.

These programs are for both plaintiff and defense lawyers and include the following:


--“Ethics 2011”

--“A Conversation with Tom Kline” -- an informal discussion with one of PA’s preeminent lawyers, Tom Kline, on what he has learned over the years

--“Tort Roundtable”—trial lawyers from around the state give a quick update on the latest in ten different areas of practice

--Judge Andrew Napolitano, Senior Judicial Analyst for Fox News, will discuss “Do We Still Have a Constitutions?”


Call the PAJ office at (215) 546-6451 to register today.  You can register for the entire package or separately pick and choose seminars to attend.  Here is a link to the PAJ ad on the event:

http://www.pajustice.org/temp/ts_7021F684-BDB9-505B-D846F009F8F82A347021F694-BDB9-505B-D112EC00972F7A04/3pageRetreatFlyer.pdf

Pennsylvania Defense Institute CLE Seminar - Pittsburgh - June 23, 2011

PENNSYLVANIA DEFENSE INSTITUTE

Presents

“Key Insurance Law Developments 2011”

(3 Substantive CLE Credits)


Sheraton Station Square Hotel

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Thursday, June 23, 2011



1:00 – 1:30 PM Registration


1:30 - 1:50 PM “Tort Reform Update”

Timothy Bittle
Bigley & Blikle


1:50 – 2:30 PM “Auto Law Update”

Thomas McDonnell, Esq.
Summers, McDonnell, Hudock, Guthrie & Skeel



2:30 – 3:10 PM “Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Law Update”

Craig Murphey, Esq.
MacDonald, Illig, Jones & Britton



3:10 – 3:25 PM Break


 
3:25 – 4:05 PM “Insurance Bad Faith Law: Update”

Robert Dapper, Esq.
Dapper, Baldasare, Benson, Behling & Kane

Daniel Rivetti, Esq.
Robb, Leonard & Mulvihill



4:05 – 4:45 PM “Civil Practice & Procedure”

Scott Millhouse, Esq.
Meyer, Darragh, Buckler, Bebenek & Eck


 
Costs for the event:

• CLE program for lawyers $125.00

• All others $25.00


For reservations, please complete the form below and return to PDI or e-mail us at coled01@padefense.org

 

Name(s)_____________________________________

___________________________________________


Firm/Company__________________________________

____________________________________________



Make checks payable to:

PENNSYLVANIA DEFENSE INSTITUTE
P.O. Box 697, Camp Hill, PA 17001-0697


For more information, contact PDI at 800-734-0737

Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Article on Discovery of Social Media Information

Tort Talkers may recall that I recently wrote on the first social media discovery decision in Pennsylvania in the McMillen v. Hummingbird Speedway Inc. case out of Jefferson County.  Here's the link to that post:   http://www.torttalk.com/2010/10/article-new-discovery-battlefield.html.   

Below is my recent article from last week's Pennsylvania Law Weekly providing an update on the Pennsylvania trial court decisions that have come down on this issue since.  Anyone needing a copy of the Pennsylvania decisions referenced may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.


Civil Practice



To Friend or Not to Friend?
Trial courts split on how to handle social media discovery requests

by

Daniel E. Cummins


The Legal Intelligencer/Pennsylvania Law Weekly


May 31, 2011

An emerging issue in Pennsylvania civil litigation personal injury matters is the extent to which one party may gain access to information on an opposing party's social networking site such as Facebook or MySpace.

On the plaintiff's side, an argument can be made that postings on such sites are protected by expectations of privacy. On the defense side, it is asserted that such postings are made with the knowledge that they may not necessarily be private and also that the allowance of such discovery would further the overriding goal of civil trials of searching for the truth on the claims and defenses presented.

A Decision Against Disclosure

According to a May 17 article by Gina Passarella in Pennsylvania Law Weekly , Bucks County Common Pleas Court Judge Albert J. Cepparulo recently issued a one paragraph order in Piccolo v. Paterson, in which he denied a defendant's motion to compel the plaintiff to allow the defense access to the plaintiff's Facebook page.

According to the article, the plaintiff in Piccolo was injured as a result of a motor vehicle accident during which she was hit in the face with the airbag and suffered significant lacerations to her lip and chin. The plaintiff required 95 stitches to her face in the emergency room on the day of the accident and then had scar revision surgery thereafter along with several laser treatments to reduce the scarring. According to the court filings, the plaintiff was permanently scarred on her face.

The article notes that, following the accident, the plaintiff allowed the defense carrier to come to her home about a year after the accident and take a number of photographs of her face.

During the course of this litigation, the plaintiff had also provided the defense with 20 photos of her face that were taken about a week following the accident. Also provided were five photos from the months just before the accident.

The article also states that the plaintiff additionally allowed the defense to take even more pictures at the plaintiff's September 2010 deposition.

In Piccolo, the defendants wanted access to other photos of the plaintiff that the plaintiff had posted of herself on Facebook. At her deposition, the plaintiff was asked about the Facebook account and defense counsel inquired whether could send a "neutral friend request" to the plaintiff so that he could then be granted access to the plaintiff's Facebook postings that the plaintiff testified she made everyday.

The plaintiff denied this request but, according to the defense filings on the motion to compel, indicated that at the deposition that her status updates and pictures were available for public viewing and that she would not make them private.

However, according to the defense filings, when the defense went to the plaintiff's Facebook page, those postings were private and only available to the plaintiff's friends. This prompted the defense attorney to follow up with a letter to the plaintiff's attorney requesting the plaintiff to accept a friend request from the defense. When that was denied, the motion to compel followed.

In support of its argument for access to the Facebook page, the defense cited the September 2010 Jefferson County trial court opinion of McMillen v. Hummingbird Speedway Inc., in which that court held that Facebook postings were discoverable and ordered the plaintiff to provide his username and password to the defense.

In opposition to the motion to compel, the plaintiffs argued that, contrary to the situation in the McMillen case, the defense counsel had only inquired about pictures posted on Facebook and not any textual postings. The plaintiffs also argued that the defense had already been provided with as complete a photographic record of a comparison of the plaintiff's pre-accident condition versus her post-accident condition as the defense could reasonably have a right to expect under the circumstances presented.

After hearing argument on the issue, Cepparulo issued his one-paragraph order in Piccolo denying the motion to compel. According to the article, it did not appear that the defense intended to appeal the decision in Piccolo.

It appears from the article that the focus of the plaintiff's injuries in Piccolo were on her facial scarring injuries as opposed to musculoskeletal injuries and the impact of those injuries on the plaintiff's activities of daily living. As set forth in the article on the case, the judge in Piccolo may have agreed with the plaintiff's contention that the defense request for access for even more photos of the plaintiff's face from her Facebook page was overkill.

A Decision In Favor of Disclosure

This is to be contrasted from the situation in McMillen where there was reason to believe that the plaintiff's Facebook page might offer relevant evidence that would serve to contradict the plaintiff's contentions of limitation in his activities of daily living as a result of his accident-related injuries.

McMillen involved a plaintiff who filed suit to recover damages for personal injuries allegedly caused when a defendant rear-ended the plaintiff's vehicle during a cool down lap following a 2007 stock car race.

During discovery, the defendant Hummingbird Speedway Inc., in its interrogatories inquired if the plaintiff belonged to any social networking computer sites. The defendant also requested the name of the site, the plaintiff's user name, login name, and password.

In this case, the plaintiff belonged to Facebook and MySpace but maintained that his user name and login name information were confidential and should not have to be provided.

In viewing the public portion of the plaintiff's Facebook page, the defendant noted comments evidencing that the plaintiff had gone on a fishing trip and had attended the Daytona 500 race in Florida.

When the plaintiff refused to fully respond to the written discovery requests pertaining to information on social networking sites of the plaintiff, the defendant filed a motion to compel the discovery desired.

The trial court noted that a party may obtain discovery regarding any information that is relevant and not privileged. The plaintiffs requested the court to find the communications shared among one's private friends on a social networking site to be confidential and, therefore, protect it from disclosure. Jefferson County Common Pleas Court President Judge John H. Foradora noted that no binding or persuasive authority was cited by the plaintiff.

Foradora additionally noted that evidentiary privileges are not favored under Pennsylvania law and should be narrowly construed.

The court found that the plaintiff did not satisfy the requirements to support a finding of privilege in this matter. The judge emphasized in his opinion that these communication websites expressly noted the possibility of disclosure.

The court in McMillen therefore found that a person using these sites could not reasonably expect that the communications would remain confidential. As the information contained in the plaintiff's pages may be relevant in proving the truth or falsity of the plaintiff's alleged injuries, the court found that the overriding goal — the search for truth in civil trials — should prevail in favor of the disclosure of information that may not have otherwise been known.

Accordingly, Foradora held that where a person's social networking sites contain information that may be relevant to the claims or defenses presented in a lawsuit, access to those sites during discovery should be freely granted.

As such, Foradora ordered the plaintiff to produce his Facebook and MySpace user names and passwords. The plaintiff was further ordered not to delete or alter any of the information on the accounts.

McMillen Followed

According to a May 24 article by Passarella in The Legal Intelligencer , the Jefferson County decision in McMillen was recently followed by Northumberland County Common Pleas Court Judge Charles H. Saylor in the case of Zimmerman v. Weis Markets Inc.

In Zimmerman, the plaintiff was suing his former employer for pain and suffering, scarring, and wage loss damages after he injured his leg in a forklift accident while working.

At his deposition, the plaintiff testified that he had not worn shorts since his accident because he was embarrassed by the scar on his leg from the accident. However, according to the court's opinion, the plaintiff was depicted in his public MySpace pictures wearing shorts with his scar visible. The plaintiff also posted pictures of himself with his motorcycle and discussed riding motorcycles elsewhere on his social media sites.

The defense filed a motion to compel discovery of the private portions of Zimmerman's Facebook and MySpace pages. In the motion, the defense sought discovery of the plaintiff's passwords, user names and login names. Relying on the Jefferson County decision in McMillen, the defense argued there may be relevant information as to the plaintiff's damages claims on the private portions of those pages.

The plaintiff asserted that his privacy interests outweigh the need to obtain this discovery material from the social networking sites. As an alternative argument, the plaintiff also requested that the court conduct an in camera review of the plaintiff's sites to determine what, if any, information should be produced in discovery.

Saylor rejected the request for an in camera review of the information as creating an undue burden on the court system in this emerging area of the law.

Saylor also decided to follow the ruling in McMillen and wrote, "This court agrees with the rationale of the opinion in McMillen, authorizing access for the reasons that no privilege exists in Pennsylvania for information posted in the non-public sections of social websites, liberal discovery is generally allowable, and the pursuit of truth as to alleged claims is a paramount ideal."

As such, the defense motion to compel discovery of the plaintiff's social networking sites was granted.

Social Networking Litigation Strategies

Written discovery requests and deposition questions pertaining to a party's social networking activities are becoming the norm in Pennsylvania civil litigation matters. It can be expected that more and more trial court decisions will be generated on this topic to further clarify the parameters of this type of discovery. As can be seen above, the current trend is in favor of the discovery of such information.

Also, as to other litigation strategies in this regard, I have seen recommendations that counsel secure a "litigation hold" court order against an opposing party in a lawsuit in order to prevent that other party from deleting any postings that post-date the subject accident from his or her Facebook page during the pendency of a litigation.

Should it be determined that a party has deleted or changed information on a social networking site after the institution of a lawsuit, it may be that spoliation of evidence issues may also arise. In such scenarios, it may come to be that the party seeking the deleted information may be entitled to an adverse •  inference jury instruction at trial.

Daniel E. Cummins is a partner and civil litigator with the Scranton law firm of Foley Cognetti Comerford Cimini & Cummins. His civil litigation blog, "Tort Talk," may be viewed at www.torttalk.com.