Sunday, April 24, 2011

Photos from Tort Talk Expo (April 20, 2011)



Judge Terrence Nealon, Judge William Nealon, and Judge Robert Mazzoni

Tuesday, April 19, 2011

Push Back on Confirmation of Medicare/Medicaid Liens Issue

A relatively recent trend in the settlement of civil litigation matters has included requests by the liability insurance company that the Plaintiff produce final lien information with regards to Medicare and/or Medicare before the matter can be finally concluded.  This is so because of the potential penalties that may exist if Medicare and/or Medicaid liens are not addressed out of the settlement funds.

In response, there has been a more recent push back by Plaintiff's counsel objecting to such requests for documented lien information, particularly where there has been previous confirmation that no such liens exist.

In an April 4, 2011 Order, in the case of Vincent v. Buck, No. 2011-CV-456 (Cambria Co., April 4, 2011, Swope, S.J.), Senior Judge Thomas A. Swope, Jr. of the Cambria County Court of Common Pleas granted a Plaintiff's Motion to Enforce a Settlement in a case where the carrier refused to issue a settlement check in a motor vehicle accident case until the Plaintiff produced documentation confirming the status of any Medicare/Medicaid Lien.

In Vincent, the Plaintiff's attorney had provided the liability carrier with copies of letters from Medicare confirming that there were no liens for the two Plaintiffs involved in this matter (these letters were not "final" confirmation lien letters).  The attorney also confirmed that, with respect to one of the Plaintiffs, that person's first party medical benefits coverage had not yet even been exhausted.

The Plaintiffs also emphasized that, in the Release, which was authored by the carrier, there was no requirement that the Plaintiffs provide any final lien documentation before the payment of the settlement funds as demanded.  Furthermore, the Release provided that the Plaintiffs agreed to remain responsible for any and all liens, including any liens asserted by any federal entity or agency.  In the Release, the Plaintiffs also specifically agreed to indemnify and hold the liability carrier and its counsel harmless for any and all liens that may arise.

In addition to arguing the above, the Plaintiffs also pointed to the recent Pennsylvania Superior Court case of Zaleppa v. Seiwell, 9 A.3d 632 (Pa.Super. 2010) in which the appellate court held that neither the liability carrier or the defendant tortfeasor had any legal standing to attempt to act on behalf of Medicare in terms of protecting a lien. 

Accordingly, when the settlement draft was not forthcoming, Plaintiff's filed a Motion to Enforce the Settlement which, as noted, was granted by the trial court in this matter.  In its Order, the trial court also allowed for interest on the delayed payment and attorney's fees and costs associated with the motion.

The prevailing Plaintiffs' attorney in this matter was Joseph J. Nypaver, Esq. of the Altoona, Pennsylvania law firm of Serbin, Kovacs & Nypaver, L.L.P.

Anyone desiring a copy of this Order (without opinion) in Vincent v. Buck may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

Friday, April 15, 2011

Judge Van Jura of Luzerne County Addresses Motion For Coordination in a Post-Koken Case

I recently reported on Judge Terrence R. Nealon’s Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas Opinion in the case of Bingham v. Poswistilo Ritz, and Erie Ins., No. 10-CIV-6020 (Lacka. Co., April 8, 2011, Nealon, J), in which Judge Nealon ruled that third party liability claims and UIM claims may be consolidated under one caption in the post-Koken world but in which Judge Nealon also ruled that such claims should be severed in the case before him under venue issues,

At the end of his Opinion in Binghman, Judge Nealon noted that the Court took no position as to whether a plaintiff may attempt to thereafter coordinate a UIM claim in Lackawanna County with the severed tort claims in Lehigh County under the different standards applicable under Pa. R.C.P. 213.1(a)(c), pertaining to “coordination of actions in different counties.”

On the heels of Judge Nealon's opinion, comes a Luzerne County decision by Judge Joseph Van Jura in the case of Orsulak v. Penn National Mutual Cas. Ins. Co. and Penn National Ins., No. 12255-Civil-2010 (Luz. Co., April 12, 2011, Van Jura, J.), addressing the open issue of coordination that was raised by Judge Nealon in the Bingham decision.

Judge Van Jura tackled this very issue in the Orsulak case and set forth the various factors to be considered on a Motion for Coordination/Petition to Transfer Venue that filed by the Defendant carrier pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 213.1.

Under Pa. R.C.P. 213.1(a), it is provided that “[i]n actions pending in different counties which involve a common question of law or fact or which arise from the same transactions or occurrence, any party, with notice to all other parties, may file a motion requesting the court in which a complaint was first filed to order coordination of the actions. Any party may file an answer to the motion and the court may hold a hearing.”

Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 213.1(c) sets forth at least six (6) factors to be used by the Court in determining whether to order coordination and to determine which location is appropriate for the coordinated proceedings. Judge Van Jura noted that the “basis for the rule is the avoidance of multiple trials and proceedings in these separate actions and the resultant economy to both the parties and the judicial system.” Orsulak at p. 4.

In addition to reviewing the factors noted under Rule 213.1, Judge Van Jura also noted guidance from the Explanatory Comment to the rule “which explains that the ultimate determination that the Court must make is whether coordination is ‘a fair and efficient method of adjudicating the controversy.’” Id.

In Orsulak, the Plaintiffs’ claims arose from a motor vehicle accident that occurred in Monroe County. The Plaintiffs filed a Writ of Summons in Monroe County against the tortfeasors only.

The case in Monroe County sat dormant with a Writ only filed while the Plaintiffs attempted to resolve their claims with a worker’s compensation carrier and with Penn National as the UIM carrier.

When the claim with the UIM carrier and the worker’s compensation carrier could not be resolved, the Plaintiffs filed a separate Complaint against Penn National as the UIM carrier alleging causes of action for breach of contract (UIM) and bad faith in Luzerne County.

Thereafter, the UIM carrier filed its Motion for Coordination/Petition to Transfer. After applying the six factors under Rule 213.1(c), along with a guidance from the Explanatory Comment, to the case before him, Judge Van Jura ruled that the Motion for Coordination should be granted and that venue in the Luzerne County case should be transferred to Monroe County.

Judge Van Jura noted that Luzerne County had no, or virtually no, connection with, the issues involved, the facts or site of the accident in question, the potential witnesses, or other sources of proof.

Judge Van Jura also noted that the Plaintiffs reside in Northampton County and that their residence was less than 33 driving miles from the Monroe County Courthouse, but over 61 driving miles to the Luzerne County Courthouse.

The court was also influenced by the fact that both the Luzerne County case and the Monroe County case were in their seminal stages and that coordination would, therefore, not result in any unreasonable delay, expense, or prejudice to any party in the action. Judge Van Jura additionally pointed to the benefits of judicial economy that would result from a coordination of the actions together in Monroe County.


Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion in the case of Orsulak v. Penn National by Judge Van Jura may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.

New A.3d Cite for Richner v. McCance Case

The new Atlantic Third citation for the recent case in which the Pennsylvania Superior Court skirted the consolidation verses severance issue in post-Koken cases is, as follows:


Richner v. McCance, 13 A.3d 950 (Pa. Super. 2011) (Insurance company’s Preliminary Objections objecting to the joinder of a Plaintiff’s third party tort claim with a count for declaratory judgment against the insurance company sustained; however, the Superior Court “emphasize[d] that [it was] not here deciding the propriety of the joinder of third party liability claims with post-Koken UIM benefit claims).

Fair Share Legislation Passes in House -- Now Goes to Senate

On Monday, April 11, 2011, Pennsylvania’s House of Representatives passed HB 1 by a vote of 112-81. The bill would replace Pennsylvania’s joint/several liability with “fair share” liability, i.e. in most cases the defendant would only be required to pay that percentage of liability assessed to that defendant by the jury's verdict.

The bill now moves on to the Pennsylvania Senate but it is currently unclear as to when the Senate will tackle this issue. Governor Corbett has previously and publicly acknowledged his support of the Fair Share legislation.

Thursday, April 14, 2011

TORT TALK EXPO ALL SET FOR NEXT WEDNESDAY

The Tort Talk Expo 2011, set to take place from 1pm - 5pm (Registration 1pm - 1:30pm) on Wednesday, April 20, 2011 at the Mohegan Sun Casino in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, is just two weeks away. This CLE program has been approved for 2 substantive and 1 ethics CLE Credit.

The seminar will be followed by a Cocktail Reception at the Breakers bar in the Mohegan Sun Casino from 5pm - 6:30 pm where attendees can continue to network and mingle.

Seats are being filled up quickly by Plaintiff's attorneys, Defense counsel, and Claims Professionals. Currently, there are over 90 attendees signed up and nearly a dozen vendor tables with different legal-related companies hoping to show you the services they can offer.

Here is an alphabetical listing of the table vendors currently scheduled to exhibit at the Tort Talk seminar:


At the Scene, Inc.:  www.atthescene.com



Courtside Documents: www.courtsidedoc.com


Digital Justice: www.digitaljustice.net




Innovative Nursing Consultants, Inc.


Love Court Reporting: www.lovecourtreporting.com


Minnesota Lawyers' Mutual: www.mlmins.com




Northeastern Rehabilitation Associates:


Strategic Financial Planners: www.strategicfinancialplanners.com


Surveillance Professionals Investigations: 



If you are interested in attending this seminar/networking event, please use the Registration Form below:

TORT TALK EXPO 2011

Seasons Ballroom
Mohegan Sun Casino
Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania

April 20, 2011

1 p.m. - 5 p.m.

[Registration 1 p.m. - 1:30 pm]
 
(2 SUBSTANTIVE CREDITS, 1 ETHICS CREDIT)

Followed by a Cocktail Reception at the

Breakers Nightclub

in the Mohegan Sun Casino
The TORT TALK EXPO 2011 is designed to be a CLE Program that will be as entertaining and informative as the posts regularly sent out from the Tort Talk blog.

The seminar will be immediately followed by a cocktail reception at which attendees can network with fellow lawyers, insurance professionals, and members of the federal and state judiciary from around Northeastern Pennsylvania.

The TORT TALK EXPO 2011 will include door prizes for every attendee and chances to win raffle prizes (gift cards, sporting event tickets, etc.). There will also be vendor tables for attendees to visit with a variety of service providers in the legal field.

Also, a portion of the proceeds from this event will be donated to the Janet Weis Children's Hospital in the Geisinger Health System in Danville, Pennsylvania.

The CLE Program will include the following topics and presenters:
THE TORT TALK TOP TEN (or so) CASES

Presenter: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
LITTLE LEAGUE TIPS FOR BIG LEAGUE LAWYERS

Presenter: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
(Will utilize baseball video clips to provide tips for the practice of law)


ANATOMY FOR LAWYERS: NECK AND BACK

(Also, witness a live simulation IME by an Orthopedic Surgeon)
Presenter: Dr. Lucian Bednarz, Physiatrist - Northeastern Rehabilitation Associates


Presenter: Dr. Thomas A. Allardyce, Orthopedic Surgeon

 
A VIEW FROM THE BENCH:

Ethical Issues in Legal Writing and Advocacy Before the Court
Moderator: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire

Presenters: Judge Thomas Raup and Judge Thomas Wallitsch
of ADR Options -- Tips for Mediation/Arbitration

Presenters: Federal District Judge William J. Nealon, Lackawanna County Judge Robert A. Mazzoni and other members of judicial panel to be identified - Tips for Pre-Trial Conferences
Networking Cocktail Reception Follows at Breakers

5 p.m. - 6:30 p.m.

Costs to cover both CLE Seminar and Cocktail Reception:
Claims professionals/representatives and risk managers
$25.00

Lawyers who are Tort Talk Email Subscribers
$145.00
Lawyers who are not Tort Talk Email Subscribers
$165.00


Make checks payable to "Tort Talk."
For reservations, please complete the requested information below and return it to the address noted below or e-mail it to dancummins@comcast.net.
 
Name(s)____________________________________

Firm/Company_______________________________

 

MAIL REGISTRATION FORM AND PAYMENT TO:

TORT TALK
c/o Daniel E. Cummins, Esq.
Foley, Cognetti, Comerford, Cimini & Cummins
507 Linden Street
Suite 700
Scranton, PA 18503
For more information, contact Dan Cummins at 570-346-0745 or at dancummins@comcast.net.

 
HOPE TO SEE YOU THERE!

Monday, April 11, 2011

Judge Terrence Nealon Thoroughly Weighs In on Joinder and Venue Issues in Post-Koken Matters

On April 8, 2011, in the case of Bingham v. Poswistilo, Ritz, and Erie Ins., No. 10 - CV - 6020 (Lacka. Co., April 8, 2011, Nealon, J.)(32 pages), Judge Terrence R. Nealon of the Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas issued the most thorough Opinion to date on the issues of venue and the consolidation vs. severance of third party claims and UIM claims in post-Koken Matters.

I proudly note that, in his Opinion, Judge Nealon actually cited to Tort Talk, with its compilation of cases in the Post-Koken Scorecard, as being part of his research on the issues presented.

Concisely, Judge Nealon held in Bingham that tort and UIM claims can be joined under Rule 2229(b) since (1) the tortfeasor and UIM insurer may be "separately" liable to the plaintiff, that is, the tortfeasor up to the liability coverage limits and the UIM carrier for any amount in excess of the liability coverage, (2) both claims arise out of the same occurrence, and (3) both claims involve common questions of fact or law affecting the liabilities of the tortfeasor and UIM insurer.

In so ruling, Judge Nealon emphasized that Rule 2229(b) does not require the tortfeasor and UIM carrier to be jointly and severally liable in that it uses the disjunctive "or" in the phrase "right to relief jointly, severally, separately or in the alternative...." [Emphasis added here].

After reviewing the split of authority on the issue of consolidation vs. severance of claims from around the Commonwealth, as well as the split of authority on the issue in his own County of Lackawanna, Judge Nealon came down on the side of allowing for the consolidation of such claims.

As for the evidentiary issue(s) involving insurance that may come into play when a consolidated case of a third party claim and a UIM claim reaches trial, Judge Nealon concluded that that issue was a matter for the presiding trial judge rather than a matter to be decided at the preliminary objections stage in the case before him.

Judge Nealon nevertheless went on to provide a thorough analysis of how the evidentiary issue has been discussed and/or handled by other courts, both in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and in other jurisdictions.  The Judge reviewed the different approaches adopted by other states i.e., trying the case as a tort case with the UIM insurer removed from the caption, but bound by the verdict, and insurance not referenced vs. allowing UIM insurance to be mentioned, but not on the issue of whether the tortfeasor "acted negligently or otherwise wrongfully," and considering such evidence as being "offered for another purpose" as permitted by Rule 411.

Ultimately, Judge Nealon decided that it should be the trial judge who could revisit the evidence of insurance issue closer to the time of trial and determine, again, at that time, whether the cases should remain consolidated for trial purposes. 

At this preliminary objections stage of the matter, the Bingham court felt that the better approach was to leave the cases consolidated for at least discovery purposes as a matter of judicial economy and to lessen the burden and expenses on the parties and the court.

While Judge Nealon ruled that the claims could be consolidated under one caption, he ultimately ruled that the cases should be severed under the venue issue presented in this matter.

Under the facts of the Bingham case, the accident occurred in Lehigh County and the tortfeasors were not residents of Lackawanna County and could not be served in Lackawanna County.

The Plaintiff filed the Complaint in Lackawanna County on account of the fact that the Plaintiff's UIM policy with Erie Insurance Exchange had a forum selection clause that required the lawsuit to be pursued in the county of the insured's domicile or residence (which was Lackawanna County). 

Judge Nealon noted that Erie's forum selection clause had been previously upheld as valid by the Pennsylvania Superior Court in the separate case of O'Hara v. First Liberty Ins. Corp., 984 A.2d 938 (Pa.Super. 2009) appeal denied, 995 A.2d 354 (Pa. 2010).

The Plaintiff argued that all of the claims could be pursued in Lackawanna County under the venue Rules of Civil Procedure (Pa.R.C.P. 1006(c)(1)) which essentially states that, where venue was good for one of the defendants, the other defendants could also be brought to suit in that same county.

However, Judge Nealon noted that Pa.R.C.P. 1006(c)(1) only applies in actions "to enforce a joint or joint and several liability," and because the UIM insurer could never be responsible for the full amount of the jury award, it could not be considered to ever be potentially jointly and severally liable with the tortfeasor(s).

Accordingly, the Judge sustained the venue preliminary objection asserted by the tortfeasor defendants, severed the tort and UIM claims, and transferred the tort action to Lehigh County and kept the UIM claim in Lackawanna County as per the forum selection clause.

In his Opinion, Judge Nealon went on to note that the court took no position as to whether the Plaintiff may thereafter attempt to coordinate his UIM claim in Lackawanna County with the tort claims in Lehigh County under the different standard applicable under Pa.R.C.P. 213.1(a) and (c).


Anyone desiring a copy of this thorough Opinion by Judge Nealon in the Bingham case may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.