In a case of semantics, the Pennsylvania Superior Court recently ruled in the case of Nationwide v. Catalini, 2011 WL 1089873 (Pa.Super. March 25, 2011, Bowes, Donohue, and Olsen, JJ.)(Opinion by Bowes), that an insured's signed form calling for an increase in their bodily injury liability coverage did not require an equal increase in the UM/UIM limits under the policy.
The dispute revolved around the inclusion of the language on the form stating "leave the other coverages the same."
The insureds argued that that language meant that they intended the UM/UIM coverage to be increased to the same amounts of the liability coverage. More specifically, the insureds wanted to bump up their UM/UIM coverage from $25,000/$50,000 to $100,000/$300,000.
Nationwide disagreed and asserted that the language at issue meant that the insured intended to increase only the liability coverage and keep the UM/UIM coverage the same as it was before the change in liability coverage was requested.
The Superior Court sided with the carrier's position and essentially ruled that the carrier did not have to obtain a new election form specifically regarding the UM/UIM coverage as the insureds had previously executed and submitted a form on the desired coverages in that regard a few years before this issue arose.
Here's a link to the Opinion online if you interested in reading it: http://www.pacourts.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/a29025_10.pdf
Source: Gina Passarella, "Increase in Bodily Injury Limits Doesn't Require New UM/UIM Elections, The Legal Intelligencer (March 29, 2011).
Tuesday, March 29, 2011
Superior Court Rules on Election of UM/UIM Coverages Issue
Labels:
Automobile Insurance,
Declaratory Judgment Actions,
UIM,
UM,
Underinsured Motorists Claims,
Uninsured Motorists Claims
Northeastern Pennsylvania Schools Fare Well in Statewide Mock Trial Competition
Here is a link to a write-up on the website of Wyoming Seminary High School (Kingston, Luzerne County, Pennsylvania), this year's champions of the statewide high school mock trial competition: http://www.wyomingseminary.org/page.cfm?p=299&newsid=159
Congratulations to the Wyoming Seminary High School students and their Attorney Advisors Frank Brier, Cathy O'Donnell, and Neil O'Donnell.
On a related note, Scranton Prep High School made it to the semi-finals and had as their Attorney Advisors John O'Brien and Judge Mannion.
Congratulations to the Wyoming Seminary High School students and their Attorney Advisors Frank Brier, Cathy O'Donnell, and Neil O'Donnell.
On a related note, Scranton Prep High School made it to the semi-finals and had as their Attorney Advisors John O'Brien and Judge Mannion.
Update on Luzerne County Matters
Here is a link to an article by Mark Guydish in the March 25, 2011 Times Leader providing an update on the case against former Luzerne County Judge Toole: http://www.timesleader.com/news/Attorney-says-he-and-Judge-Toole-created-a-paper-trail-for-beach-house.html?searchterm=Toole
Sunday, March 27, 2011
ARTICLE: Negligent Infliction of Emotional Distress Claims in Medical Malpractice Cases
My article, "A Suspension of Common Sense," which analyzed the evolution of the common law claim for negligent infliction of emotional distress and recent issues regarding that type of a claim in medical malpractice cases, was published in last week's Pennsylvania Law Weekly.
The article may be viewed by scrolling down to the JDSupra.com box in the right hand column of the blog and clicking on the link to the article or by clicking this link:
http://www.jdsupra.com/post/documentViewer.aspx?fid=94d68de3-6625-4999-80b9-a2d24ba00404.
The article may be viewed by scrolling down to the JDSupra.com box in the right hand column of the blog and clicking on the link to the article or by clicking this link:
http://www.jdsupra.com/post/documentViewer.aspx?fid=94d68de3-6625-4999-80b9-a2d24ba00404.
Thursday, March 24, 2011
Another Victory for Insurance Company in Debris in the Road Case
On March 2, 2011, Judge Joy Flowers Conti of the United States District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania granted a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings in favor of Allstate Insurance Company based upon a Complaint for declaratory relief in the case of Allstate v. Squires, Civil Action No. 10-1458 (W.D. Pa. March 2, 2011, Conti, J.).
In this case, the issue was whether an insured can bring a claim for uninsured motorist benefits when he was involved in an automobile accident after swerving to avoid a box on the roadway that apparently came from a phantom vehicle.
Based upon the reasoning set forth in the Smith, Terwillinger, and the Adragna cases (the Adragna case was handled by my firm), Judge Conti found that Allstate did not have an obligation to extend uninsured motorist coverage since the accident at issue did not arise from the ownership, maintenance, or use of an automobile.
I send thanks to the prevailing attorney R. Sean O’Connell of the Pittsburgh law firm of Robb Leonard Mulvihill for forwarding this Decision to my attention.
Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
In this case, the issue was whether an insured can bring a claim for uninsured motorist benefits when he was involved in an automobile accident after swerving to avoid a box on the roadway that apparently came from a phantom vehicle.
Based upon the reasoning set forth in the Smith, Terwillinger, and the Adragna cases (the Adragna case was handled by my firm), Judge Conti found that Allstate did not have an obligation to extend uninsured motorist coverage since the accident at issue did not arise from the ownership, maintenance, or use of an automobile.
I send thanks to the prevailing attorney R. Sean O’Connell of the Pittsburgh law firm of Robb Leonard Mulvihill for forwarding this Decision to my attention.
Anyone desiring a copy of this Opinion may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
Labels:
Automobile Insurance,
Coverage Questions,
Declaratory Judgment Actions,
UM,
Uninsured Motorists Claims
Another Luzerne County Post-Koken Decision in Favor of Consolidation
On March 16, 2011, Judge Thomas F. Burke, Jr. of the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas issued an Order denying the tortfeasor Defendant’s Preliminary Objections on the issue of consolidation of claims in the post-Koken case of Kush v. Rogowski and Progressive, No. 12760-Civil-2010 (Luz. Co., March 16, 2011, Burke, P.J.).
In Kush, the tortfeasor Defendant filed Preliminary Objections and the UIM carrier simply filed an Answer to the Complaint. I was advised that the tortfeasor Defendant raised the usual arguments of misjoinder and prejudice but also made this objection:
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS/FAILURE TO PLEAD PERFORMANCE OR OCCURRENCE OF CONDITION PRECEDENT
Under that preliminary objection, the tortfeasor Defendant asserted that the Plaintiff should not be permitted to join her underinsurance action in the underlying tort action unless and until Plaintiff has established that any and all preconditions to payment have been satisfied under the terms and conditions of her personal policy of insurance issued by Progressive.
As noted, the Court overruled the tortfeasor Defendant’s Preliminary Objections. In doing so, Judge Burke cited with a “See” signal, the case of Borthwick v. Webb and GEICO, 100 Luz. Reg. Reports 135 (2010).
As such, this Kush decision represents another Luzerne County decision in favor of the consolidation of post-Koken claims.
All of the cases compiled to date, can be viewed on the post-Koken scorecard by scrolling down the right hand column of this blog and clicking on the date under “Post-Koken scorecard.”
Note that the Post-Koken scorecard, while thorough, is not represented to be an exhaustive listing of all of the cases that may be out there. There could be other cases that I am not aware of and it is recommended that you conduct your own additional research in your own county.
I send thanks to prevailing Attorney Ann O’Donnell Farias of the O’Donnell Law Offices in Kingston, Pennsylvania for forwarding this case to my attention.
Anyone desiring a copy of this Order (without Opinion) in the case of Kush v. Rogowski and Progressive may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
In Kush, the tortfeasor Defendant filed Preliminary Objections and the UIM carrier simply filed an Answer to the Complaint. I was advised that the tortfeasor Defendant raised the usual arguments of misjoinder and prejudice but also made this objection:
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS/FAILURE TO PLEAD PERFORMANCE OR OCCURRENCE OF CONDITION PRECEDENT
Under that preliminary objection, the tortfeasor Defendant asserted that the Plaintiff should not be permitted to join her underinsurance action in the underlying tort action unless and until Plaintiff has established that any and all preconditions to payment have been satisfied under the terms and conditions of her personal policy of insurance issued by Progressive.
As noted, the Court overruled the tortfeasor Defendant’s Preliminary Objections. In doing so, Judge Burke cited with a “See” signal, the case of Borthwick v. Webb and GEICO, 100 Luz. Reg. Reports 135 (2010).
As such, this Kush decision represents another Luzerne County decision in favor of the consolidation of post-Koken claims.
All of the cases compiled to date, can be viewed on the post-Koken scorecard by scrolling down the right hand column of this blog and clicking on the date under “Post-Koken scorecard.”
Note that the Post-Koken scorecard, while thorough, is not represented to be an exhaustive listing of all of the cases that may be out there. There could be other cases that I am not aware of and it is recommended that you conduct your own additional research in your own county.
I send thanks to prevailing Attorney Ann O’Donnell Farias of the O’Donnell Law Offices in Kingston, Pennsylvania for forwarding this case to my attention.
Anyone desiring a copy of this Order (without Opinion) in the case of Kush v. Rogowski and Progressive may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.
Labels:
Automobile Insurance,
Koken,
UIM,
UM,
Underinsured Motorists Claims,
Uninsured Motorists Claims
New Logos for Tort Talk


Here are the new logos I had created for Tort Talk. The "T" with the Scales of Justice represents the "Tort" coverage by the blog and the surrounding cartoon bubble represents the "Talk." What do you think?
Now that the logo is in place, can the Tort Talk theme park be far behind. Some of the rides could include roller coasters like the "Res Ipsa Loqui-Coaster" and "Negligence is in the Air." Of course, there could also be bumping cars where the worst injuries possible are soft tissue sprain/strain injuries to the neck and back of 6 to 12 weeks duration.
Please be reminded that the Tort Talk Expo CLE Seminar set for April 20th at the Mohegan Sun Casino is now less than 30 days away. Over 70 people have signed up to date and, while seats remain, they are going fast.
The attendees so far are comprised of plaintiff's attorneys, defense attorneys, and claims professionals from a number of different carriers. So, in addition to being an opportunity to collect some CLE credits (2 substantive and 1 ethics), this event promises to be an excellent networking opportunity at the seminar and the following cocktail reception.
Here's the link to the Ad/Registration form:
http://www.torttalk.com/2011/02/federal-middle-district-judge-william-j.html
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

