On April 5, 2011, I attended the re-argument of the Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital case before an En Banc Superior Court Panel.
The argument was held at a special session of the Court at the MMI Preparatory School in Freeland, Luzerne County, Pennsylvania and it was noted that this was the first time an En Banc Superior Court had ever heard arguments in a high school setting.
You may recall that Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hospital involved the issue of whether repeated written communications by one attorney to that attorney's retained medical expert were discoverable, particularly where such communications were admittedly and purposefully designed to address the strategy of how the expert should frame his opinion and where such communications were found by the the trial court judge to have potentially "materially impacted" the expert's formulation of his opinion.
I wrote the amicus curiae appellate brief on behalf of the Pennsylvania Defense Institute in support of the appellee's position that such communications should indeed be discoverable under the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. The amicus brief can be viewed at this link:
http://www.jdsupra.com/post/documentViewer.aspx?fid=13d479ae-68e2-41c2-8279-492075821e68
Judge Hess of the Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas originally ruled in Barrick at the trial court level that such communications were discoverable. On appeal, the original Superior Court panel, which consisted of Judges Musmanno, Lazarus, and Olsen, affirmed.
When the Plaintiff's Petition for Re-Argument En Banc was granted, the Superior Court's original decision was withdrawn.
The En Banc Panel of Superior Court Judges that heard the re-argument did not consist of any of the Judges who heard the case the first time around.
The panel instead consisted of President Judge Correale F. Stevens, Judge John T. Bender, Judge Mary Jane Bowes, Judge Jack A. Panella, Judge Christine L. Donohue, Judge Jacqueline O. Shogan, Judge Sallie Updyke Mundy, Judge Paula Francisco Ott, and Judge Robert A. Freedberg.
After a spirited debate between the panel and the attorneys over the interplay between Pa.R.C.P. 4003.3 and 4003.5, i.e. the balance between the protections of the attorney work product doctrine and the discoverability of the bases for an expert's opinion, the Court took the matter under advisement.
I will keep you advised as to any decision issued by the Court.
Tuesday, April 5, 2011
En Banc Superior Court Panel Hears Re-Argument in Barrick
Large Jury Verdict In Wayne County MVA Case
Here's a link to a blurb in the Sunday, April 3, 2011 Scranton Times Tribune reporting on a $1.9 million dollar jury verdict secured by Attorney Dan Munley for his clients in a Wayne County automobile accident case: http://thetimes-tribune.com/jury-returns-1-9-million-verdict-for-wayne-county-family-injured-in-crash-1.1127359#axzz1ISeFvE5u
Monday, April 4, 2011
TORT TALK EXPO 2011 Is Two Weeks Away (April 20, 2011)
The Tort Talk Expo 2011, set to take place from 1pm - 5pm (Registration 1pm - 1:30pm) on Wednesday, April 20, 2011 at the Mohegan Sun Casino in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, is just two weeks away. This CLE program has been approved for 2 substantive and 1 ethics CLE Credit.
The seminar will be followed by a Cocktail Reception at the Breakers bar in the Mohegan Sun Casino from 5pm - 6:30 pm where attendees can continue to network and mingle.
Seats are being filled up quickly by Plaintiff's attorneys, Defense counsel, and Claims Professionals. Currently, there are 84 attendees signed up and nearly a dozen vendor tables with different legal-related companies hoping to show you the services they can offer.
Here is an alphabetical listing of the table vendors currently scheduled to exhibit at the Tort Talk seminar:
If you are interested in attending this seminar/networking event, please use the Registration Form below:
The seminar will be followed by a Cocktail Reception at the Breakers bar in the Mohegan Sun Casino from 5pm - 6:30 pm where attendees can continue to network and mingle.
Seats are being filled up quickly by Plaintiff's attorneys, Defense counsel, and Claims Professionals. Currently, there are 84 attendees signed up and nearly a dozen vendor tables with different legal-related companies hoping to show you the services they can offer.
Here is an alphabetical listing of the table vendors currently scheduled to exhibit at the Tort Talk seminar:
Cleverfish: http://www.cleverfish.com/
Courtside Documents: www.courtsidedoc.com
Digital Justice: www.digitaljustice.net
Exhibit A: www.exhibitadigital.com
Innovative Nursing Consultants, Inc.
Love Court Reporting: www.lovecourtreporting.com
Minnesota Lawyers' Mutual: www.mlmins.com
Optimo-iT: www.optimo-it.com
Northeastern Rehabilitation Associates: www.nerehab.com
Strategic Financial Planners: www.strategicfinancialplanners.com
If you are interested in attending this seminar/networking event, please use the Registration Form below:
TORT TALK EXPO 2011
Seasons Ballroom
Mohegan Sun Casino
Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania
April 20, 2011
1 p.m. - 5 p.m.
[Registration 1 p.m. - 1:30 pm]
(2 SUBSTANTIVE CREDITS, 1 ETHICS CREDIT)
Followed by a Cocktail Reception at the
Breakers Nightclub
in the Mohegan Sun Casino
The TORT TALK EXPO 2011 is designed to be a CLE Program that will be as entertaining and informative as the posts regularly sent out from the Tort Talk blog.
The seminar will be immediately followed by a cocktail reception at which attendees can network with fellow lawyers, insurance professionals, and members of the federal and state judiciary from around Northeastern Pennsylvania.
The TORT TALK EXPO 2011 will include door prizes for every attendee and chances to win raffle prizes (gift cards, sporting event tickets, etc.). There will also be vendor tables for attendees to visit with a variety of service providers in the legal field.
Also, a portion of the proceeds from this event will be donated to the Janet Weis Children's Hospital in the Geisinger Health System in Danville, Pennsylvania.
The CLE Program will include the following topics and presenters:
THE TORT TALK TOP TEN (or so) CASES
Presenter: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
LITTLE LEAGUE TIPS FOR BIG LEAGUE LAWYERS
Presenter: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
(Will utilize baseball video clips to provide tips for the practice of law)
ANATOMY FOR LAWYERS: NECK AND BACK
(Also, witness a live simulation IME by an Orthopedic Surgeon)
Presenter: Dr. Lucian Bednarz, Physiatrist - Northeastern Rehabilitation Associates
Presenter: Dr. Thomas A. Allardyce, Orthopedic Surgeon
A VIEW FROM THE BENCH:
Ethical Issues in Legal Writing and Advocacy Before the Court
Moderator: Daniel E. Cummins, Esquire
Presenters: Judge Thomas Raup and Judge Thomas Wallitsch
of ADR Options -- Tips for Mediation/Arbitration
Presenters: Federal District Judge William J. Nealon, Lackawanna County Judge Robert A. Mazzoni and other members of judicial panel to be identified - Tips for Pre-Trial Conferences
Networking Cocktail Reception Follows at Breakers
5 p.m. - 6:30 p.m.
Costs to cover both CLE Seminar and Cocktail Reception:
Claims professionals/representatives and risk managers
$25.00
Lawyers who are Tort Talk Email Subscribers
$145.00
Lawyers who are not Tort Talk Email Subscribers
$165.00
Make checks payable to "Tort Talk."
For reservations, please complete the requested information below and return it to the address noted below or e-mail it to dancummins@comcast.net.
Name(s)____________________________________
Firm/Company_______________________________
MAIL REGISTRATION FORM AND PAYMENT TO:
TORT TALK
c/o Daniel E. Cummins, Esq.
Foley, Cognetti, Comerford, Cimini & Cummins
507 Linden Street
Suite 700
Scranton, PA 18503
For more information, contact Dan Cummins at 570-346-0745 or at dancummins@comcast.net.
HOPE TO SEE YOU THERE!
Friday, April 1, 2011
Federal Middle District Judge Caputo Construes Definition of "Occupying" in a Motor Vehicle Insurance Coverage Case
In a March 28, 2011 Memorandum Opinion in the casee of Sona v. State Farm, No. 3:10-CV-1416 (M.D.Pa. March 28, 2011, Caputo, J.), Judge A. Richard Caputo addressed the issue of whether or not the injured party was "occupying" a dirt bike at the time of an accident, since if he was, the injured party would be precluded from both first party medical benefits and UIM coverage under the terms of the State Farm policy.
The case of Sona involved an injured party who had taken his van to a garage for repairs. Upon arriving at the garage, he removed a dirt bike from the rear of the van so that the oil could be changed on the bike as well.
After the bike was removed, a mechanic drove the van into the garage. The injured party was then manually pushing the dirt bike into the garage. The injured party did not have the key for the dirt bike and never sat on it. While the injured party was moving the bike manually across the parking lot, another vehicle backed out of its parking spot and struck the injured party's hand, causing personal injuries.
The parties went into litigation and eventually filed cross-motions on the issue of coverage for first party benefits and UIM benefits. As noted, the issue centered around whether or not the injured party was occupying the motorcycle at the time of the accident. If he was, exclusions under the policy would have precluded coverage.
Judge Caputo confirmed the law that a dirt bike is considered to be a "motor vehicle" under Pennsylvania law and turned to the case of Utica Mut. Ins. Co. v. Contrisciane, 473 A.2d 1005 (Pa. 1984) for the relevant factors to utilize in determining whether a person was "occupying" a motor vehicle at the time of an accident.
After applying those factors to the case at hand, Judge Caputo ruled that the injured party was not" occupying" the dirt bike at the time of the accident. The court noted that, rather than being used as a "motor vehicle" at the time of the accident, the dirt bike was being used in a manner more akin to a situation like a person moving a piece of furniture.
The court therefore found that the exclusions to coverage under the policy were inapplicable. As such, Judge Caputo entered a ruling in favor of coverage.
I have been informed that the parties involved agreed that no appeal would be filed from Judge Caputo's decision.
Anyone desiring a copy of this decision may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
I send thanks to the prevailing Plaintiff's attorney Howard Rothenberg of the Scranton law office of Herlands, Rothenberg & Levine for bringing this case to my attention
The case of Sona involved an injured party who had taken his van to a garage for repairs. Upon arriving at the garage, he removed a dirt bike from the rear of the van so that the oil could be changed on the bike as well.
After the bike was removed, a mechanic drove the van into the garage. The injured party was then manually pushing the dirt bike into the garage. The injured party did not have the key for the dirt bike and never sat on it. While the injured party was moving the bike manually across the parking lot, another vehicle backed out of its parking spot and struck the injured party's hand, causing personal injuries.
The parties went into litigation and eventually filed cross-motions on the issue of coverage for first party benefits and UIM benefits. As noted, the issue centered around whether or not the injured party was occupying the motorcycle at the time of the accident. If he was, exclusions under the policy would have precluded coverage.
Judge Caputo confirmed the law that a dirt bike is considered to be a "motor vehicle" under Pennsylvania law and turned to the case of Utica Mut. Ins. Co. v. Contrisciane, 473 A.2d 1005 (Pa. 1984) for the relevant factors to utilize in determining whether a person was "occupying" a motor vehicle at the time of an accident.
After applying those factors to the case at hand, Judge Caputo ruled that the injured party was not" occupying" the dirt bike at the time of the accident. The court noted that, rather than being used as a "motor vehicle" at the time of the accident, the dirt bike was being used in a manner more akin to a situation like a person moving a piece of furniture.
The court therefore found that the exclusions to coverage under the policy were inapplicable. As such, Judge Caputo entered a ruling in favor of coverage.
I have been informed that the parties involved agreed that no appeal would be filed from Judge Caputo's decision.
Anyone desiring a copy of this decision may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
I send thanks to the prevailing Plaintiff's attorney Howard Rothenberg of the Scranton law office of Herlands, Rothenberg & Levine for bringing this case to my attention
Judge Kosik of Federal Middle District Court Addresses IME Issue
Judge Edwin Kosik of the Federal District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania recently issued an interesting discovery order in the post-Koken case of Kurland v. Santiago, Civil No. 3:10-Civ-1278 (March 28, 2011).
In that case, there was apparently a dispute on whether or not the Plaintiff could have a registered nurse accompany the Plaintiff to an medical examination arranged by the defense and whether that nurse could audio tape and/or video tape the proceedings.
In his Order, Judge Kosik allowed the Plaintiff to bring a registered nurse to “witness the examination in a professional and unobtrusive manner without any oral or video recordings.”
The prevailing attorneys in this matter were Attorneys Bryon R. Kaster and C. J. Haddick of the Camp Hill, Pennsylvania law firm of Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote.
This ruling emphasizes the difference between Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35, which pertains to "Physical and Mental Examinations," and Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4010, pertaining to "Physical and Mental Examination of Persons."
Fed.R.C.P. 35 is silent on the ability of a party to have a representative or nurse present at an IME. The Rule is also silent on whether or not the proceedings can be audio taped or video taped.
In contrast, the state rule PA.R.C.P. 4010 specifically expressly allows a party to bring a representative or attorney with them to the IME. That Rule also allows for the stenographic or audio taping of the IME. The state rule is silent as to the issue of video taping.
Anyone desiring a copy of Judge Kosik's Order may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
In that case, there was apparently a dispute on whether or not the Plaintiff could have a registered nurse accompany the Plaintiff to an medical examination arranged by the defense and whether that nurse could audio tape and/or video tape the proceedings.
In his Order, Judge Kosik allowed the Plaintiff to bring a registered nurse to “witness the examination in a professional and unobtrusive manner without any oral or video recordings.”
The prevailing attorneys in this matter were Attorneys Bryon R. Kaster and C. J. Haddick of the Camp Hill, Pennsylvania law firm of Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote.
This ruling emphasizes the difference between Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35, which pertains to "Physical and Mental Examinations," and Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4010, pertaining to "Physical and Mental Examination of Persons."
Fed.R.C.P. 35 is silent on the ability of a party to have a representative or nurse present at an IME. The Rule is also silent on whether or not the proceedings can be audio taped or video taped.
In contrast, the state rule PA.R.C.P. 4010 specifically expressly allows a party to bring a representative or attorney with them to the IME. That Rule also allows for the stenographic or audio taping of the IME. The state rule is silent as to the issue of video taping.
Anyone desiring a copy of Judge Kosik's Order may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
Tuesday, March 29, 2011
Judge Van Jura of Luzerne County Addresses Effect of Release Between Original Parties on Claims of Contribution Between Defendants
In a March 23, 2011 Opinion, Judge Joseph Van Jura of the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas addressed the issue of the effect of a Release entered into by a Plaintiff and an original Defendant upon claims for contribution by the original Defendant against an Additional Defendant in the case of Hartzell v. Saxe, No. 5503 of 2002 (Luz. Co. March 23, 2011, Van Jura, J.).
The Hartzell case arose out of a motor vehicle accident. The Plaintiffs sued original Defendants, Saxe and Medico. The original Defendants joined in certain additional defendants including Additional Defendant, Redmond.
The trial court emphasized that both the original Complaint and the Praecipe for Writ to Join Additional Defendants were filed within the applicable two year statute of limitations.
In their Joinder Complaint, the original Defendants included a prayer of relief demanding judgment against the Additional Defendant, Redmond “solely and/or for contribution and/or for indemnity on the causes of action alleged by the Plaintiffs….”
Judge Van Jura reviewed the Uniform Contribution Among Tort-Feasors Act, 42 Pa. C.S. §8324(c), which provides that “a joint tort-feasor who enters into a settlement with the injured persons is not entitled to recover contribution from another joint tort-feasor whose liability to the injured person is not extinguished by the settlement."
In this matter, the Additional Defendant filed a Motion for Summary Judgment alleging that the original Defendants were unable to establish the necessary elements for a claim of contribution against the Additional Defendant given the Release entered into by the Plaintiff and the original Defendant.
The Court noted that, when the original Defendants entered into a settlement with the Plaintiffs by way of a Release, the terms of that Release provided that the Plaintiffs were releasing the original Defendants for any and all claims in full settlement. The Release also contained language confirming that the Release did not extend to the Additional Defendants, including Additional Defendant Redmond.
As such, the Additional Defendant Redmond argued that the Release in question did not extinguish his liability to the Plaintiff as required under 42 Pa. C.S. §8234(c) and that, therefore, the original Defendants were precluded from pursuing a claim of contribution against the Additional Defendant.
Although the original Defendants produced evidence showing that the Plaintiff did not have any intention of moving forward upon its case any further and had filed a Praecipe for Discontinuance of the Plaintiffs’ claims only, Judge Van Jura nevertheless held that the Additional Defendant Redmond was entitled to summary judgment on the original Defendant’s contribution claim, because the Release in question in this matter could not be construed to extinguish the potential liability of the Additional Defendant to the Plaintiff.
This issue kind of hurts your head when you try to think it through. Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
The Hartzell case arose out of a motor vehicle accident. The Plaintiffs sued original Defendants, Saxe and Medico. The original Defendants joined in certain additional defendants including Additional Defendant, Redmond.
The trial court emphasized that both the original Complaint and the Praecipe for Writ to Join Additional Defendants were filed within the applicable two year statute of limitations.
In their Joinder Complaint, the original Defendants included a prayer of relief demanding judgment against the Additional Defendant, Redmond “solely and/or for contribution and/or for indemnity on the causes of action alleged by the Plaintiffs….”
Judge Van Jura reviewed the Uniform Contribution Among Tort-Feasors Act, 42 Pa. C.S. §8324(c), which provides that “a joint tort-feasor who enters into a settlement with the injured persons is not entitled to recover contribution from another joint tort-feasor whose liability to the injured person is not extinguished by the settlement."
In this matter, the Additional Defendant filed a Motion for Summary Judgment alleging that the original Defendants were unable to establish the necessary elements for a claim of contribution against the Additional Defendant given the Release entered into by the Plaintiff and the original Defendant.
The Court noted that, when the original Defendants entered into a settlement with the Plaintiffs by way of a Release, the terms of that Release provided that the Plaintiffs were releasing the original Defendants for any and all claims in full settlement. The Release also contained language confirming that the Release did not extend to the Additional Defendants, including Additional Defendant Redmond.
As such, the Additional Defendant Redmond argued that the Release in question did not extinguish his liability to the Plaintiff as required under 42 Pa. C.S. §8234(c) and that, therefore, the original Defendants were precluded from pursuing a claim of contribution against the Additional Defendant.
Although the original Defendants produced evidence showing that the Plaintiff did not have any intention of moving forward upon its case any further and had filed a Praecipe for Discontinuance of the Plaintiffs’ claims only, Judge Van Jura nevertheless held that the Additional Defendant Redmond was entitled to summary judgment on the original Defendant’s contribution claim, because the Release in question in this matter could not be construed to extinguish the potential liability of the Additional Defendant to the Plaintiff.
This issue kind of hurts your head when you try to think it through. Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
Another Decision in Favor of Consolidation out of Dauphin County
On March 21, 2011, Judge Scott Arthur Evans of the Dauphin County Court of Common Pleas issued a post-Koken Order in the case of Wolfe v. Hans and Progressive, No. 2010-CIVIL-11199 (Dauphin Co. March 21, 2011 Evans, J.), denying severance in response to Preliminary Objections and a Motion to Sever filed by the tortfeasor Defendant.
The prevailing attorney is Steven D. Stambaugh of the York, Pennsylvania office of Stambaugh Law, P.C.
This is the fifth decision out of Dauphin County in favor of consolidation. Click here to view the Post-Koken Scorecard on TortTalk.com: http://www.torttalk.com/2009/12/new-and-improved-updated-list-of-post.html.
Anyone desiring a copy of this Order (without Opinion) may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
The prevailing attorney is Steven D. Stambaugh of the York, Pennsylvania office of Stambaugh Law, P.C.
This is the fifth decision out of Dauphin County in favor of consolidation. Click here to view the Post-Koken Scorecard on TortTalk.com: http://www.torttalk.com/2009/12/new-and-improved-updated-list-of-post.html.
Anyone desiring a copy of this Order (without Opinion) may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
Labels:
Automobile Insurance,
Koken,
UIM,
UM,
Underinsured Motorists Claims,
Uninsured Motorists Claims
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

