Sunday, August 22, 2010

Recent Pennsylvania Supreme Court Decisions of Note

American and Foreign Insurance Company v. Jerry's Sports Center

My partner, Sal Cognetti, Esquire was local counsel for the prevailing party in a recent August 17, 2010 Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision that should have a significant impact in the insurance industry here in Pennsylvania.

In the case of American and Foreign Insurance Company v. Jerry's Sport Center, Inc., 2010 WL 3222404 (Pa. Aug. 17, 2010, Baer, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed the issue of whether, following a court's declaration that an insurance company had no duty to defend its insured, the insurance carrier was entitled to be reimbursed those amounts it paid out to defense counsel for the defense of its insured in the underlying suit.

The carrier was seeking such reimbursement from its insured on the basis of a series of reservation of rights letters as opposed to any express language in the insurance policy allowing for any such reimbursement.

The basic facts of the case involved a lawsuit filed by the NAACP against numerous firearms wholesalers and distributors for failing to reasonably and safely distribute its firearms to the public. The NAACP was asserting that this alleged negligence of the firearms dealers was the cause of injuries, deaths, and damages to NAACP members.

The insured in this matter, Jerry's Sports Center, was one of the defendant firearms dealers named in the underlying suit. American and Foreign Insurance Company defended Jerry's Sports Center under a reservation of rights and, when the carrier prevailed in its declaratory judgment action with a finding that it need not defend nor indemnify its insured under the circumstances of the lawsuit, the carrier sought to get back from its insured the defense costs it paid out to a New York City defense firm which costs were in excess of $300,000.

In its decision, the Supreme Court held that "an insurer is not entitled to be reimbursed for defense costs absent an express provision in the written insurance contract." Here, there was no such provision in the policy and, therefore, no reimbursement was allowed.

While this case involved a corporate insured, the decision appears to be a victory for the "little man" insured, protecting them from having to pay back insurance companies any defense costs in the event of a decision in favor of a carrier in a declaratory judgment action on the coverage/duty to defend issue (assuming there is nothing in the policy requiring the insured to reimburse the carrier in such circumstances).

To view the majority opinion by Justice Baer online, click on this link: http://www.aopc.org/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-48-2009mo.pdf


To view the concurring opinion by Justice Saylor: http://www.aopc.org/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-48-2009co.pdf


I thank my partner Sal Cognetti, Esquire for bringing this case to my attention.



Kincy v. Petro

In the case of Kincy v. Petro, 2010 WL 3222025 (Pa. Aug. 17, 2010, Todd, J.), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled upon the effect of a trial court order consolidating, under Pa.R.C.P. 213(a), two separate actions involving different parties and different theories of liability "for all purposes."

The Court ruled that, in such circumstances, "such an order does not result in the complete consolidation of such actions, such that the pleadings are merged and/or the actions shed their separate identities."

The underlying facts shed light on the issue presented. This matter involved a motor vehicle accident. In the Plaintiff's vehicle were two injured parties, Alice Kincy as the driver and her brother Jerome Nixon as a passenger. The Defendant vehicle was owned by a Defendant-mother who had allowed Defendant-daughter to drive the vehicle.

For some reason, the Plaintiff-driver, Alice Kincy, filed suit only against the Defendant-owner. The Defendant-owner filed an Answer and New Matter identifying the daughter as the driver of the Defendant vehicle at the time of the accident. Nevertheless, the Plaintiff-driver never amended her Complaint or otherwise sued the Defendant-driver.

Meanwhile the Plaintiff-passenger, Jerome Nixon, had filed suit against both the Defendant-owner and the Defendant-driver.

Thereafter, a trial court judge issued an order consolidating the two lawsuits "for all purposes" including discovery and arbitration. At a later joint arbitration, a panel ruled against the Plaintiff-driver, Alice Kincy, but entered an award in favor of Plaintiff-passenger, Jerome Nixon. Mr. Nixon would eventually settle his case.

The Plaintiff-driver, Alice Kincy, appealed her case up to the court of common pleas level where both the Defendant-owner and Defendant-driver asserted in a summary judgment motion that the Plaintiff-driver failed to timely assert a valid claim of negligence against the Defendant-driver.

Kincy countered by arguing that the consolidation order merged her Complaint with Nixon's Complaint such that a valid negligence claim was indeed asserted against the Defendant-driver. She also filed her own motion for summary judgment with similar arguments. The trial court denied the cross motions for summary judgments without an opinion.

Later, however, a different trial court judge granted the Defendants' motion in limine to preclude the Plaintiff-driver from introducing any evidence against the Defendant-Driver who was not named in the Complaint at issue. That trial judge noted that, where the consolidation order involved actions having different parties, the order merely served to consolidate the two lawsuits, not merge them into one lawsuit. As such, the Defendants were granted a nonsuit at trial due to the failure to name the Defendant-Driver in the Complaint.

The nonsuit was upheld at the Supreme Court level. The Supreme Court's Opinion gives a nice analysis of the varying effects a trial court consolidation order may have.

Where there are identical parties, subject matter, issues and defenses, a consolidation order can result in a "complete consolidation," or merger of the actions into one lawsuit.

The Court rejected any notion that actions involving different parties, issues, or defenses could be completely consolidated, or merged into a single lawsuit, to be "untenable." Rather, such actions can be consolidated, or combined, for discovery purposes, for trial purposes, or both--but the cases still retain their separate identities under Pa.R.C.P. 213(a).

To view the majority Opinion of Justice Todd online, click on this link: http://www.aopc.org/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-92-2009mo.pdf


To view the concurring opinion by Justice Saylor, click on this link:
http://www.aopc.org/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-92-2009co.pdf




Applying this case to the cases that have been consolidated in the Post-Koken arena, it appears that, although those cases are combined to proceed under one caption, they remain their separate identities given that there are different parties involved on each side of the case.

The further import of this Kincy decision on those Post-Koken cases remains to be seen as those cases proceed toward trial across the Commonwealth.



I thank Attorney James Beck of the Philadelphia office of the Dechert LLP law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

TORT TALK Selected by LexisNexis as one of the TOP 50 INSURANCE LAW BLOGS in the U.S.

I have just been notified that Tort Talk was selected by the LexisNexis Insurance Law Community as one of the Top 50 Insurance Law Blogs in the United States!

I am grateful for all of the Tort Talkers who took the time to email their support for Tort Talk to LexisNexis. I send thanks again to all of you who have brought important cases to my attention to publicize--very much appreciated. I also thank the LexisNexis Insurance Law Blog Advisory Board for selecting Tort Talk for this honor. To paraphrase actress Sally Field, "You like the blog, you really like it!"

In its announcement of the top blogs selected, LexisNexis wrote, "These top blogs offer some of the best writing out there. They contain a wealth of information for all segments of the insurance industry, and include timely news items, expert analysis, practice tips, frequent postings and helpful links to other sites and sources."

In their specific reference to Tort Talk, LexisNexis wrote, "Recently nominated by the ILC Community, this blog provides updates, trends and thoughts about Pennsylvania Civil Litigation Law. It’s a nice mix of good writing, interesting topics and practical information for the insurance defense crowd."

Currently, Tort Talk has 378 subscribers. I have also been advised that, over the past year, it has also been cited as a resource on Post-Koken issues in several Federal Court Briefs and was mentioned at several oral arguments before various state level courts of common pleas.

The complete list of the Top 50 Insurance Law Blogs, in alphabetical order, can be viewed at this link:

http://www.lexisnexis.com/Community/insurancelaw/blogs/topblogs/archive/2010/06/22/insurance-law-community-s-top-50-insurance-blogs-for-2009.aspx



THANKS AGAIN FOR ALL YOUR SUPPORT. I HOPE TO KEEP YOU INTERESTED AND, AT TIMES, ENTERTAINED WITH MY WRITING.

Sunday, August 15, 2010

Studies Confirm Excessive Work Hours Decreases Productivity Levels


According to an August 11, 2010 online article entitled "Why Lawyers Should Work No More Than 40 Hours a Week" by Debra Cassens Weiss in the ABA Journal, about 100 years worth of productivity studies essentially all came to the conclusion that, after 40 hours at the office during any given week, one's work begins to suffer and become more error-prone.

As I have likewise recommended in several of my Pennsylvania Law Weekly articles, this article recommends limiting work hours to a reasonable number, limiting constant Blackberry use, focusing more on other parts of your life outside of work, and regular physical fitness as means to improve your practice and overall quality of life.

This short, but interesting, article can be viewed at:

Great Turnout Expected for CLE Seminar This Wednesday at the Mohegan Sun - PLEASE JOIN US

A great turnout is expected for the CLE seminar being put on by the Pennsylvania Defense Institute and the Northeastern Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association this Wednesday, August 18, 2010 at the Mohegan Sun Casino in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania.

Presently, there are approximately 60 confirmed attorneys or claims professionals planning to attend the seminar and the following cocktail hour at Breakers in the Mohegan Sun Casino. Also, another 20 or so judges from all around the Northeastern Pennsylvania region expected to come to the cocktail hour.

The seminar begins with a 12:30 pm registration and will consist of a one hour Auto Law/Post-Koken Update by Attorneys Robert Panowicz and Daniel E. Cummins, a one hour Bad Faith Litigation Update by Attorneys Tim Lenahan and Suzanne Tighe, and a one hour ethics discussion on a variety of topics by an unbelievable panel of judges consisting of Third Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Thomas Vanaskie, Superior Court Judge Correale Stevens, Luzerne County President Judge Thomas Burke and Lackawanna County Judge Terrence Nealon.

There will also be an exciting raffle going on at the seminar designed to encourage the attendees to visit, again and again, the many table vendors who will be at the seminar to advertise their services. These vendors have paid a fee to secure a table to advertise at the event and it would be nice to see them get a number of visitors to make the event worthwhile to them as well.

Under the raffle, attendees will be permitted to submit their business card, or fill out a slip with their name and contact info to submit into a basket. At the end of the seminar, all of the entries will be gathered and winners will be chosen. The prizes include $50 Mohegan Sun gift cards (5 to give away), local Yankees baseball tickets, Phillies baseball tickets (2 sets to give away), and a $200 Mohegan Sun gift card. The Mohegan Sun gift cards can be used for the shops and restaurants and even to gamble at any time, including the night of the seminar.

You can still sign up to come to the seminar and cocktail hour if you'd like. As noted, it should be a great event to get your CLE credits and to network with fellow attorneys, claims professionals, and members of the state and federal judiciary. Please contact me for any more info on the event and how to reserve your spot. I can be reached at dancummins@comcast.net.

Saturday, August 14, 2010

Amicus Involvement Chronicled in National Email Newsletter for the Defense Research Institute

My recent work on the amicus position for the Pennsylvania Defense Institute in a defense win was recently chronicled in the The Voice, the national email newsletter of the Defense Research Institute.

The Defense Research Institute is a national organization I belong to made up of insurance defense counsel and claims professionals. It is a counterpart to the more local Pennsylvania Defense Institute in which I am a member of the Board of Directors.

The article can be viewed at the below link:

http://www.imakenews.com/dri/e_article001806004.cfm?x=bh7kWGt,bhNtT67r

Of course, past results are no guarantee of future results and each case must be handled on its own merits.

Sunday, August 8, 2010

Superior Court Judge Correale Stevens Added to Panel of Judges at Upcoming Mohegan Sun Seminar

On Thursday, August 5, 2010, I presented a Post-Koken Update at the Pennsylvania Defense Institute's CLE Seminar held at the Union League in Philadelphia. It was a nice turnout and a good networking event.

I now turn my attention to the final preparations for the upcoming August 18, 2010 CLE seminar being put on at the Mohegan Sun Casino in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania by the Pennsylvania Defense Institute and the Northeastern Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association.

One great development is that Superior Court Judge Correale Stevens has been added to the panel of judges set to speak during the ethics hour. Already on the panel is U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Thomas I. Vanaskie, Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas President Judge Thomas Burke, and Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas Judge Terrence R. Nealon.

I also note that there are approximately 20 judges from around the Northeastern Pennsylvania region who have indictated that they plan to attend the cocktail reception following the seminar. Also present will be some court administrators from different counties as well as claims professionals from various insurance companies (State Farm, Progressive, GEICO, Penn Millers Insurance Company, Guard Insurance, and Erie Insurance). It should be a great networking event for all who attend.

I also note that we currently have 13 table vendors set to appear at the seminar to advertise their litigation-related services. We will be running a raffle to encourage attendees to visit the table vendors. Every time an attendee visits a vendor (you can visit any one of them as many times at you want), the attendee can put their business card or provide their name and contact info on a slip of paper to be put into a drawing.

Presently, we have two sets of Phillies tickets, a set of local Yankees tickets, and 5 separate Mohegan Sun $50 gift cards to give away. The $50 Mohegan Sun gift cards can be used the night of the event at the shops and restaurants in the casino or even to gamble.

Here's the info on the upcoming seminar--hope to see you there:




THE PENNSYLVANIA DEFENSE INSTITUTE

and

THE NORTHEAST PENNSYLVANIA TRIAL LAWYERS ASSOCIATION


Proudly Present a Continuing Legal Education Program On

“CIVIL LITIGATION DEVELOPMENTS 2010”


at the


MOHEGAN SUN CASINO at POCONO DOWNS
WILKES-BARRE, PENNSYLVANIA


Wednesday August 18, 2010


1 p.m. to 5 p.m.

Cocktail Reception (5-7 p.m.) at Breakers in the Mohegan Sun


2 Substantive and 1 Ethics CLE Credit


Auto Law Update

Bad Faith Update

Panel Discussion with Members of the Federal and State Judiciary

New Citations of Note

Here's the new Westlaw citation for the post-Koken opinionn in the case of Firoozifard v. Krome and State Farm, 2010 WL 2666306, No. C-48-Civil-2009-14369 (Northampton Co. June 21, 2010 Beltrami, J.)(Court denied a third party tortfeasor defendant's motion to sever the third party liability claims from the UIM and UM claims; court also notes that insurance issues can be kept from jury and the task of applying third party credit to determine UIM award can be kept away from jury and handled by the court only after the verdict).




Also, here's the new Atlantic Second Reporter citation for the case of Gormley v. Edgar, 995 A.2d 1197 (Pa.Super. 2010)(The Superior Court panel, consisting of Judge Gantman, Judge Bowes, and Senior Judge Kelly ruled that, where the Plaintiff made allegations in the Complaint that she sustained “anxiety” as a result of the accident, which is a recognized mental health disorder, the Plaintiff put her mental health status at issue. As such, the Superior Court found that the trial court properly ruled that the defense was entitled to discovery of medical records pertaining to the Plaintiff’s pre-accident mental health treatment records.).