Thursday, July 8, 2010

A Few More Post-Koken Cases Brought to My Attention

Clinton County: Consolidation of Post-Koken claims favored

On June 3, 2010, Judge J. Michael Williamson, President Judge of the Clinton County Court of Common Pleas issued an Order, without opinion, in the post-Koken case of Wentzel v. Swinehart and State Farm, No. 375-10 CV (June 3, 2010, Williamson, P.J.) in which he denied both the UIM carrier’s Motion to Sever the Plaintiff’s bad faith claim and the request that the bad faith claim be stayed pending the resolution of the underinsured motorist action. In so ruling, Judge Williamson cited the Gunn v. Hartford, 2008 W.L. 6653070, GD 07-Civil-002888 (Alleg. Co. July 25, 2008, Wettick, J.).

I thank Attorney Stuart Hall, from Lock Haven, Pennsylvania for forwarding the case to my attention.

Anyone desiring a copy of the Wentzel Order may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.



Philadelphia County: Another decision by Judge Tereshko in favor of severance

In another post-Koken decision I have been made aware of, Judge Allan L. Tereshko issued an Order back on May 10, 2010 in the case of Thomas v. Titan Auto Ins., Nationwide Ins. Co., Jones, and Briel, March Term 2010 No. 03050 (May 10, 2010, Tereshko, J.). Consistent with his prior rulings in the same context (see Post-Koken Scorecard), Judge Tereshko granted the Petition to Sever filed by Titan/Nationwide the third party claims from the UIM claims and also granted the request that the case be therefore transferred to Montgomery County.

The case was transferred under Pa. R.C.P. 1006 (pertaining to proper venue) as the place of the accident was in Montgomery County and the Plaintiffs and the individual Defendants all resided in Montgomery County at the time of the motor vehicle accident. The decision to transfer was not based upon any forum selection clause as I have been informed that the Nationwide policy does not contain any form selection clause.

I have also been informed that the Plaintiff has filed an appeal from this decision. Currently, the case is still at a stage where the Plaintiff is required to file their concise statement of matters complained of on appeal.

I thank Attorney Victor Verbeke of the Conshohocken law firm of Snyder & Verbeke, in-house counsel for Nationwide, for forwarding this case to my attention.

Anyone desiring a copy of the Court Order issued in the Thomas case may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.


Montgomery County: forum selection clause upheld

On June 30, 2010, Judge Bernard A. Moore of the Montgomery County Court of Common Pleas issued an Order without Opinion granting the Preliminary Objections of Progressive Direct Insurance Company in the case of Dunne v. Closs, Progressive, et al., No. 09-38446 (Montg. Co. June 39, 2010, Moore, J.), which involved both a post-Koken severance issue and a claim of improper venue.

In Dunne, the Plaintiffs were allegedly injured in an accident that occurred in Northampton County. The Plaintiffs, who were residents of Monroe County, filed a lawsuit in Montgomery County, where the owner and operator tortfeasor defendants resided.

The lawsuit included negligence claims against the alleged tortfeasors and a claim for underinsured motorist (UIM) benefits against Plaintiffs' carrier, Progressive.

Both the alleged tortfeasors and the UIM carrier filed motions to sever the tort claims from the contract claims against the UIM carrier. Progressive also moved for enforcement of the forum selection clause contained in its policy. The Progressive forum selection clause required that any legal action brought against the carrier on behalf of an insured person must be brought in the state or federal court serving the county of residence of the insured (in this case, Monroe County).

In pursuing the forum selection clause argument, Progressive relied primarily on the case of O’Hara v. The First Liberty Insurance Corp., 984 A.2d 938 (Pa.Super. 2009), appeal denied, 995 A.2d 354 (Pa. May 3, 2010), for its position that its forum selection clause supercedes the venue rules.

Judge Moore granted Progressive's Preliminary Objections and dismissed all claims against Progressive without prejudice to the Plaintiffs' right to re-file in Monroe County or the Middle District.

A tip of the hat to the prevailing defense attorney, Chuck Stokes, Esquire of the Bethlehem/Scranton office of the Forry Ullman law firm for bringing this case to my attention.

Anyone desiring a copy of this Order may contact me at dancummins@comcast.net.


With the addition of these two decisions to the Post-Koken Scorecard, there are now at least 24 decisions in favor of the consolidation of post-Koken claims and 18 in favor of severance. The Post-Koken Scorecard may be viewed by scrolling down the right-hand column of the blog and clicking on the date under the "Post-Koken Scorecard" link.

Rumors Regarding Nominations to Middle District Federal Bench in Scranton

According to an article in today's Scranton"s The Times - Tribune by Borys Krawczeniuk, the names of Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas Judge Terrence R. Nealon, Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas Judge Carmen D. Minora, and Scranton attorney Robert D. Mariani will be submitted to President Obama as the choices of Senators Robert Casey and Arlen Spector to nominate to fill three openings on the bench of the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania.

The openings were created by Judge A. Richard Caputo and Judge James M. Munley taking senior status and Judge Thomas I. Vanaskie moving up to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals.

Here's a link to the article: http://thetimes-tribune.com/sources-nealon-minora-mariani-to-be-submitted-for-nomination-to-federal-bench-1.880953.

Pennsylvania Supreme Court: UM Carrier Must Show Prejudice to Deny for Late Notice of Claim

On July 6, 2010, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court handed down its decision in the case of Vanderhoff v. Harleysville Ins. Co., 2010 W.L. 2653247 (Pa. 2010, Baer, J.), in which it considered the issue of “Whether an insurance carrier should be required to prove prejudice relative to the late reporting to the carrier of an accident involving an unidentified vehicle when such accident was timely reported to law enforcement officials?”

In this uninsured motorist case, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that an insurance company is indeed required to prove prejudice relative to the late reporting to the carrier even where the accident involving an unidentified vehicle was timely reported to law enforcement officials.

The majority opinion by Justice Baer, which was joined by Chief Justice Castille, Justice Todd and Justice McCaffery, noted that the Court’s decision was controlled by the case of Brakemen v. Potomac, Ins. Co., 371 A.2d 193 (Pa. 1977) in which the Court held that, in order to deny uninsured motorist benefits, a carrier must establish prejudice resulting from the insured’s failure to provide notice.

The Supreme Court chose not to follow its more recent opinion in the case of State Farm Ins. Co. v. Foster, 889 A.2d 78 (Pa. 2005), which centered around the issue of the requirement that an accident in this context be reported to law enforcement officials within thirty days of the accident.

In Vanderhoff, the subject accident was allegedly reported to law enforcement officials within thirty days of the accident as required. However, the insurance company did not receive notice of the accident until about eight (8) months after the accident. The Supreme Court ruled that, since the accident was reported to law enforcement officials within the thirty day requirement, the case would be remanded back to the trial court to determine whether or not the insurance company can establish prejudice from its later receipt of notice.

Justice Eakin, joined by Justice Saylor, dissented under the argument that the Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law (75 Pa. C.S.A. §1702) does not contain a prejudice requirement in this context.

The prevailing Plaintiff's attorney in Vanderhoff was Attorney Brian Corcoran, a solo practitioner out of Kingston, PA.


A copy of the Vanderhoff majority opinion by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court can be viewed at this link:
http://www.pacourts.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-43-2008mo.pdf.


I thank Attorney Paul Oven of the Moosic office of Dougherty, Leventhal & Price for bringing this case to my attention.

Wednesday, July 7, 2010

Ciavarella and Conahan Pre-Trial Motions Denied

In two Orders handed down yesterday, July 6, 2010, Judge Edwin M. Kosik of the Federal Middle District Court denied pre-trial Motions filed by former Luzerne County judges Mark Ciavarella and Michael Conahan in the federal criminal case. The Order primarily affects Ciavarella since Conahan previously pled guilty.

In his Order, Judge Kosik denied Ciavarella's motion for a change of venue as well as the motion for Judge Kosik's recusal, i.e. a request that Judge Kosik not handle the case. The Order also denies Ciavarella's efforts to keep the taped recordings of the former judge and his co-Defendants from the jury.

Ciavarella awaits trial on the 48 criminal counts levied against him.

Here's a link to the July 6, 2010 Times Leader article by Terri Morgan-Besecker entitled "Judge Denies Motion To Dismiss Indictment Against Conahan and Ciavarella: http://www.timesleader.com/news/hottopics/judges/Judge-denies-motion-to-dismiss-indictment-againt-Conahan-and-Ciavarella.html


Here are links to Judge Kosik's Orders-

Memorandum and Order Denying Motion to Dismiss: http://media.timesleader.com/documents/Dismissal_ruling1.pdf


Memorandum and Order Denying Recusal Motion: http://media.kjonline.com/documents/Recusal_ruling1.pdf

Monday, July 5, 2010

Summary Judgment in Favor of Carrier in Recent Eastern District Court Bad Faith Decision

The Eastern District of Pennsylvania handed down a recent bad faith decision in the case of 3039 B Street Associates, Inc. v. Lexington Insurance Company, PICS Case No. 10-1892 (E.D. Pa. May 3, 2010, Robreno, J.).

In this case, the Plaintiffs' commercial real estate and personal property was damaged by water after a sprinkler pipe burst. The Plaintiffs alleged bad faith conduct on the part of the carrier and requested punitive damages based on defendant Lexington Insurance Company's delay in payment of its claims by conducting a protracted investigation. Lexington moved for summary judgment requesting that plaintiffs' claim be dismissed.

Applying Pennsylvania law, the court ruled that the Plaintiffs could not make a claim under the Unfair Insurance Practices Act since the statute does not provide for a private right of action.

In terms of the 42 Pa.S.C.A. §8371 bad faith claim, relying upon the factors in Polselli v. Nationwide Mut. Fire Ins. Co. , 23 F.3d 747 (3d Cir. 1994), the court found that the carrier had a reasonable basis for denying the claim. The policy set out a procedure for adjusting claims, which was followed by the carrier. The parties were in close communication from the date the claim was submitted and the carrier was responsive to the insured's inquiries.

The court also noted that the Plaintiffs failed to provide defendant with information material to the satisfaction of their claim. Plaintiffs' did not file a proof of loss within the 30 days provided in the policy; rather, four months passed until the proof of loss was submitted. The court also noted that the carrier acted promptly after this information was received.

Believing the carrier had acted reasonably in investigating the claim, the court granted the carrier's summary judgment motion and dismissed the claims presented.

Latest Article - Consolidation vs. Severance Issue in Post-Koken Cases

The below article of mine originally appeared in the June 29, 2010 edition of the Pennsylvania Law Weekly, a statewide legal news publication.(c) 2010 Incisive Media US Properties, LLC. Further duplication without permission is prohibited. All rights reserved. Please contact the author for permission to reprint or duplicate.



A Growing Need for Guidance
Trial courts struggle with consolidation vs. severance issue in post-Koken cases


by


Daniel E. Cummins
Pennsylvania Law Weekly/The Legal Intelligencer
June 29, 2010

The gale-force winds of change brought on by "Hurricane Koken" continue to wreak havoc in the common pleas courts across the state as trial court judges struggle, without any appellate guidance, to determine whether a variety of post- Koken automobile accident litigation claims should proceed in a consolidated fashion under one caption.

This first part of a two-part column will review those "ordinary" post- Koken cases involving the issue of whether the third party claims against the responsible party defendant may proceed to a jury in a consolidated fashion with the companion underinsured or uninsured motorists benefits claims against the injured party's own automobile insurance carrier.

In next month's column, the trial courts' struggles over the same issue in post- Koken cases that involve bad faith claims will be analyzed.

In all scenarios involving this consolidation versus severance issue, there is a growing split of authority in Pennsylvania trial courts that is creating an increasing need for appellate guidance.

In fact, as noted below, there are even splits of authority within some county common pleas courts. This lack of a consistent common law on the issue leaves the bar and trial court judges with great uncertainty on the issue.

The Initial Preference

It has been about five years since the automobile accident litigation landscape was changed by a 2005 state Supreme Court case, Insurance Federation of Pennsylvania v. Commonwealth, Department of Insurance (Koken).

In Koken , the high court ruled for the first time that automobile insurance carriers were not required to include arbitration clauses in their policies for the resolution of disputed uninsured and underinsured motorist benefits claims.

Thereafter, many carriers got rid of the arbitration clauses in their policies, leaving UIM and UM claims to be litigated by way of lawsuits filed in the trial courts.

One of the first issues that repeatedly came to the attention of the trial courts, typically by way of preliminary objections, was whether these new UIM or UM claims could be pursued in the same lawsuits and under the same captions as the third party claims against the defendant tortfeasors who caused the accidents.

As noted in my November 2009 article on this topic, "Two Roads Diverged," the first number of trial court judges to address this issue ruled in favor of allowing for the consolidation of these UIM and third party claims. By November 2009, there were at least 15 trial court decisions addressing the issue, all of which had ruled, or suggested they would rule, in favor of keeping these claims together under one caption to proceed to a jury trial in a consolidated fashion.

Concisely, these initial decisions were handed down in Lackawanna, Luzerne, Pike, Lehigh, Dauphin, Beaver, Allegheny and Philadelphia counties.

Among those judges who were the first to hand down opinions on this issue were Lackawanna County Common Pleas Court Judge Carmen Minora and Allegheny County Common Pleas Court Judge R. Stanton Wettick.

The common and overriding rationale of the consolidation decisions is that the claims arising out of the same "transaction or occurrence," i.e the same motor vehicle accident, should be tried together as a means of furthering the interests of judicial economy for the already overburdened trial courts. Another factor noted is the avoidance of piecemeal litigation with the possibility of inconsistent verdicts.

These post- Koken claims arising out of a single accident have been allowed to stay together under the permissive joinder of actions provision found in the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure at Rule 2229 or, in the alternative, under Rule 213(a) which allows for the consolidation of actions arising out of the same occurrence.

The judges in favor of consolidation seem unfazed by the fact that keeping the third party liability claims together with the UM/UIM claims will bring the topic of "insurance" in front of the jury at trial.

Although Pennsylvania Rule of Evidence 411 and its supporting caselaw precludes the mentioning of any form of insurance at personal injury trials, these judges have generally noted that the statute precluding a mention of "insurance" at trial expressly provides that insurance issues may be mentioned at trial where that topic may be relevant. Here, the mentioning of "insurance" is relevant to the litigation of the uninsured or underinsured motorist claim, the judges ruled.

Since those initial decisions, however, the storm has shifted course.

Other trial court judges, some of whom are even members of the bench in the aforementioned counties, have ruled in favor of severing the third party liability claims from the UM/UIM claims.

A Run The Other Way

Led by two Butler County Common Pleas judges, S. Michael Yeager and Marilyn J. Horan, judges who support the severing third party liability claims from UM/UIM claims have created run of decisions in favor of their rulings.

Yeager and Horan appear to have written the first opinions in favor of severance. Other judges, from York and Adams counties, have followed suit.

The main rationale put forth in those severance decisions is primarily that evidence of "insurance" is not admissible in personal injury civil litigation matters under Pa.R.E. 411. These courts have also referred to Pa.R.E. 403, which allows a trial court to preclude relevant evidence "if its probative value is outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice, confusion of the issues, or misleading the jury…."

The fact that the third party tortfeasor defendant may be unduly prejudice by having the UM/UIM insurance company as a co-defendant in front of a jury in violation of the Rules of Evidence seems to be the main reasoning of the courts in favor of severing the claims for the protection of the tortfeasor's right to a fair trial.

Some of the courts in favor of severance have also noted that the act of severing and staying the UM/UIM claim pending the resolution of the third party liability claim furthers the interest of judicial economy.

For example, in those cases where the jury comes back with a verdict in the liability lawsuit that is less than the tortfeasor's liability policy limits, there would be no need to litigate the UIM claim.

In total, there have been at least 16 decisions in favor of severance and at least 22 decisions in favor of consolidation.

This split of authority on the consolidation versus severance of post- Koken cases cries out for appellate guidance to bring certainty on the issue to the bench and bar.

Further compounding the need for appellate guidance on this issue is the fact that there are now splits of authority in a few counties. In both Lackawanna County and Philadelphia, for example, there have been decisions handed down on both sides of the issue.

A Little Help Here?

While the need for appellate guidance on this issue is great, the likelihood that such appellate guidance may be forthcoming anytime soon is not so great.

In order to get to the Superior Court to address the consolidation versus severance issue, which is typically raised by way of preliminary objections, permission to appeal on an interlocutory basis must be secured by the litigants from the trial court.

Understandably, most plaintiffs attorneys will not want to delay their client's claim for a year or more in order to take the case to the appellate arena. Similarly, defense counsel seeking permission to pursue such an appeal have an uphill battle in securing permission from trial court judges who do not want to delay an injured party's recovery or want cases languishing on their docket.

The only other way this issue might go up the appellate ladder is on the merits after a trial and on an appeal from post-trial motions. With many post- Koken cases still only in discovery, the chances for this type of review on appeal remains far off.

Therefore, until appellate guidance on this issue is secured, members of both sides of the motor vehicle accident bar will have to weather the storm on a county by county basis.

To reiterate, there are currently at least 22 decisions in favor of the consolidation of these claims with those decisions coming out of Lackawanna, Luzerne, Pike, Lehigh, Dauphin, Beaver, Allegheny, Philadelphia and Northampton counties. There are now at least 16 decisions in favor of the severance of claims with those decisions coming out of Butler, York, Adams, Lackawanna and Philadelphia counties.

Hopefully, one wise trial court judge will soon grant a party permission to file an interlocutory appeal on the consolidation versus severance issue in post- Koken cases so that this important issue can be addressed and settled by the Superior Court and, perhaps, even the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, once and for all.

Daniel E. Cummins is a partner and civil litigator with the Scranton law firm of Foley, Cognetti, Comerford, Cimini & Cummins. He handles insurance defense matters all across Northeastern Pennsylvania as far west as Williamsport, PA, as far north as the New York border, as far east as the New Jersey border, and as far south as the Easton - Allentown - Jim Thorpe line of towns (i.e. Northampton, Lehigh, and Carbon Counties). His civil litigation blog, "Tort Talk," may be viewed at www.torttalk.com. It features a "Post-Koken Scorecard," which provides a synopsis of trial court post-Koken decisions uncovered to date.

Hoping You Can Take A Few Moments to Put a Plug in For Tort Talk

I have been advised by the LexisNexis Insurance Law Community that Tort Talk is one of the nominated candidates for the LexisNexis Top 50 Insurance Blogs of 2009.

I understand that comments in support of Tort Talk can be made up through July 9, 2010 when the comment period closes. Thereafter, with input from the LexisNexis Insurance Law Center Advisory Board, LexisNexis will select the Insurance Law Community's Top 50 Insurance Blogs for 2009. After the Top 50 Insurance Blog honorees are announced, LexisNexis will ask its Community to vote for Top Insurance Blog of the Year.

If you are willing and able, I am hoping you might be able to take a few moments to register at LexisNexis (it's free and quick) and post a comment in favor of Tort Talk if you deem it worthy of such commentary--these plugs may assist Tort Talk in securing more votes and possibly reaching the Top 50 list. Here's the link to post your comment(s): http://www.lexisnexis.com/Community/insurancelaw/blogs/topblogs/archive/2010/06/22/insurance-law-community-s-top-50-insurance-blogs-for-2009.aspx


Thanks very much--I really appreciate it.